Need some opinions on lighting

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dasani
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Dasani

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 3, 2010
Messages
528
Reaction score
2
Location
Cullman, Alabama
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I am trying to decide on lighting for my new 20 long (30"L x 13"W x 13"H)
I want this tank to be SPS and zoa/paly dominated (rare zoas and palys to frag and sell for a lil cash)

I have a pretty good bit of money saved up from selling some old equipment and I plan to give my money to 'Santa' and he can pitch in to buy the system.

Here is what I am deciding on:
2x 150w fishneedit.com metal halide pendants
2x Pheonix 14000k bulbs
Total...Around $400

OR

A diy LED fixture. 23" long x 4" wide with dimmable drivers and 24 3w cree xre LED's (12 blue, 12 white)
Total....Around $380

I have seen some amazing growth with metal halides and they seem to be the top choice for SPS tanks.
I haven't seen as many growth shots with LED's (I guess b/c they are newer and not many people have them) but I have seen amazing PAR ratings and color. Plus everyone that has them says they get the same growth as they did with metal halides.

Please tell me what you would go with and why.
Thanks
 
300w or 72w hmmm $400 or $380 hmmm, plus the led's are the new "fad". Can't say much for the groth but mabye someone else will. If others say the groth is the same then why not go with the led's ?
 
300w or 72w hmmm $400 or $380 hmmm, plus the led's are the new "fad". Can't say much for the groth but mabye someone else will. If others say the groth is the same then why not go with the led's ?
Wattage is completely different with LED's. I have heard LED's with 60 degree optics are the same as 150w metal halides.

My dads tank has great growth with mh's and seeing all of Jason's and Tammy's tanks with metal halides and the growth on those corals makes me want mh's. But I have heard LED's are the same...
Still undecided tho :/ but leaning towards LED's due to price and that they last 50k hours.
 
50k hours, sweet. Yea but a watt is a watt isn't it ? "24 3w cree xre LED's" = 72 watts

Yes a watt is a watt but does 150 watts of NO fluorescent have the same intensity at 150W MH? I don't believe it does.

As for the lights its a matter of what you like. I have had MH and T5. I will be slowly getting rid of both and going to LED. Just the cost of replacement bulbs coming up in 3 months for me is over $500. One of the LED fixtures I want is $470. And it is "supposed" to last 5 years or more. I'm betting more. Just my thoughts..
 
That is another reason I want LED's...they last like 13 years if you run them 10 hours a day. Plus you get the shimmer affect and the colors t5's give. And you have actinics and you can dim them.

You should look into building a fixture. It's not to complicated. Check out reefledlights.com. They have a guide on how to do it here: Reef Led Lights How To DIY LED
 
You should look into building a fixture. It's not to complicated. Check out reefledlights.com. They have a guide on how to do it here: Reef Led Lights How To DIY LED

Thanks! I may have to check it out I like DIYing stuff but I travel ALOT with my job and don't have alot of free time for that stuff usually. The "honey do" list gets kinda long sometimes. LOL! :)
 
Thanks! I may have to check it out I like DIYing stuff but I travel ALOT with my job and don't have alot of free time for that stuff usually. The "honey do" list gets kinda long sometimes. LOL! :)

DIY is really the way to go, If you buy it I will build it for you Dave. no charge or expectations other than if you sell them I get first dibs.
 
DIY is really the way to go, If you buy it I will build it for you Dave. no charge or expectations other than if you sell them I get first dibs.

Mike, that sounds like a plan! You should shoot me a PM or call me about some frags....
 
Dave the Acans are doing great.Mike does'nt need any more corals.LOL.Just kidding.I hope the frags are doing good for you.
As far as LED v/s MH.I like the look of LEDs and MH.The T-5's dont give the shimmer the MH do.I know the PAR value of the leds is impressive.I would be comfortable with a lps or zoa tank with all leds.I dont think they have had a chance to be on a sps tank long enogh to decide if growth,color ect can be compared to MH yet.Mike and I were just discussing this topic a few minutes ago.I think some one should set up two tanks with shared water,suppliments and just light differences same frags and see what comes of it in a year.That would be the only fair comparison IMO.I like my MH and have been very happy with them.To bad I can not afford to do this exsperiment but would like to see it.
 
If I can convince the banker to let me spends some cash I would be willing to setup the 300 with a 55 on each side. I feel if they are divided with the same frags off of the same colonies sharing the same water ups and downs then we might have a good compare.......

I might just have to do this.
 
Ya that's a good point Jason. I have heard lots of people say their LED's bleach. I read about one guy who said he got growth and then it 'peeled' off. Not really sure what he meant by that.
As for mh's I have seen amazing growth.
After going to Jason's over the last 8 months or so and seeing the growth on corals in his tank makes me want mh.
And after seeing this much growth in 2 years makes me want it:
spsgrowth.gif

FTS.jpg


Now...
150w or 70w?
1 or 2 pendants?
 
I'm not saying I DON'T like my halides. I just don't like the cost of replacement bulbs............
 
I'm not saying I DON'T like my halides. I just don't like the cost of replacement bulbs............

Ya but this would be $55 a year.

Plus the fixture comes with a bulb, so I would have 2 years covered after I get a Pheonix. And replacement bulbs on fishneedit are $25.
 
Make sure and go with a reputable bulb.I tried some cheapies and was happy for about three mnths and them was very dis appointed.I am fixing to start carring Reeflux and others.I am going with 3x400w 20k reeflux bulbs with two purple T-5's on my 180gal.
 
Make sure and go with a reputable bulb.I tried some cheapies and was happy for about three mnths and them was very dis appointed.I am fixing to start carring Reeflux and others.I am going with 3x400w 20k reeflux bulbs with two purple T-5's on my 180gal.
Ya I plan to get a 14000k Pheonix. I have never heard anything bad about them and I have seen them used on some amazing SPS tanks. Including that JBJ tank I posted a pic of. Although I have heard that the fishneedit bulbs are just as good as other bulbs and last about 8-10 months. But I'll just use it for back up if needed.
 
Ya but this would be $55 a year.

Plus the fixture comes with a bulb, so I would have 2 years covered after I get a Pheonix. And replacement bulbs on fishneedit are $25.

ok on a tank this small I feel the only way to go is LED's one fixture will save you 55 a year on bulbs alone not to mention 30-50 a year in electric. I have seen first hand with my eyes what LED's can do. The colors are much nicer blues reds and purples and as far as growth I have been told its really the same as MH. So as I see it why not save up to 100.00 a year and go with LEDs, not to mention you wot have to worry about bulbs going out of spectrum early and going thru a brown out phase. Just make sure you use a dimable ballast........MOST IMPORTANT


I think you would be foolish to go with MH on this tank, and if you need help building them well get emm ordered and I will help you its very easy.
 
Last edited:

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new