Rapid random tank crash?? Nothing was added or changed. What changed?

Possibly but the only thing in there is saltwater and reef actif being slowly dosed in. It's been doing that for awhile now. Nothing new so why would it randomly cause death now.
An overnight disaster can be the result of only a couple things. Typically equipment failure like heater failure or dosing machine overdosed extreme amount, pump failed, etc... they only other thing is something got into your water and completely destroyed the chemistry.
 
My money is on the ammonia being the cause, that isn’t almost detectable, it could be the lighting but that looks like it is almost approaching 1.0 ppm. If you say you have someone baby sitting the tank then maybe they dumped a whole bunch of food in unknowingly or cleaned the glass with an ammonia based glass cleaner or something like it.
 
My money is on the ammonia being the cause, that isn’t almost detectable, it could be the lighting but that looks like it is almost approaching 1.0 ppm. If you say you have someone baby sitting the tank then maybe they dumped a whole bunch of food in unknowingly or cleaned the glass with an ammonia based glass cleaner or something like it.
Nah she didn't. She knows what to do. The ammonia could be the result of things dying from something else that killed them. There's no reason it would randomly spike
 
My money is on the ammonia being the cause, that isn’t almost detectable, it could be the lighting but that looks like it is almost approaching 1.0 ppm. If you say you have someone baby sitting the tank then maybe they dumped a whole bunch of food in unknowingly or cleaned the glass with an ammonia based glass cleaner or something like it.
I use a special reef safe glass cleaner. She knows what to use
 
An overnight disaster can be the result of only a couple things. Typically equipment failure like heater failure or dosing machine overdosed extreme amount, pump failed, etc... they only other thing is something got into your water and completely destroyed the chemistry.
Yah but the question is what could rapidly kill everything
 
I see you said you recently switched to a hanna salinity checker. Is it by chance the salinity pen? I had one that couldnt even get close to the actual salinity. If I am not mistaken it is pretty common to get a defective one. I would cross check your AWC salinity with another method.
 
Ugh sorry my friend. That's the scary part of this hobby. We can do everything right forever and then have the rug pulled from under us in an instant. I feel for you so much. Im not a big collector or anything like that, but if you'd like to restart, Id happily send you some frags to add some color back to it. This is in no way a solution. Im just heartbroken for you and send you my best.
 
I've got a 70 gallon that has been running fine for the past 5 months. Coraline growing, fish healthy, acros and sps growing, everything opened up and colorful. No issues. Alk has been steady around 9, Ph 8.1, salinity around 35.5, 36. I run carbon, UV auto water change all for reef, and kalkwasser. Parameters are stable and everything was fine...

Over a period of 1 day the tank was fine and the next about every coral was read dead. SPS acros Monti almost everything dead and sliming😮‍💨. Nothing obvious was a sign of failure. No equipment failure, parameters all checked out nothing new added or changed. What could it be? I find it hard to believe how fast everything could die no major parameters like temp alk, pH, salinity are at play. They all checked out. Temp was fine all night. The only thing I noticed was that the saltwater in the brute trash can I use for auto water change had some scummy yellowish brown slime stuff that kinda smelled. I believe this to be reef actif that I add in the saltwater for carbon dosing to be slowly added in. Tropic marine uses this in their salts so I don't see the issue.

I really don't know what happened? Bacterial? Toxin or poison? A few snails died but they wouldn't kill a whole tank. Probably died from whatever killed the corals. No equipment failure. ICP tests have been sent off to see if anything out of the normal can be checked. This is a complete mystery to me

IMG_20250521_121827_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121830_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121823_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121824_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121840_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121842_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121817_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121818_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121814_01.jpg IMG_20250521_121812_01.jpg
This sort of crash is typically caused by some type of bacterial issue.

It just happens from time to time - unfortunately.

The bright side is that even though many of those coral appear dead, you will probably find some magically sprouting fresh growth in a few months.
 
First, sorry for your loss. Not necessarily the cause, but I use TM Bio-Actiff salt. But you are supposed to use it in 24 hrs. of mixing. So you can pocket that for the future. Are all your fish fine? If so I would go with a bacterial issue.. Also JFYI corals will thrive on ammonia, so that's not the problem, it is the effect of the issue.
 
Ammonia was registering detectable from the basic API dropper vial color test. It's suppose to be yellow meaning 0 and it's the next color up is a yellow green So that means there is some low amounts of ammonia. Question is did the ammonia kill the corals and snails or did something else kill the snails and corals which then caused an ammonia spike? None of this makes sense. Why would ammonia randomly appear... It wouldn't so something must have killed them causing the spike. The rest was cross checked with another established reef tank and it registered zero or yellow meaning no ammonia.
EDIT - I did not see the picture of the ammonia test before writing this. It looks like it's 0.25 to me. It's nowhere near 1. That is not enough ammonia to do anything to coral (usually). Are you sure you didn't have a power outage or something like that during the night? Additionally, I'm assuming your fish are ok - and you're right the snails dying don't usually cause an issue. It seems like either something from your replacement water - (doubt) - or something died and released a toxin - which then caused a downward cascade - and yes it can happen quickly. Do you run activated carbon in your tank? Coral toxins can be released upon dying and carbon can help rectify that.

As to your API test - if the color is closer to the yellow than the 0.25 picture - the results is read as 0. If the green is closer to the 0.25 color, the reading is 0.25. Note I'm not saying this is 'good' - but you may have had a spike - and you're catching it only as it's coming down. 0.25 would not do what you have now though.

Hope this helps update with anything (PS your LPS may be ok).
 
As stated check for stray voltage. The easiest way is if you have a boo-boo on one of your fingers, dip it in the tank so that it’s submerged.
Then put just the tip of your finger in and you should feel it tingling on your injury. It’s a phenomenon.
How are your fish doing? I apologize if you mentioned them, I’m still working on my first cup of coffee.
Are there any smells? Rotten eggs? I see some corals that still look fine, are the white ones dead, or bleached?
Do you have a temp monitor? Did you shut your ac off? Was your house empty while you were gone? No co2, ph spike?
Just spitballing ideas.
 
I thought the same. Nothing....I will say that I'm on vacation and if course this **** happens when I'm away so I have a family member taking care of the tanks. I can't verify for myself but I did ask her and she said no. She knows what she is doing for the most part though
First of all, I'm SO sorry about your losses.

Secondly. If you are still on vacation who did all the testing and checking? The baby sitter of the tank?

Reading now that you are on vacation and this happened when you were away, makes me believe that something in the babysitting went very wrong.
 
Otherwise my best bet is doser going crazy, heater going crazy, baby sitter going crazy or something leaking, maybe a magnet or some other equipment? If something was rotting in your sump I wouldn't suspect it to wipe em all out so fast.

A few month ago I wiped out (all acros in) my tank in ONE day 24 after manually adding a Cyano Control by Tropic Marin. Right dose, but somehow they didn't put up with it. So chemistry CAN take them out fast.
 
As stated check for stray voltage. The easiest way is if you have a boo-boo on one of your fingers, dip it in the tank so that it’s submerged.
Then put just the tip of your finger in and you should feel it tingling on your injury. It’s a phenomenon.
How are your fish doing? I apologize if you mentioned them, I’m still working on my first cup of coffee.
Are there any smells? Rotten eggs? I see some corals that still look fine, are the white ones dead, or bleached?
Do you have a temp monitor? Did you shut your ac off? Was your house empty while you were gone? No co2, ph spike?
Just spitballing ideas.
If you have a volt meter and you are comfortable. Switch the meter to AC voltage, put the black probe into your ground of your receptacle, then put the red probe into your tank water and see if you get any reading . If you do, unplug stuff one at a time and see which makes it go away, There are articles on how to do it and acceptable levels which is not much, I think like 3 volts. Good luck!
 
If you have a volt meter and you are comfortable. Switch the meter to AC voltage, put the black probe into your ground of your receptacle, then put the red probe into your tank water and see if you get any reading . If you do, unplug stuff one at a time and see which makes it go away, There are articles on how to do it and acceptable levels which is not much, I think like 3 volts. Good luck!
True - just remember there can be 'voltage' measured that is not 'the stray voltage mentioned above' - but merely induced voltage from tank equipment. Thus - if you unplug some of your equipment - it may lower it - but it may be insignificant. Additionally, if fish are not having an issue, it's not likely the problem. The symptoms here do not suggest stray voltage (to me) - but its always a good thing to consider
 
True - just remember there can be 'voltage' measured that is not 'the stray voltage mentioned above' - but merely induced voltage from tank equipment. Thus - if you unplug some of your equipment - it may lower it - but it may be insignificant. Additionally, if fish are not having an issue, it's not likely the problem. The symptoms here do not suggest stray voltage (to me) - but its always a good thing to consider
when testing used equipment; my first test for safety, which rules out induced voltage:

— Take a bucket of saltwater, place by a GFCI
— Place pump/heater/etc in bucket
— plug a grounding probe into a GFCI
— Plug individual submerged gear into GFCI
— dip grounding probe into water bucket

If the GFCI trips; you know you have a very dangerous piece of gear on your hands!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 15 35.7%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 1 2.4%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 33.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 12 28.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new