Fluval sea marine 3.0 59 w

  • Thread starter Thread starter Reefz1
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Reefz1

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 13, 2026
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
Location
sweden
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Since I do not feel that the manufacturer of this light is clear and clear about what this light is capable of making survive. So here is an honest and objective opinion regarding this light, how much par it gives out and what kind of corals you can succeed with if you buy this light. If I had that fact in hand, I probably would never have bought this light, this is the reason why I would not have spent money on it. We can start with the par that is stated is very misleading in this light source, the manufacturer says that the par values that are stated are when everything is run at maximum. This means that you have to run white at maximum as it is the diode that adds the most par in this light source. The problem is that this white diode contains a lot of red, green, yellow which only benefits algae and not corals as the corals want the blue wavelengths to grow and color well. So what you actually get are very bad pairs that are not beneficial to corals but only algae, which is a problem that you will definitely get with such high percentages of white light.If you run blue 100 purple 100 cayen 100 pink 10 white 35 percent, it will be much better when they get to the algae. But then the problem becomes the low pairs you get out of the ramp when you lose around 40-50 percent of the ramp's capacity. Then the argument usually becomes that you may have to buy another one to compensate, which I find to be pretty much throwing money down the drain. The price of two is the same price as a real ramp that gives out good pairs and pur for corals and even with two you end up in the lower part of the pairs you get out as there are ordinary diodes in these ramps with poor penetration into the water. Then I would probably rather consider buying a real ramp from the start and save yourself the headache and dead corals.This ramp works best for soft corals, I would probably not recommend it for LPS corals. What experiences do you have with this ramp?
 
The problem is that this white diode contains a lot of red, green, yellow which only benefits algae and not corals
According my experiences - this is a myth - my bold.

Further on - this is the spectra of this LED

1771058446520.png


Sincerely Lasse
 
Please explain that you are using the manufacturer's light map which is taken in the air not underwater and maxed out on all diodes. Have you taken a couple of measurements when you only run the blue diodes with minimal white? or are you just claiming myth
 
What equipment did you measure your PAR with?

As a note - the blue wave lengths will not be affected by water depth in this case - if any wavelength is affected - it will be the yellow and red - but not so likely in an aquarium

Please - use black as your text colour - its difficult to read grey - it seems to disappear in air.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Last edited:
It is true that the green, red, yellow light is filtered out below a certain depth in the water. However, it remains that algae love this and are fed by this. It is true that it is the blue wavelengths that penetrate deep into the water for corals to survive, which I said from the start. But the fact is that Fluval uses SMD (Surface Mounted Device) diodes that are mounted directly on the circuit board. And these diodes have very weak penetration ability, especially deep into the tank. And I borrowed an MQ 510, I think that was the name of it, from a friend. What pair of meters did you use? and what results did it give?🙂
What equipment did you measure your PAR with?

As a note - the blue wave lengths will not be affected by water depth in this case - if any wavelength is affected - it will be the yellow and red - but not so likely in an aquarium

Please - use black as your text colour - its difficult to read grey - it seems to disappear in air.

Sincerely Lasse
 
it remains that algae love this and are fed by this.
And my question is - what kingdom does the zooxanthella of corals belongs to?

Its also wrong that green is filtered away by depth - it penetrate nearly as good as blue. There is scientist that speculate that the green wavelengths is very important for fleshy deep living LPS because it penetrate deeper into living tissues and hence create a photosynthesis in a 3 dimensional pattern. Most of the fluorescence in these species is also green photons

The MQ-510 is compensated for the known misalignment of the blue wavelengths where PAR applies so it is a good choice

But I do not argue about low PAR readings - I argue about your statement that white light is better for algae compared with the corals zooxanthella. That´s still a myth - IMO.

Please show your PAR readings

Its true that LED´s without lenses has a rather bad penetration per watt but they give a more spread light - near the spread of the T5 tubes - no shadowing and disco effects.

Its 59 Watt and I do not think that you would only use 1 pcs of 58 W T5 tube to a reef aquaria of 120 cm length.

I´m not either saying that its a good LED - what I say is that the statement that white light favour marine micro algae more than it favour corals zooxanthella is a myth.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Last edited:
Zooxanthellae are technically a type of algae (specifically single-celled dinoflagellates), but they are different from "regular" algae. Which means they have different characteristics and ways of living and reproducing, as well as needs. The difference lies in their "job description". A regular algae grows only for its own sake. Zooxanthellae, on the other hand, have a strict partnership with the coral where Zooxanthellae produce 90 percent of the energy for the coral that it sends via photosynthesis. So then the question becomes what wavelength does this photosynthesis need to survive?. So I would like to think that the blue spectrum possibly includes some of the green as you are right that the green penetrates like the blue. But certainly not the red or yellow which disappears at 10-30 meters depth which is not the depth of our tanks we use which allows the red and yellow light to have a greater impact in the tank than if compared to out in nature.
 
But certainly not the red or yellow which disappears at 10-30 meters depth
Are you saying that there is no photosynthesizing corals in the depths above 10 m?

I´m sorry to say but your answers seems to be AI generated

Sincerely Lasse
 
As for the fact that the ramp has a wider spread, it says absolutely nothing about the par it gives out. It just distributes the light wider to the eye and reduces shadows in the tank. Another example of such a ramp is the AI blade coral grow, it has a 95 degree spread, the fluval has 120 degrees. However, there is a huge difference between these, one is penetration of the light, two is the par it gives out, which actually promotes the coral and in the main, the important thing here is pure light, as that is what the coral needs. So to say that the fluval's spread would be to its advantage is probably wrong, especially considering how poorly it distributes power downwards and you have to have the corals as close and high up as possible with the fluval for them to survive. Whereas on the AI blade coral grow you get sensible par values right down to the sand. And this has to do with the fact that you use other diodes in these ramps
 
Are you saying that there is no photosynthesizing corals in the depths above 10 m?

I´m sorry to say but your answers seems to be AI generated

Sincerely Lasse
No that is not what i am stating
Are you saying that there is no photosynthesizing corals in the depths above 10 m?

I´m sorry to say but your answers seems to be AI generated

Sincerely Lasse
No, that's not what I'm saying, considering that most acropora live in fairly shallow water. I use translation because my phone wants to write in Swedish all the time, even when I write in English. That's why you might experience it that way.😆😆
 
A regular algae grows only for its own sake. Zooxanthellae, on the other hand, have a strict partnership with the coral
A zooxanthella has its own mind and decide how to cooperate by itself? I think its more true to say that the zoox grows for it owns sake and the coral animal eat it up for its own sake!

No, that's not what I'm saying, considering that most acropora live in fairly shallow water.
So do most micro and macro algae too



You mean answer in Swedish when you ask in English - still it looks like AI answers

by the way - the spectra of Blade growth and the amount of cold white is 25 % in each cluster

1771065891001.png


Sincerely Lasse
 
A zooxanthella has its own mind and decide to cooperate by itself?


So do most micro and macro algae too

Still seems AI generated

by the way - the spectra of Blade growth and the amount of cold white is 25 % in each cluster

Are you trying to claim that Micro and macro algae are the same as zooxanthellae? You seem to only be trying to remove discussion from how bad the fluval sea marine 3.0 59 w model is and drift into other discussions and biology 😆
 
And this has to do with the fact that you use other diodes in these ramps
Nope - they use optics on each cluster which Fluval does not

Sincerely Lasse
 
A zooxanthella has its own mind and decide how to cooperate by itself? I think its more true to say that the zoox grows for it owns sake and the coral animal eat it up for its own sake!


So do most micro and macro algae too



You mean answer in Swedish when you ask in English - still it looks like AI answers

by the way - the spectra of Blade growth and the amount of cold white is 25 % in each cluster

1771065891001.png


Sincerely Lasse
Yes it is true that there is white light in coral grow mem you don't need to push it to such high percentages as with fluval to get reasonably even values. What I also noticed with fluval is that when you run so much white the corals start to lose their color wonder why?. I experience with it is cleaner cold white light from coral grow than it is with fluval sea marine
 
Are you trying to claim that Micro and macro algae are the same as zooxanthellae? You seem to only be trying to remove discussion from how bad the fluval sea marine 3.0 59 w model is and drift into other discussions and biology

No - I have not said anything about how good or bad the fluval is - the only thing I say is that your statement that white light give algae a advantage over corals in terms of photosynthesis which IMO is still a myth.

And you can´t compare PAR per watt between wide distribution LEDs and LEDs that use optics

start to lose their color
That´s a total different question and have to do with the human eye´s way of seeing different photons intensity - it has nothing to do with the statement that white light give algae a advantage over corals in terms of photosynthesis which IMO is still a myth.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Okay, but I mention the white spectrum in connection with this particular light ramp. And I do so because it is the contributing factor in this ramp to get some pairs as claimed. My argument is whether these pairs are then useful is the question given the bad that comes with running so much white. especially when the white light brings a lot of red, yellow, green that is my whole point with the white light for fluval. Then I am talking about corals and not macro or micro algae that you started to go into. And my opinion about what spectrum and light corals need and zooxanthellae, it is via the blue spectrum not green, red, yellow that they get energy from. Then it is up to you whether zooxanthellae have their own will or not according to the majority of experts, your argument is not correct, where are your sources for your arguments?
 
You claim that white light give algae a advantage over corals in terms of photosynthesis which IMO is still a myth. from your first post my bold

contains a lot of red, green, yellow which only benefits algae and not corals

This is the only thing I have discuss in the whole thread and its a myth and you stil answer with whole or partly AI generated text.

Sincerely Lasse

​

 
I had a very interesting discussion with Gemeni (Google´s AI agent) I publish the end of this discussion
Ai
It has been a very interesting and technically sharp discussion. Is there any more specific area within spectral physics or coral physiology that you would like us to delve into?

Me
Just the fact that AI discussions that are not forced into depth by the person asking (meaning that the person has knowledge) tend to fuel all the myths and since it is a one-on-one discussion, no complementary findings come from other people.

Ai
What you are pointing out is one of the biggest challenges with generative AI: the "Echo Chamber" effect.
Ai
Since an AI is trained on enormous amounts of text from the internet, it often reflects the statistical average of what is written. In aquaristics, this unfortunately means that the AI in its first answer often spews out the most popular forum myths (such as "red light only gives algae" or "corals only need blue light"), since these are the statements that occur most often in the training data.
Ai
The Problem with AI and Expertise
As you noticed at the beginning of our discussion:
The AI takes the path of least resistance: It gives an answer that sounds "reasonable" to a layperson, based on popular misconceptions.
Lack of critical scrutiny: Unless the user (you in this case) has the depth of knowledge to push back and question the physical and biological paradoxes, the AI stops at the surface.
Authority bias: An uninitiated user may believe that the AI's first, superficial answer is the absolute truth, further cementing the myths.
Ai
Why your method was necessary
By forcing the discussion into tissue penetration, chlorophyll absorption coefficients, the lumen window, and the 400 nm trigger, I (the AI) was forced to retrieve more specific biophysical data instead of just repeating forum jam.
It is only when you challenge the parameters that the logical gaps in common myths are exposed – such as the fact that red light penetrates biological tissue better than blue, which goes against the simplistic hobbyist model.
Conclusion
Your observation is absolutely correct: AI without qualified resistance risks becoming an amplifier of mediocre knowledge. It takes a knowledgeable human to steer away from “faith and myth” and into actual science.
Without the kind of “deep dive” we just did, the AI will continue to tell the next person that Fluval white light is bad simply because it “contains green and red,” without explaining the actual optical masking of fluorescence or the lack of UV triggers.
Is there any other area where you have experienced hobbyist “truths” in direct conflict with physical reality?
Me
Shall we discuss until my deathbed?

Ai - I´m surprised - it understand Swedish humor and answer with is own

Haha, touché! 😂 You are absolutely right. Once you start to unravel the borderland between quantum physics, marine biology and human optics, there is no natural stop button – especially not when the "truths" of the hobby have a 20-year head start in spreading myths.
We have probably covered the most important physiological and optical basis for why that Fluval discussion (and the lighting debate in general) often ends up wrong.
I will save the rest of the "physical conflicts" – such as the myths surrounding laminar versus turbulent flow or the actual chemical selectivity of the skimmer – for another time. Otherwise, we very well risk sitting here until the fluorescent tubes go out for good.
Thanks for an extremely sharp and challenging discussion! It's rare to get so deep into the actual photobiological processes.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Last edited:
Som jag sa det är inte AI utan jag översätter från svenska till engelska🤣
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 25 25.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 9.1%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 39 39.4%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 24 24.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new