The post was meant to be a tongue in cheek (you know, a light hearted take) regarding the opinion that you posted.
So was mine, I did not intend to word my response with anything argumentative. I simply asked for clarification on where your thoughts came from as well as gave reasons for my own.
Correct me if I am wrong, but you paraphrased the cost and complexity part and added your opinion regarding number of choices and other peoples opinions being unhelpful as a drawback. Glasses can be half full or half empty. Some may see choices and broad user feedback as a bonus, not a drawback.
That's fair, I was making a comment on the fact that most find it very overwhelming when they are just starting out. In my opinion, yes, I find that a drawback most inexperienced reefers will run into.
Moreover, I did not say that you were wrong or that owning a car is better than Uber or a skimmer is better than none. I was simply light heartedly trying to point out that some of the argued "downsides" are personal opinion, but it yours or some other persons.
I didn't take it as that. I took it as you were saying skimmers are useful tools that combat a common problem, an opinion in which I have agreed on several times already. I didn't think I implied anything of a combative or negative nature, but if that is what came across, apologies.
Why does somebody have to be either rich or foolish to rank "cost" as a downside? Low value is a downside when compared to something of greater value but cost is only part of value right -- and each of us assigns value differently.
Also a fair point, value does have to be assigned by each individual. I wasn't trying to say it wasn't. I do, however, think its fair to assume 99% of us will ask the question, "how much does it cost?" before making a decision. So I guess I took a liberty to make a generalization that most of us will view the potential cost of a skimmer as a downside.
My comment stems from the old adage "Rich or foolish" that came from the bible. From google: '"Rich or foolish" often refers to the biblical contrast where wealth gained without wisdom leads to spiritual emptiness.' My family uses it to justify doing something ourselves versus paying someone else to do it. IE: Mechanic, home improvement, ect. In the end, I see what I said can be viewed as opinion. My comment probably should have been worded differently.
On a thought provoking note, I do think there is value in the knowledge gained by not using a skimmer. I think it kind of forces newer reefers learn more about their aquarium's nutrient process which can certainly be valuable.
I am bit new to all of this and not sure who the good sources of knowledge are, but maybe one day I will be a source of knowledge too.
I did not and was not questioning your knowledge or experience Bean. You've been a contributing and active member of the community for a very long time. (Also not calling you old.) I was simply trying to convey my quote wasn't just from Joe Schmoe off the street but from a community trusted source.
Enjoy your experiment, but in doing so and speaking of knowledge. Is this method new?
Let's revisit the 80s and 90s.
Contrary to lore, most people used dry rock because live rock was expensive and actually kind of hard to get and was a mess to "cure". There was no "internet", you either had a very rare LFS that carried it or you mail ordered.
The vast majority of tanks were 40–75 gallon soft and LPS systems. SPS was rare, ugly and almost impossible to keep for most people.
The prevailing wisdom was to start slow and allow the system (ahem, the biome) to stabilize over time.
Skimmers were not universal or even close to being so. Before wet/dry filters, many tanks were literally just an airstone and maybe an UG with a lift tube or some floss and carbon.
10% was the common water change and systems were simple.
Sound familier?
I want to point out the fact that I didn't say the method was new and innovative. I sure hope I didn't imply it either. I know its nothing actually new. I also hope it didn't come across that I was praising Ryan for coming up with everything on his own. I give praise Ryan because he sorts through the wealth of knowledge and methods in our community and put a method together in a cohesive and easy to follow along and understand way. I will say this is a new method for me. I can admit fault and I'm definitely a correct things after they have already gone wrong reefer. Which as you can assume, doesn't always provide the best results. I'm hoping to change that by following this method and simply share my experience along the way.
Bean, please take what I'm about to say as a sort of constructive criticism and I do not intend this to be disrespectful or rude in anyway. I understand you're a straight forward person, to which I can come to an understanding of and can hold some sort of respect for. What I don't understand is why you find the need to say some of the things you do or why you word things the way you do. I
THINK(?) you mean to take more of an educational and thought provoking tone, but that isn't how it comes across on the internet and I'm positive I'm not the only one who thinks this. You come across very argumentative and holier than thou at times. Its because of this, I've seen a few of your interactions on here with others where people find you.... abrasive. Personally, I find myself having to read your comments, walk away, then come back later and try to come up with a response without being argumentative or disrespectful in return. Others may not have that instinct and as I'm sure you have noticed, go with their initial response which is to lash out with argumentative and even disrespectful comments. Its even difficult for me sometimes to make myself take a step back before I respond to people sometimes. I completely understand if this isn't how you intended for your messages to come across as, but without having a conversation face to face, sarcasm, general tone, and even jokes just don't translate well over text or the internet. If you could keep this in mind in the future I, and I'm sure others, would greatly appreciate that. I actually do enjoy people who play devil's advocate and challenge the way I think, even forcing me to look at my own thoughts and opinions in a different way. I do my best to own up to mistakes I've made, along with trying to view things from other's perspective along the way. I believe that is how knowledge and thought progresses in society. It is not, however, enjoyable to have these conversations when it feels like the other person is being disrespectful, talking down to you, and argumentative for the sake of being argumentative. Thank you BeanAnimal, I respect you and value your knowledge and experience to which I look forward to in this build thread.