Marine Depot Elite OverFlow Box - Anybody Using These?

[Nano_Tuners]

Looking at this Marine Depot - branded overflow box for a new 90g tank, but having trouble finding anyone who has used them before...

Has anyone used them (small medium or large model) who has any input? Thanks!

https://www.marinedepot.com/marine-depot-elite-overflow-box-w-holesaw-drill-bit-medium

 

[lpsouth1978]

I would recommend the Fiji cube overflow. The Marine depot and Eshopps sit too low on the outside of the tank resulting in more noise and difficulty tuning.

 

[aabjones888]

I really like my Fiji overflow I have on a 20 gallon.

 

[ca1ore]

Looks like a clone of the eshopps eclipse. All seem based on the same underlying crappy design. Not a lot of new thinking LOL. A least the Fiji box has that removable skim box.

 

[lpsouth1978]

Looks like a clone of the eshopps eclipse. All seem based on the same underlying crappy design. Not a lot of new thinking LOL. A least the Fiji box has that removable skim box.

The Fiji Cube has the removable internal box AND the external box sits higher (nearly level) with the internal box. I have used the Eshopps AND the Fiji cube. I had to modify the Eshopps to make it quiet and get the waterline above the rim on my tank, but use the Fiji Cube just the way it is.

 

[Nano_Tuners]

Sounds like Fiji Cubs is the way to go! Thanks all!

 

[ca1ore]

The Fiji Cube has the removable internal box AND the external box sits higher (nearly level) with the internal box.

The removable skim box is a nice touch, though not unique to the fiji unit. From the pictures, it does NOT appear that they have fixed the lower external box problem. If I were gong with a 'mass market' overflow I would probably select the fiji - not without its design challenges though.

 

[lpsouth1978]

The removable skim box is a nice touch, though not unique to the fiji unit. From the pictures, it does NOT appear that they have fixed the lower external box problem. If I were gong with a 'mass market' overflow I would probably select the fiji - not without its design challenges though.

The lower external box may not be completely fixed, but it is MUCH better than the Eshopps and Marine Depot overflows. They are like 1.5-2" lower than the internal box. The Fiji Cube is maybe 0.5" and a huge improvement. If I really had a choice and the room, I would go with the EMS overflow. That was the BEST overflow box I have ever used, HANDS DOWN!!

@zatch check out the EMS 32" overflow. I used this on a 75g (nearly identical to the 90g, just shorter). and it was amazing! having the weir go almost the complete length of the tank is great for surface skimming.