Day 86 - Pico being broken down, and summary
Over here in the UK we have had some colder weather, and temperatures in the house at night have dropped down to 17c (62f) and I have been seeing for 2 days in a row the temperature drop into the high 23's and the power draw is at 100% heating the whole time, showing the 3.75W of heating is not coping. It is delivering around +6.5c.
With this in mind, the Yellow Goby has been moved to my Fluval Flex and the corals are being moved after this update. I could run the heating higher, but this is a situation I expect the setup to be able to deal with, and with a new board just shipped, I think this is a good stage to call it on this test and start gearing up for the next one.
So what have I learnt in this 86 day test?
(1) Pico reef aquariums can be made to have a stable temperature, power permitting
The setup was super stable with a +/-0.2c tolerance up until this colder weather where it just doesn't have enough power to keep up. It also highlights how a power cut would impact a small Pico quickly, so a Addition UPS will be considered as a option moving forwards.
(2) Yellow goby was happy in this size tank
I know many people really stick there nose up, but he fattened up and was happy in this tank the whole time. Now in a Fluval Flex 34L between tests on his own. I used the fish size guide from Jay Hemdal before doing this, and in the test, I can say this size worked IMO.
(3) Lighting needs refinement
The new dual light has worked better this past 2 weeks but the blending is still not great, so a revised lid which blends both more quickly will be needed. I am using the same LEDs on the Flex and growing corals, so its just a matter of intensity and blending I need to resolve here.
(4) DC Pump / filter works great
No concerns with this side of things. It is plenty powerful enough and having the pump code controlled is really helpful for getting the power delivery just right.
(5) 3D Printed lid is really good for evaporation loss
In the 86 days, the 1.7L aquarium had 0.2L of fresh RO water topped up and had 2x 0.3L water changes. That was it. The 3 months of running used less than 2.5L of salt water, so running this for half a year on a 10L jerry can should be very easy.
(6) Water quality has remained good throughout
I was expecting very high nitrate or phosphate at least in this small aquarium, but the highest I ever saw was well within the numbers I would like, and with very little water changes. Even with the goby being fed daily with that biological load.
(7) Curved aquariums at this size suck
The distortion to your view on such a small cylinder tank is just horrible to be honest with you, so this will be the last time I use this IKEA jar for this purpose. Yes it works, and you could use it, but the acrylic cubes are much more my choice for this size aquarium.
So what is changing on the new board?
The new board has tweaks more than a radical change. The heating is no longer 3 modules running from transistors and instead is 1 big module controlled by a MOSFET. The heating is also being increased from 3.75W to 4.45W, a 19% increase. The design is capable of pushing this up to 5W without having to completely revise the board.
A internal thermistor has been added so I can make sure internal temperatures are safe. LEDs remain the same circuit but the current limiting resistors are spread across more off them to keep them cooler. Wasn't a issue on the current board, but I like to have large margins, especially when the cost difference is small.
Connectors for most parts will now be
external instead of internal. This will make removal and access much easier. wires to the board are not soldered now either (Except power) and are using connectors. This again is done to make it easier but also a better experience to replace parts if needed.
The final edition is cooling, which can deliver the same power rating the heating module can towards cooling. This means a 5V fan or even a 5V fan + TEC setup should be possible, giving us hopefully a -2c cooling option with no evaporation concerns. Not required, but nice to have. Certainly nice to have on the next test aquarium which will hopefully run into the peak of summer to test this option out as well.
What aquarium container will you use next?
I have so far used a 10cm acrylic cube and this IKEA jar. my next test will be done either on the 10cm acrylic cube (0.7L) again, or to test the heating abilities a 15cm acrylic cube (2.7L) may be used. Test fitting for the board is being done on the 10cm cube. As for when the next one will be started, until I have the boards in hand, designed and 3D printed the parts and passed my initial tests, it is hard to say. Maybe as soon as a month. Possibly longer.
What I will do is make a post after this one with a link to the new build when it starts, so if you like the post or comment, you should get a notification when I do this.
Thanks for joining me on this journey of development for Pico's. It isn't over yet!
- Paul (Polymate3D)