Looking for a new rbta

mfinn

likes zoanthids
View Badges
Joined
Jul 22, 2006
Messages
14,638
Reaction score
11,799
Location
Olympia, WA.
What state or country do you live in
Washington
Rating - 100%
22   0   0
Back a couple decades ago the Rose Bubble Tip Anemones were the hot thing. Then came rainbows and a multitude of colors.
I jumped on the rainbow wagon and sold off the red ones.
But now after some new stuff and other changes in my softy tank I'm thinking about going back to the rbta's.
What are the newest ones?
Any recommendations on vendors?
 
I think most are still a rainbow variety like Chicago and Colorado…just a rainbow variant

The latest versions I’ve heard of are the nexus burst which are a mix of orange and purple.

There’s always the good ol black widows which are more of brighter classic RBTA, they don’t have the green of rainbows.

I believe the original RBTAs got re-named into Sherman’s

All of this is to my knowledge. The name history may be off but that’s just how I understand it.
 
I think most are still a rainbow variety like Chicago and Colorado…just a rainbow variant

The latest versions I’ve heard of are the nexus burst which are a mix of orange and purple.

There’s always the good ol black widows which are more of brighter classic RBTA, they don’t have the green of rainbows.

I believe the original RBTAs got re-named into Sherman’s

All of this is to my knowledge. The name history may be off but that’s just how I understand it.
Kind of the way I remember it too.
When they first started appearing in the early/middle 90's you had to be very special friends with someone to get the privilege of spending $100 or more on one.
Then they became common and sellers needed a name other than "Rose" so I think Sherman was the next one up.
I think the Black Widow had a center disk that was a black color.
I want to get back to the nice over all red.
 
Last time I saw a true rose bta was in 2017 at a lfs in LA. Haven’t seen one since then
 
I’ve seen CCK corals sell some on here, look like true Sherman rose to me(name comes from them originating in Sherman, Tx). Albeit the prices are high. But I live in Texas and can usually find them for under $150.
 
I’ve seen CCK corals sell some on here, look like true Sherman rose to me(name comes from them originating in Sherman, Tx). Albeit the prices are high. But I live in Texas and can usually find them for under $150.
Thanks.
Yeah prices are crazy these days.
 
I did get CSB from someone here, I think that the cheapest way to do unless you could find someone locally, my LFS sell normal rbs for over $100
 
Can't speak to decades ago. But currently, Shermans are different from roses, which are different from black widows and rainbows,
My rose bubble tips stay smaller than all of my other BTA, and tend to split more readily.
Bright reds/pinks are going to be the shermans and black widows. Widows will have a white looking web coloration around the center/mouth, hence the name. My shermans always got bigger than my widows, not sure if that's a factor for you.

They're all bubble tips, but I think of Chicagos and Colorados as their own category. Both have yellow tips vs the rest with purple/pink. (Even the yellow on the Grails terminates in a purple color) I've also heard of people getting Chicagos to change their color depending on lighting source. There was a reef builders article on it years ago, if I remember right. T5s made them a vibrant red, where LEDs would pull crazy yellows. I don't have one to test it myself though.

Don't have comparisons with my Colorado, widows, and shermans vs the others, but I do have plenty of rainbow/rose/grail pics in the tank together to compare sizes/colors.

Of the 3 kinds in my 20L, the Grails are the biggest, then Rainbows which can hit ~10", last are the roses which will only get 3-4" then split. They're dull red/pink, small and split constantly, so they're more of a nuisance imo. I've debated getting rid of all the roses on several occasions.
Rainbows on the left, Grails in the middle, back right is a rose.
20261115_150830.JPG


Rainbows left, roses middle/right
20260214_031325~2.JPG
 
Last edited:
Somehow i always thing RBA and CBS are pretty much look alike beside those marble leg and abit yellow on the tips. This first anemones is CBS and the second and third are regular RBA that i got from someone locally.

 
Back a couple decades ago the Rose Bubble Tip Anemones were the hot thing. Then came rainbows and a multitude of colors.
I jumped on the rainbow wagon and sold off the red ones.
But now after some new stuff and other changes in my softy tank I'm thinking about going back to the rbta's.
What are the newest ones?
Any recommendations on vendors?

A guy on the PNW facebook page has a bunch. Todd Yamashita. He's a good guy and would sell you one cheap I bet. Ben Carolan and I got 15 huge SPS colonies from him about 6 weeks ago.
 
A guy on the PNW facebook page has a bunch. Todd Yamashita. He's a good guy and would sell you one cheap I bet. Ben Carolan and I got 15 huge SPS colonies from him about 6 weeks ago.
Can you share a link or his contact please, i seem to cannot find that facebook page.
 
A guy on the PNW facebook page has a bunch. Todd Yamashita. He's a good guy and would sell you one cheap I bet. Ben Carolan and I got 15 huge SPS colonies from him about 6 weeks ago.
Thanks

I actually have a fish order with @copps coming next week so I sent him a message and he has exactly what I was hoping for and at a pretty good price.
 
I was just looking at his older guam BTA thread last night, is it that one? Keep the thread updated, I'd love to see how it looks. Is he still doing corals and such as well? Kinda tempted with that flame angel pair of his.

And because I already had some pics taken. Here's the Colorado top vs rainbow bottom
8342b4e0-925c-44ad-bf27-b3dd9ce74f5a.jpg


It's difficult to get Colorado color representation in pics vs in person, but here's the best I can get to what I see.
b54b06ad-2c51-4a82-8c13-8c1ebd497876.jpg

And a comparison with orange filter/no filter/yellow filter with just Hydra 26HDs T5s haven't come on yet.
4afa5a05-7b4a-428e-9e5a-0f5491b9fd5c.jpg
 
I was just looking at his older guam BTA thread last night, is it that one? Keep the thread updated, I'd love to see how it looks. Is he still doing corals and such as well? Kinda tempted with that flame angel pair of his.

And because I already had some pics taken. Here's the Colorado top vs rainbow bottom


It's difficult to get Colorado color representation in pics vs in person, but here's the best I can get to what I see.

And a comparison with orange filter/no filter/yellow filter with just Hydra 26HDs T5s haven't come on yet.
Yes it was.
He is sending me a pair of Coral Beauty's.
I saw the thread he did with the Coral Beauty's that had that intense orange. I missed the first pair, but had him find another for me.

So having made the decision to add a RBTA to my mix a couple days ago, it occurred to me this morning to ask about anemones.

My thoughts on the anemones was I didn't need anything fancy, just a basic red RBTA like I had a decade ago. I had a strain that would get easily 10"-12' across and split like crazy. But for some reason I fell into the rainbow rush and traded my rbtas away.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 23 23.7%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 9.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 39 40.2%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.1%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 24 24.7%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new