The problem is it was never that high. And the system worked before it was this high. There is reason to lower it imo.If it ain't broke don't try to fix it. That tank looks awesome. If mine looked that good I wouldn't even be testing lol.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The problem is it was never that high. And the system worked before it was this high. There is reason to lower it imo.If it ain't broke don't try to fix it. That tank looks awesome. If mine looked that good I wouldn't even be testing lol.
If something is rusting slowly it may still provide support until its too late, in which it fails. Phosphate is fine for a while until its too late.My main thought is the tank looks great and I would keep doing what you are doing. That's definetely higher than most of us shoot for and by a lot. On the other hand it is much lower than many successful tanks. If it working for u I don't see why I would change.
I have to say it's hard to argue with that logicIf something is rusting slowly it may still provide support until its too late, in which it fails. Phosphate is fine for a while until its too late.
Ok- you know your system better than anyone. The only thing I can add from experience is that if it were me, I would lower it only as fast as it took to get to that level. So, you’ll be giving your animals a chance to adapt to it, instead of being shocked. Trust me, it happened to me.The problem is it was never that high. And the system worked before it was this high. There is reason to lower it imo.
If something is rusting slowly it may still provide support until its too late, in which it fails. Phosphate is fine for a while until its too late.
Why, oh why, do people still chase numbers when they have gorgeous healthy tanks??Hey everyone
I have a mixed reef tank over 1.3 years old and everything looks happy and healthy.
for the couple last months I’m getting really high phosphate levels
Just wondering what can be the cause?
• 85 gallon tank with low live stock and plenty of corals
• Indonesian rocks 1.3 years old
• nyos 120 skimmer
• 2 mp10, 1 mp40
•Vectra M2
•2 4” inch filter sock filtration
• 55W troptronic UVC
I feed the tank daily with 2 cubes of mysis and artemia and once a week with Reef energy and reef roids.
I water change 12% each week.
Id love to hear your thoughts.
We all chase numbers to a certain extent. If not, why not put corals in 1.018 sg (salinity)? Or why not let alkalinity drop to 4dkh, or rise higher than 12dkh?Why, oh why, do people still chase numbers when they have gorgeous healthy tanks??
Fish in 1.018 is fine short term but NOT coral. You cant place coral in hyposalinityWe all chase numbers to a certain extent. If not, why not put corals in 1.018 sg (salinity)? Or why not let alkalinity drop to 4dkh, or rise higher than 12dkh?
We all have different goal parameters. Responsibly targeting parameters in optimal ranges is fine IMO.
Exactly. The dose makes the poison.Fish in 1.018 is fine short term but NOT coral. You cant place coral in hyposalinity
You're stretching quite a bit comparing salinity to phosphates... I don't consider it "chasing" salinity when I ensure that it's near 1.026 by using an ATO. (I also think you're being disingenuous with the low alk level you mentioned, but some keep things at 12 and do fine).We all chase numbers to a certain extent. If not, why not put corals in 1.018 sg (salinity)? Or why not let alkalinity drop to 4dkh, or rise higher than 12dkh?
We all have different goal parameters. Responsibly targeting parameters in optimal ranges is fine IMO.
I expect coral to die. Many scientific literature explain what happens to stony corals when exposed to high po4 for too long. Its called eutrophication. There are also many expert reefers like glenn f on here will tell you the same high po4 gets tissue necrosis as well as ultra low. Its food to sps but also a poison to building its skeleton. A sort of double edged sword. But high po4 may be fine for one tank but not for others. Such things like nearby algae growth can be fatal to corals, especially with high po4 and no predators to eat it.So curious what bad things you expect to happen? There are many examples of long running amazing tasks with high phosphate levels
What scientific literature? Thanks.I expect coral to die. Many scientific literature explain what happens to stony corals when exposed to high po4 for too long.
Do you have any evidence that higher phosphates (above 0.5ppm) improves growth and coloration? I’ve always heard the reverse to be more true for calcifying corals.What scientific literature? Thanks.
What is the problem with phosguard? ThanksI‘d use a very small amount of GFO and replace every few days until you reached your desired level.
I would not use phosguard.
I expect coral to die. Many scientific literature explain what happens to stony corals when exposed to high po4 for too long. Its called eutrophication. There are also many expert reefers like glenn f on here will tell you the same high po4 gets tissue necrosis as well as ultra low. Its food to sps but also a poison to building its skeleton. A sort of double edged sword. But high po4 may be fine for one tank but not for others. Such things like nearby algae growth can be fatal to corals, especially with high po4 and no predators to eat it.
I am not sure I follow.Do you have any evidence that higher phosphates (above 0.5ppm) improves growth and coloration? I’ve always heard the reverse to be more true for calcifying corals.