Hey folks! I recently got into an argument with someone about running copper at low levels and what it actually does to protozoans like ich or velvet.
As we know, many LFSs run low levels of copper, below therapeutic, just to mask symptoms of potential disease and keep fish looking healthy long enough to be sold.
What I always understood was that low copper levels (e.g. around 1.0 ppm copper power instead of the therapeutic 2.0+ ppm), weaken or kill some percentage of ich to the point where it can no longer multiply enough to cause a full outbreak. I don't know the exact percentage or if there's any study someone can point me to? For example, at 1.5 ppm it might eliminate or make unable to complete its life cycle, let's say, 50%. I'd be curious to read anything on that if it exists.
So essentially, subtherapeutic copper acts more like ich management rather than treatment, similar to running UV. It wipes out or weakens some percentage of the parasites but not enough to truly clear a system, just enough to keep a visible outbreak at bay. Hence, when we bring the new fish home and place it into a system with no copper at all, the parasite can finally reproduce unchecked, and the fish often becomes sick and declines very quickly.
The argument I got into was that copper does absolutely nothing until it reaches full therapeutic levels or 2.0+ ppm - it doesn't kill, weaken, or debilitate ich at all. But if that's the case, why would an LFS run low copper levels at all? Their argument was that the LFS actually does aim for therapeutic levels but don't maintain it well, so it often drops below and becomes ineffective.
Anyway, just wanted to hear our fish disease experts thoughts on this. Thank you!
As we know, many LFSs run low levels of copper, below therapeutic, just to mask symptoms of potential disease and keep fish looking healthy long enough to be sold.
What I always understood was that low copper levels (e.g. around 1.0 ppm copper power instead of the therapeutic 2.0+ ppm), weaken or kill some percentage of ich to the point where it can no longer multiply enough to cause a full outbreak. I don't know the exact percentage or if there's any study someone can point me to? For example, at 1.5 ppm it might eliminate or make unable to complete its life cycle, let's say, 50%. I'd be curious to read anything on that if it exists.
So essentially, subtherapeutic copper acts more like ich management rather than treatment, similar to running UV. It wipes out or weakens some percentage of the parasites but not enough to truly clear a system, just enough to keep a visible outbreak at bay. Hence, when we bring the new fish home and place it into a system with no copper at all, the parasite can finally reproduce unchecked, and the fish often becomes sick and declines very quickly.
The argument I got into was that copper does absolutely nothing until it reaches full therapeutic levels or 2.0+ ppm - it doesn't kill, weaken, or debilitate ich at all. But if that's the case, why would an LFS run low copper levels at all? Their argument was that the LFS actually does aim for therapeutic levels but don't maintain it well, so it often drops below and becomes ineffective.
Anyway, just wanted to hear our fish disease experts thoughts on this. Thank you!
