Reef Chemistry Question of the Day #248 Sea Urchin Spines

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Reef Chemistry Question of the Day #248

Sea urchin spines are mostly commonly made of which if the following materials?

A. Aragonite
B. Magnesium-rich calcite
C. Calcium-rich Brucite
D. Uranophane

Good luck!






























.

 

[needbiggertanks]

B?

 

[MnFish1]

Reef Chemistry Question of the Day #248

Sea urchin spines are mostly commonly made of which if the following materials?

A. Aragonite
B. Magnesium-rich calcite
C. Calcium-rich Brucite
D. Uranophane

Good luck!






























.

Def a trick question. But I found a world renowned experts article so. B

Sea Urchin Spines

Corals use aragonite for their skeletons, but urchins have found calcite to be more suitable for their spines. The magnesium-rich part of the description implies that a significant portion of the calcium ions have been swapped for magnesium ions, and the exact amount of magnesium present is discussed later in this article.

 

[Hitman]

B

 

[rkpetersen]

Yeah B. Sea urchin spines are impressively tough. The material is being researched as a substitute for autologous bone graft or cadaver bone graft in orthopedic surgical procedures.

 

[CNDReef]

B

 

[Dom]

C

 

[SDReefer]

B, sea urchin spines are made out of calcite, the most stable polymorph of calcium carbonate.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

And the answer is...

Sea urchin spines are mostly commonly made of which if the following materials?

B. Magnesium-rich calcite

Sea Urchins: A Chemical Perspective by Randy Holmes-Farley - Reefkeeping.com
http://reefkeeping.com/issues/2004-08/rhf/index.htm

This is all you are likely to want to know (and more) about sea urchin spine chemistry:


Sea Urchin Spines

The first thing that comes to mind when most aquarists hear the name sea urchin is an animal covered in spines. Sea urchin spines come in a wide range of sizes, shapes, and colors. Some urchin spines are long and slender (Figure 1). Others are short and fat (Figure 2). In still others, the spines have been almost eliminated (Figure 3). Many researchers in the past century have studied sea urchin spines, so quite a lot is known about them. They provide a fascinating look at how nature solves bioengineering problems, and they are a good place to start this chemical perspective on sea urchins.

Not all urchin spines are the same. They have, in fact, evolved in many different ways, as is clear in the photographs in this article. Some are covered in epidermis (tissue), while others, notably the pencil urchins (and all cidarid urchins), are not. Consequently, the discussions that follow are intended to highlight the chemical aspects of certain urchins, but the attributes detailed may not extend to any particular species.

Sea Urchin Spines: Structure

While sea urchin spines have a wide range of appearances, they also have some commonality. All, for example, are largely made of calcium carbonate, as are coral skeletons. Interestingly, recent studies have shown some sea urchin spines to be large single crystals of calcite,1 while others are mosaics of many individual crystals.2 For example, by using X-ray reflection, the spines of Heterocentrotus trigonarius have been shown to consist of 10-cm long single crystals of magnesium-rich calcite.1Calcite is a particular crystalline form of calcium carbonate in which the calcium and carbonate ions are arranged in a slightly different pattern than in the other predominant form of calcium carbonate found in marine organisms: aragonite. Corals use aragonite for their skeletons, but urchins have found calcite to be more suitable for their spines. The magnesium-rich part of the description implies that a significant portion of the calcium ions have been swapped for magnesium ions, and the exact amount of magnesium present is discussed later in this article.

In all Heterocentrotus trigonarius spines, the calcite crystal is aligned in a particular direction in relation to the spine's axis. In other words, the arrangement of calcium and carbonate ions was perfectly aligned with respect to the length of the spine, leaving no gaps along which the spine might easily crack.2

The spine itself, however, is not a solid crystal, like a chunk of calcite that might reside in a rock collection. Rather, it is very porous, as seen by scanning and transmission electron microscopy (SEM, and TEM, respectively). These pores consist of two types: a continuous assortment of macropores that are easily seen by SEM, and a series of many small (80 nm) protein inclusions that are easily seen by TEM. These proteins are, in fact, critical for the spine's initial formation, and will be discussed later in this article.

Sea Urchin Spines: Composition

As mentioned above, the crystals are magnesium-rich calcite, containing 2-25 mole percent magnesium ions (75-98 mole percent calcium)2,3 This level of magnesium is appreciably higher than in most coral skeletons (which use the aragonite crystal form of calcium carbonate), and similar to or higher than many calcareous algae (which often deposit calcite having several mole percent magnesium). The magnesium content of the spines has been shown to vary somewhat with water temperature, and has also been shown to increase by about 2 mole percent from the tip of the spine to the base.

It has been suggested that the presence of magnesium in the calcite strengthens the calcite by altering the way cracks can propagate through it. The additional magnesium near the base makes the base stronger, thus increasing the likelihood that any spine that does break will break farther from the body, causing the urchin to lose less material than if the break were nearer to the body.2

When exposed to excessive heavy metals, the spines of sea urchins can incorporate these metals into their crystal structure. Lead and zinc, for example, have been shown to be incorporated into the spines of Paracentrotus lividus and Arbacia lixula when the ambient levels rise above those in normal seawater.4 What effect these incorporations have on the spines, for example, on their strength is not clear.

Sea Urchin Spines: Formation

A multitude of studies have examined the deposition of calcium carbonate in sea urchin larvae, and a few have studied it in adults. As might be expected from a process that results in a large, shaped single crystal, the deposition is very carefully controlled. How this happens is only poorly understood. As with calcification in corals, it is a very complicated process. It involves numerous proteins and other organic compounds. What is known of the overall process is outlined in the following sections.

Sea Urchin Spine Formation: Uptake of Calcium and Carbonate

Sea urchins can take calcium and alkalinity directly from the water column to deposit calcite to form spines. This has been demonstrated by the fact that some (e.g., Strongylocentrotus purpuratus) have been shown to be able to take calcium from solution and calcify even when kept under starvation conditions, although the calcification rate was slower than under fed conditions.5

At least two species, however, have been shown to have some propensity to consume solid calcium carbonate that may be dissolved by the lower pH in their guts and released to the organism to provide the building blocks for calcification, sort of like miniature CaCO3 reactors.6 In these experiments, Diadema setosum and Echinometra sp. were shown to prefer artificial foods with powdered calcite added over the same foods with no calcite. Many urchins might similarly obtain calcium and carbonate ("alkalinity") from the calcareous algae and other bits of calcium carbonate that they consume. [As an interesting aside, it has been claimed that many calcareous algae deposit CaCO3 in an effort to make themselves less palatable to fish.7 In the case of sea urchins, this strategy appears to backfire.]

Will urchins significantly deplete calcium and alkalinity in a reef aquarium? Probably not very much relative to other calcifying organisms, but in a new aquarium in which coralline algae and corals may be calcifying slowly, this relatively low depletion rate may be an appreciable part of the total. When I first set up my reef aquarium, I used wild Florida live rock that contained quite a load of sea urchin hitchhikers. More than 30 rock-boring urchins (Echinometra lucunter) were present, and they grew very rapidly for a year or so, before dwindling. During that time, coralline algae grew poorly (even in areas not browsed by the urchins) and I had few rapidly calcifying corals. Consequently, while I did not realize it at the time, some of the limewater that I was adding may have been ending up in the urchins. As an aside, studies have shown that moderate grazing by sea urchins can increase the spread of coralline algae from the chips that are released. However, in a finite space like a reef aquarium, heavy sea urchin grazing may overwhelm the growth of coralline algae.

Sea Urchin Spine Formation: The Role of Organics

The spicules in sea urchin embryos, as well as the spines in growing adults, are deposited by primary mesenchyme cells, which surround the growing tips of the spines. These cells accumulate calcium and secrete calcium carbonate.8 Exactly how the secreted calcium and carbonate ions become shaped into spines, however, is not entirely clear.

More than a dozen different proteins have been found to be associated with calcification in sea urchins.8-16 In the completed spine, many of the proteins remain trapped inside pores in the spine. In one case, the trapped protein was estimated to comprise 0.1% of the spine's total mass.3,8 In a related experiment, some of the proteins (acidic glycoproteins) present in sea urchin calcite were extracted and added back to calcite crystals in vitro (in test tubes) to see what effect it had. These proteins turned out to adsorb onto specific crystalline facets of the calcite where they altered crystallization along those facets.9 In another experiment, proteins extracted from the spines of Paracentrotus lividus also adsorbed onto only a single crystal facet, encouraging one of the other facets to grow more. Interestingly, when magnesium was added to the mix, the proteins directed growth to occur on a different facet.10 In this way, the sea urchin can use a variety of organic and inorganic materials to modify growth of spines to specific sizes and shapes as it "chooses," based on the materials secreted onto the growing surfaces.10,15

Sea Urchin Spines: Coloration

The descriptions of sea urchin spines provided to this point do not explain why they are colored. Indeed, the coloration of sea urchin spines has been the subject of numerous research projects for decades. Obviously, with so many different urchins of different colors, the explanations of the colors will vary, but sea urchins as a group have a relatively novel set of chromophores. In fact, many of these form a homologous family of chemical structures that has been named the spinochromes ('spino' for spine and 'chrome' for color). Figures 4 and 5 show some of these novel structures that have been isolated from sea urchins, but many related structures have also been isolated from them.

Each species of urchin may have many different chromophores, giving it a distinct color, just as mixing different pigments in paints gives different colors. The red sea urchin Strongylocentrotus franciscanus contains spinochrome B, echinochrome A and spinochrome E.17 Diadema setosum(which is dark purple/black) contains echinochrome A, spinochrome A and the methyl ether of echinochrome A.18 Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis (which can have red, green, or violet spines that are often white tipped: Figure 7) contains spinochromes A, C, D, and E as well as the two dimers shown Figure 5.19 The spines of Strongylocentrotus nudus have been found to contain at least 11 different pigments, including spinochromes A, B, C, and E and echinochrome A.20

By varying the substituents on these spinochrome rings, the urchins have made a variety of different colors, with only small chemical changes potentially leading to large color changes. For example, having hydroxyl groups on only the quinone side of the ring system (the side with the two C=O groups) often gives oranges and reds, while having hydroxyl groups on both rings gives purples and blues.21Some of the –OH groups attached to the rings are also acidic, and can deprotonate to –O- groups. Echinochrome A, for example, has three of the –OH groups deprotonated under the pH and calcium concentrations in normal seawater (Figure 6).22 This deprotonation also drastically changes the color, and is especially likely in the presence of high calcium concentrations.

That said, why would a sea urchin care about color? After all, they don't "see" each other. Are these dyes even produced for the color effect, or for other reasons? Some may use color to warn potential predators if they are especially poisonous (discussed later in the article). Other urchins may use these molecules for purposes entirely different from color. In fact, the spinochromes may have evolved to perform several different functions for the urchins.

It has been noted, for example, that spines of many species of sea urchins are rarely covered with any epiphytic growth (that is, few or no organisms settle onto the spines to grow, although some do get such growth, as shown in Figure 8). It has been suggested that the spinochromes my provide part of this natural anti-biofouling coating. In fact, the spinochromes and related compounds have been shown to be effective anti-biofouling agents for fishing nets,23 and other applications.24-26 How can this inhibition work? The spinochromes are very water soluble molecules, and they could easily leak (or be secreted) from the various tissues containing them into the intercellular water of the epidermis as well as into the nearby water column. At adequate concentrations, these molecules could then kill organisms that try to settle onto this "toxic" substrate. At sublethal concentrations, the secreted spinochromes may simply irritate organisms sufficient to get them to move away (or not settle in the first place). This process has not, however, been proven to take place.

An alternate explanation of the advantages of the spinochromes involves protection from oxidation by superoxide free radicals (O2-). Such chemistry is well beyond the scope of this article, but these highly oxidizing free radicals have been implicated in all sorts of undesirable phenomena in organisms, including diseases in humans ranging from aging and cancer to heart disease. It also plays a role in certain types of coral bleaching. Such radicals are very reactive, and damage nearby organic molecules. The benefit to humans of the antioxidant vitamins, for example, may be that they rapidly scavenge free radicals.

In the case of sea urchins, they may use the spinochromes and related compounds to defend against the superoxide free radicals (O2-) that bombard them in the ocean.27-31 These oxidizing species are generated by physical processes involving oxygen and light, and also are made and secreted by many organisms. Several of the spinochromes have been shown to be powerful superoxide and reactive iron scavengers.32,33 Whether this is indeed an advantage that benefits sea urchins, or whether it is an unintended consequence of the chemistry used to attain some other goal, is not clear.

Finally, sea urchin embryos are easily damaged by ambient ultraviolet light.34 Consequently, it is possible that these pigments provide protection for the growing and adult urchins exposed to intense sunlight.

It is also possible that we do not yet know the most important function of the spinochromes, and that all of the effects described above are incidental to some unknown primary use.