Hammer Upset?

Mike628

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 7, 2014
Messages
898
Reaction score
336
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello everyone. Having some issues with hammers. Had one and was doing great. It was happy and had full extension. Added a second and it was doing just as good as the first one. Tentacles looked full and very open and now they are partially retracted and skinny. Noticed vermetid snails and yesterday and figured that might be an issue. I pulled both, scraped them, dipped in seachem reef dip again and put them back in the tank. Any help is appreciated. I’ve also attached my lighting schedule as well. (Also looks like my one zoa that I have is not happy as well)
20261116_173031_500EFEB7-F0F0-43A2-8B41-BE77351C2917.png


20261116_173123_A686B184-D5F6-41A6-9032-D22E7B5EB3F6.png
 
Yes AI Prime 16 HD. I honestly couldn’t figure out what it needed to be at. I’ve searched and searched online but haven’t found anything for settings. Tank is an 18” x 18” cube. Light mounted 9” from water surface.
 
IMO your light should be at 70%+. A prime at 30% isn't going to grow anything.
I have AI Prime on a 15 gallon softie tank (10" depth), mostly mushrooms and zoa's, set at 80% for 10 hours per day. I have a jeaboa 60 watt light on a 10 gallon (10" depth) set at 75%.
Turn your light up since your tank is 18" deep, but depending how long you have had it like that, you might need to do it slow. IF you just added the corals then I would just turn the light up quickly, if they have been there a while and acclimated to that low light then you'll need to dial up slow, like 10% weekly or something, know what I mean.
I would start with fixing the light to the proper setting then see how everything reacts before making any other changes. Just my 2 cents
Also as FYI, if you go to the AI Prime website, you can download different pre-set schedules that were created by experts.
good luck
 
IMO your light should be at 70%+. A prime at 30% isn't going to grow anything.
I have AI Prime on a 15 gallon softie tank (10" depth), mostly mushrooms and zoa's, set at 80% for 10 hours per day. I have a jeaboa 60 watt light on a 10 gallon (10" depth) set at 75%.
Turn your light up since your tank is 18" deep, but depending how long you have had it like that, you might need to do it slow. IF you just added the corals then I would just turn the light up quickly, if they have been there a while and acclimated to that low light then you'll need to dial up slow, like 10% weekly or something, know what I mean.
I would start with fixing the light to the proper setting then see how everything reacts before making any other changes. Just my 2 cents
Also as FYI, if you go to the AI Prime website, you can download different pre-set schedules that were created by experts.
good luck

Good to know…the green hammer has been there a little over a week and the gold is new as of Saturday. I found the BRS video and suggested settings for an 18” X 18” cube. Can I dial it up then just set acclimation mode to run for 30 days? I’ve attached a photo of their suggested parameters. How do these numbers look? I’m new to this light, switched from a Kessil that burnt out on me. My biggest concern and the reason for my caution was due to hearing how these lenses burn with high UV and Violet spectrums.
20261116_193515_83376349-7947-4223-9F7E-118B45907550.png
 
IMO those settings are too high. Do a quick google search about AI Prime melted lenses, it seems to be a common problem with folks that run the lights over 100%. Even this forum has many threads on the subject if you do a search. I’ve had my prime for 5 years in December going on to the 6th year in Jan, so you won’t have an issue if you keep it under 90% ish for longevity of the light IMO. And frankly it’s a good light for your size tank and I feel no need to run it that high, I think 85% or 90% will get you the results you want. That’s just my 2 cents but do more googling, there are AI Prime forums on Facebook, and the AI Prime website has a lot more info and I think also a AI Prime sub forum if I remember.
 
IMO those settings are too high. Do a quick google search about AI Prime melted lenses, it seems to be a common problem with folks that run the lights over 100%. Even this forum has many threads on the subject if you do a search. I’ve had my prime for 5 years in December going on to the 6th year in Jan, so you won’t have an issue if you keep it under 90% ish for longevity of the light IMO. And frankly it’s a good light for your size tank and I feel no need to run it that high, I think 85% or 90% will get you the results you want. That’s just my 2 cents but do more googling, there are AI Prime forums on Facebook, and the AI Prime website has a lot more info and I think also a AI Prime sub forum if I remember.

I just feel like all my searches have turned up with nothing. Possible I’m not looking in the right places…I’ll continue the search. If you don’t mind me asking what are your settings at on your tank and what size tank? Hammers are also splitting so that might be part of the problem? Also if this is any help I’ve listed my parameters below.

1.026 salinity
0 ppm ammonia and nitrite
30 ppm nitrate
7.8 ph
400 ppm calcium
7.3 dkh
1640 ppm magnesium (I think I over titrated)
 
Last edited:
I just feel like all my searches have turned up with nothing. Possible I’m not looking in the right places…I’ll continue the search. If you don’t mind me asking what are your settings at on your tank and what size tank? Hammers are also splitting so that might be part of the problem? Also if this is any help I’ve listed my parameters below.

1.026 salinity
0 ppm ammonia and nitrite
30 ppm nitrate
7.8 ph
400 ppm calcium
7.3 dkh
1640 ppm magnesium (I think I over titrated)
Do you have an LFS that would let you borrow a PAR meter? 30% I agree seems low on a 55W light. I run a 65W on my 15”x15”x15” and always had it 80-90% (before I moved tanks it had hammers). Hard to use just a one size fits all setting though so a meter helps.

I am wondering about the zoas though. I would have thought if lighting was too low they would be more extended. Do they look like they are reaching when they open? Makes me wonder if there is another culprit too.
 
Unfortunately none of my LFS have a par meter as far as I know. When the zoas were open they looked like they were reaching.
 
Unfortunately none of my LFS have a par meter as far as I know. When the zoas were open they looked like they were reaching.
Then lighting is probably going to be the answer imo. I personally don’t think I’d change it over 30 days continuously, but that’s just me. I’d bump it in increments and give it a couple days to see how they react then bump it again until you reach your target. If any of the bumps causes them to get upset you can dial it back to your last point.
 
Unfortunately none of my LFS have a par meter as far as I know. When the zoas were open they looked like they were reaching.
Then lighting is probably going to be the answer imo. I personally don’t think I’d change it over 30 days continuously, but that’s just me. I’d bump it in increments and give it a couple days to see how they react then bump it again until you reach your target. If any of the bumps causes them to get upset you can dial it back to your last point.
Okay that’s a good idea. I can try that and see how it goes
 
I might of missed it but what is your Phos at? Temp as well?

Temp is 78°. It fluctuates from 77° and 79° but stays pretty consistent at 78°. I do not have a test for phosphates yet. I’m going to try and snag a salifert kit tomorrow from one of my LFS.
 
Temp is 78°. It fluctuates from 77° and 79° but stays pretty consistent at 78°. I do not have a test for phosphates yet. I’m going to try and snag a salifert kit tomorrow from one of my LFS.
I honestly dont think its your lighting. Especially the hammers staying closed up due to low light??? I bet your phos is crazy high or possibly 00. Do you run any phos removal?
 
hmm you pulled them out scraped and dipped...
tbh vermetids are the least you should be concern about atm.

What dip and method did you use? what portion of the hammers did you scrape? hopefully not at the top where the flesh are.

also, id bring up the alk to an 8 and crank up your lights.
 
Temp is 78°. It fluctuates from 77° and 79° but stays pretty consistent at 78°. I do not have a test for phosphates yet. I’m going to try and snag a salifert kit tomorrow from one of my LFS.
I honestly dont think its your lighting. Especially the hammers staying closed up due to low light??? I bet your phos is crazy high or possibly 00. Do you run any phos removal?
I do not run any remover. I am going to stop today and see if I can get a test kit on my way home. I will update test results tonight.
 
hmm you pulled them out scraped and dipped...
tbh vermetids are the least you should be concern about atm.

What dip and method did you use? what portion of the hammers did you scrape? hopefully not at the top where the flesh are.

also, id bring up the alk to an 8 and crank up your lights.

I did a 15 minute dip with seachem reef dip. I only scraped the skeleton and frag plugs, I made sure to stay away from the flesh bands.

Do I need to raise alk, ph, or both? I know they go hand in hand. I can turn the lights up as well I just do not want to shock the corals and bleach them.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT KIND OF REEFING DEAL ARE YOU HOPING TO PICK UP THIS BLACK FRIDAY?

  • A whole new aquarium or complete system

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Lighting, pumps, or other major equipment

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Controllers, testing, dosing, or automation gear

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Dry goods and restocks, like salt, media, or food

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Corals! Must...Have...CORALS!!!

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Fish or other livestock

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Rock, sand, or other aquascaping supplies

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • I’m browsing, but don’t have a specific target

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • I’m not shopping for reef deals this year

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 1 7.7%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new