Need to upgrade my Protein Skimmer

ReefOC

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 27, 2024
Messages
396
Reaction score
188
Location
California
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
I have a RedSea 750XXL (200 gallon display with sump) and think I have created a high bioload with lots of fish and corals. I am losing lots of my corals.

Chemistry:
I am experiencing high nitrates and phosphates. I have tried to lower feeding but can't get them under control. Hence, I started to diagnose it. It occurred to me that while my ReefMat is expended faster than most people report, also my protein skimmer may not be keeping pace. I currently have a Reef Octopus 152 Int, which is not rated for a 200 gallon tank and certainly not with high bioload. I'm assuming this is a primary factor to my problem.

Request:
So I'm seeking advice on which brand/model this forum would recommend to upgrade and hopefully help reduce my nitrates and phosphates. Let me know what you think.
 
I run a reef octo regal 250 ext on my. Tank size is 360 gallon and this skimmer is rated with that size between the medium 500g and high 300g bioload range. Can’t keep either. Have to dose just to maintain. And that’s having 14 small to mid size tangs and an additional 10 small chromis at the moment.
 
Out of curiosity, what are you considering high? What types of coral are you losing and how does the loss present itself?
I test weekly:
3/25 - 52 Nitrate and .28 Phosphates
8/25 (5 months later) - 75 Nitrate and .9 Phosphates.

I have lost most of my hard corals, Monti, Slimer, alot of Acros,
 
I run a reef octo regal 250 ext on my. Tank size is 360 gallon and this skimmer is rated with that size between the medium 500g and high 300g bioload range. Can’t keep either. Have to dose just to maintain. And that’s having 14 small to mid size tangs and an additional 10 small chromis at the moment.
What are you dosing? I tried vodka and then RedSea NoPox. It didn't put a dent in my problem.
 
I have a RedSea 750XXL (200 gallon display with sump) and think I have created a high bioload with lots of fish and corals. I am losing lots of my corals.

Chemistry:
I am experiencing high nitrates and phosphates. I have tried to lower feeding but can't get them under control. Hence, I started to diagnose it. It occurred to me that while my ReefMat is expended faster than most people report, also my protein skimmer may not be keeping pace. I currently have a Reef Octopus 152 Int, which is not rated for a 200 gallon tank and certainly not with high bioload. I'm assuming this is a primary factor to my problem.

Request:
So I'm seeking advice on which brand/model this forum would recommend to upgrade and hopefully help reduce my nitrates and phosphates. Let me know what you think.
I run a Tunze 9430dc on my ext 170.
I control po4 when needed with phosphate minus in a nylon bag. I control no3 with a sulfer reactor.
I feed my fish heavy.
I run po4 <0.1 and no3 <5.
Very simple and effective.
This system is currently 14 months old.
20250804_111724.jpg
 
I test weekly:
3/25 - 52 Nitrate and .28 Phosphates
8/25 (5 months later) - 75 Nitrate and .9 Phosphates.

I have lost most of my hard corals, Monti, Slimer, alot of Acros,
I asked as many run “dirty” tanks and still manage to keep corals happy. I’m still curious how the corals die off (bleached, browned, stn/rtn, bottom up, tips down, etc.) might shed light on another issue for those that can help you out. As far as reducing your levels, I’m not convinced that just a bigger skimmer alone will achieve what you want.
 
I asked as many run “dirty” tanks and still manage to keep corals happy. I’m still curious how the corals die off (bleached, browned, stn/rtn, bottom up, tips down, etc.) might shed light on another issue for those that can help you out. As far as reducing your levels, I’m not convinced that just a bigger skimmer alone will achieve what you want.
The monti looked like bleaching, and the rest were dominated red/purple algae. Early on my slimer was dying from the sides.

I have been testing weekly, even with ICP quarterly and can't find another cause for the coral die off and I noticed last night cyano.

Is my analysis that my skimmer is one of the keys to resolving this even correct?
 
The monti looked like bleaching, and the rest were dominated red/purple algae. Early on my slimer was dying from the sides.

I have been testing weekly, even with ICP quarterly and can't find another cause for the coral die off and I noticed last night cyano.

Is my analysis that my skimmer is one of the keys to resolving this even correct?
With cyano (I think pretty much everyone has it somewhere to be honest) noted now, I’m curious about flow. With bleaching, I’d be curious on lighting (as your nutrients are for sure not starving it). Red/purple algae sounds interesting as well. Maybe post a pic for someone to look at, I can’t see well enough to be any assistance with that.

As @X-37B mentioned above, he is running a sulphur reactor (denitrator) as well as a skimmer, plus running gfo or lanthanum (not sure what that product is) to reduce phosphate as needed. Not just relying on a skimmer for a heavily fed system.
 
Pic of your system.
I
With cyano (I think pretty much everyone has it somewhere to be honest) noted now, I’m curious about flow. With bleaching, I’d be curious on lighting (as your nutrients are for sure not starving it). Red/purple algae sounds interesting as well. Maybe post a pic for someone to look at, I can’t see well enough to be any assistance with that.

As @X-37B mentioned above, he is running a sulphur reactor (denitrator) as well as a skimmer, plus running gfo or lanthanum (not sure what that product is) to reduce phosphate as needed. Not just relying on a skimmer for a heavily fed system.
Phosphate minus is gfo that does not need to be rinsed.
Pic of your system helps.
I have never bought into the high nutrient way to run a reeftank.
What are your parameters and WC schedule?
 
With cyano (I think pretty much everyone has it somewhere to be honest) noted now, I’m curious about flow. With bleaching, I’d be curious on lighting (as your nutrients are for sure not starving it). Red/purple algae sounds interesting as well. Maybe post a pic for someone to look at, I can’t see well enough to be any assistance with that.

As @X-37B mentioned above, he is running a sulphur reactor (denitrator) as well as a skimmer, plus running gfo or lanthanum (not sure what that product is) to reduce phosphate as needed. Not just relying on a skimmer for a heavily fed system.
Screenshot 2025-08-09 at 8.07.20 AM.png
IMG_3247.jpeg
IMG_3249.jpeg
IMG_3250.jpeg
 
Nice system.
To start
Stabilize sg to 1.0265 +- 0.0005.
Slowly reduce no3 and po4 both have been steadily increasing.
Reduce alk to 7-8 as it has also been steadily increasing.
From the chart your po4 is to high reduce to 0.1 to .2 to start slowly.
Reduce no3 to < 5 slowly
Reduce alk to 7-8 slowly
This is what I would do if it was my system.
 
With cyano (I think pretty much everyone has it somewhere to be honest) noted now, I’m curious about flow. With bleaching, I’d be curious on lighting (as your nutrients are for sure not starving it). Red/purple algae sounds interesting as well. Maybe post a pic for someone to look at, I can’t see well enough to be any assistance with that.

As @X-37B mentioned above, he is running a sulphur reactor (denitrator) as well as a skimmer, plus running gfo or lanthanum (not sure what that product is) to reduce phosphate as needed. Not just relying on a skimmer for a heavily fed system.
Forgot to talk about flow.. I have 4 Octopulse 4's running 24x7 at 80% in random flow pattern and upgraded my return nozzle with a dual random flow generator. As for lighting I have 4 XR15's and an Ecotech Blade Grow from edge to edge running at peak of 85% for 4 hours and lower for 5 hours (9 total).
 
Last edited:
Nice system.
To start
Stabilize sg to 1.0265 +- 0.0005.
Slowly reduce no3 and po4 both have been steadily increasing.
Reduce alk to 7-8 as it has also been steadily increasing.
From the chart your po4 is to high reduce to 0.1 to .2 to start slowly.
Reduce no3 to < 5 slowly
Reduce alk to 7-8 slowly
This is what I would do if it was my system.
Thank you! I think my question is would you upgrade the skimmer? Second I have High Denisity GFO available in a reactor that I haven't been running, would you use that or Phosphate Minus, as they seem to be the same thing. Any other recommendation on the tools you'd use in my situation.
 
As far as skimmers go, I have had a few brands, RedSea, BubbleKing, Tunze, and Reef Octopus. So far I've stuck with Reef Octopus. I have a Regal 250-EXT and a Elite 150SSS. The Regal 250-EXT is a BEAST. After owning a recirculating style skimmer, you'll never go back and that's a promise. (I'm still trying to figure out how to replace my Elite with a recirculating skimmer, smalls sumps suck.) I still love my Elite, but the 250-EXT will skim the same with one fish or a thousand fish while the elite does a great job, I definitely notice the difference in the skimmate production based on bioload and how the quantity changes each time I feed. Some weeks the Elite makes a full cup, other weeks it makes half a cup. The 250-EXT would make the same amount, same consistency in the exactly the same amount of time each week. The extra adjustment basically allows you the luxury of adjusting exactly how much in nutrients you pull from the water. For your system, being that eventually the corals will uptake more and more as they grow, that would likely be very beneficial to you.
 
Forgot to talk about flow.. I have 4 Octopulse 4's running 24x7 at 80% in random flow pattern and upgraded my return nozzle with a dual random flow generator. As for lighting I have 4 XR15's and an Ecotech Blade Grow from edge to edge running at peak of 85% for 4 hours and lower for 5 hours (9 total).
It sounds like you have everything going. Aside from the levels, the lighting might (and I say that loosely here) be a little low for sps in a high nutrient environment. Probably perfectly adequate and just grabbing at straws really.

We have the same tank (750) fingers crossed no bursting seams. My levels are not as high as yours, actually I’m not too sure I haven’t tested nitrate or phosphate in a while (a couple months ago). Last I checked I was around 30ppm nitrate and 0.4ppm phosphate. It sounds like you have a few more fish than I. My lighting is pretty intense with 3x500x Kessils and 4-T5s. I had a lot more flow previously with 6 wavs but they kept dying off so I have 2 Jebao gyres and 2 wavs now.

I don’t use my skimmer to pull much out (I only empty the cup once a month or so) it’s just for aeration really. I pulled out my fleece roller a few months back as well so no mechanical filtration at all. Well a small amount of rock, ulva and ogo in the sump.

There’s so many ways one can keep a thriving reef and no true one size fits all option.

If you do decide to run gfo, I myself would go slow and steady while performing large water changes as the rocks will keep leeching/desorbing phosphate until it balances out at whatever level you choose. While I’m not a believer in any golden ratios out there, I myself wouldn’t want to drop phosphate to near zero while maintaining nitrate near a hundred but that’s just me. I hope someone can chime in on the algae you’ve encountered and offer sound advice based off of everything you’ve noted and gander at your pictures. Best of luck!
 
Thank you! I think my question is would you upgrade the skimmer? Second I have High Denisity GFO available in a reactor that I haven't been running, would you use that or Phosphate Minus, as they seem to be the same thing. Any other recommendation on the tools you'd use in my situation.
I hate gfo, lol. It's just me as I can't control the mess.
I also just run it in a nylon bag. Simple and easy to change.
Upgrade can't hurt. I have run Tunze skimmers, 4 currently so I'm partial to them and run overesize skimmers in all systems.
The reactor with gfo is fine.
 
You can not overskim no matter what anyone says.
In my ext 170 I run 2 9430dc skimmers. One with ozone one without. Do I need 2 no. But running 2 allows me to feed heavy and keep my po4 media to a min.
20250126_094115.jpg
 
I run a reef octo regal 250 ext on my. Tank size is 360 gallon and this skimmer is rated with that size between the medium 500g and high 300g bioload range. Can’t keep either. Have to dose just to maintain. And that’s having 14 small to mid size tangs and an additional 10 small chromis at the moment.
What are you dosing? I tried vodka and then RedSea NoPox. It didn't put a dent in my problem.
Sorry meant dosing phos and nitrate to keep them elevated. They will bottom out if I don’t.
 
X-37B Is that a Deltec Nitrate Reactor?
If so which pump are you using on it?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new