HELP ME .... choose the best functional Heater(s)

  • Thread starter Thread starter ZoWhat
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
There are



Nothing further from truth!

There is nothing to break/wear out on outlets numbered 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 on an EB8 because there is nothing mechanical. As long as they are not overloaded I have not had one fail in about 18 years that I've been on APEX. These outlets are reated for 5A, I keep them at or below 300W or less than 3Amps.

Now the EB832 is a different beast althogether with plenty of its own problems, besides the mickey mouse design.

Here is my observation tank. No failure to report and none expected either, not from an EB8. Look at the number of clicks - notice the temp is within .1 degree from desired temp in either direction.

Week

1762539540182.png


Day

1762539637230.png
Good to know! I have heard of lots of EB832 failing from over use and a search shows that's not uncommon. I run the old school EB4/8s myself
 
Good to know! I have heard of lots of EB832 failing from over use and a search shows that's not uncommon. I run the old school EB4/8s myself

Yes, the EB832 is relay-based and has had its share of issues. I've been staying away from these all together and have about a dozen of EB4/EB8s in use. Each type has its own best use scenario and I have never had any strip or outlet failure.

Too bad they've been discontinued but I managed to pile on bunch of brand new spares in case of need to expand.

I'm sure Neptune could easily sell a batch of new EB8s/EB4s if they decided to produce them but I suspect EB832 are more of a gravy item for them because of price difference and probably cost difference on production end.
 
I run 3 Aqua Logic controllers. 2 with brs and 1 with an eheim.
Next system will be another.
20251108_074614.jpg

Link?

ive looked into Aqua Logic via Google but there's no clear Product Page with prices and specifications
 
Ranco controllers are the gold standard for reliability. They do use mechanical relays for turning current on and off, but are rated for about 8 amps. You can buy the single stage units brand new for about $100 (heating or cooling control but not both), or the 2 stage for heating and cooling for less than $200. The caveat is that they come unwired with no power cord or anything. So you will need to install an adequate power cord to plug into 120vac AND either a female output cord(s) or better yet a box for output receptacles, you will also have to heat shrink the temp probe and fill the open end with silicone to make it salt water safe. It's not difficult but a basic understanding of electrical wiring is necessary.

The AquaLogic units everyone is mentioning come prewired but typically cost more.

These units do not have any kind of wifi connection so no way of alerting the user of a malfunction. They will display error codes on the screen if there is an internal malfunction, it's usually the temp probe that has failed, but those are easily sourced locally and cheap enough that a spare can be kept for such an event. They also only have display resolution to the degree with no tenths, I'm certain the resolution is in the logic but just not displayed. It was probably deemed not necessary due to their intended usage 🤷‍♂️

I would caution against plugging a Ranco into your Apex for redundancy, the Ranco's relays are normally open and in the event of failure will not cause your heater to stay on. The Ranco is likely more reliable than the Apex anyways so letting the Apex control the Ranco would be doing yourself a dis-service.

I don't own one, but I read that InkBirds do have their share of failures which is expected at the price point they are sold at. They do have some nice features though.

For the physical heater elements, I prefer an Eheim Jager (decades ago they were called Ebo-Jager). They're German, have a 3 year warranty and they just plain work well. But never just 1 heater, always split it up between 2 or more. Finnex heating elements are also very decent. The titanium units that BRS markets have great specs but have a poor track record for reliability from what I read, so buy at your own risk. Like return pumps and LED fixtures, I ALWAYS keep a new spare heater on hand.

This is my 2 stage unit that I added a receptacle box to, 2 for heaters and 2 for cooling (fans etc), yes it should be mounted vertically so water doesn't get into it, lol.

IMG_1918.jpeg

And this is my other that is similar to the AquaLogic branded Rancos that have power cords prewired. I got this one with a Trade Winds chiller but I use it for the heaters instead.

IMG_1920.jpeg



Thanks for reading!
 
Last edited:
I tried to EDIT my long post above but I missed the edit window.

The AquaLogic units do come with a titanium encased temp probe which is a really nice feature. That titanium encased temp probe is near $100 all by itself, rightly so I suppose. Their power cord pass throughs use water tight grommets to keep the internals free of moisture. I've never had an issue with any of mine that don't have the watertight pass throughs but for some installations it might be worthwhile.
 
I agree with @nursedude I have the Innovative Marine Helios set up. Quality is off the charts and the control is precise and quick.
 
I’ve had this one for just over one year in use
My LFS owner suggest I replace it every year
Wondering if that’s necessary??
IMG_7313.jpeg
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new