Tank Swap

Got it. What about the intake pipe in the overflow box? How is that made/designed? That picture i posted looks like it has more than just a pipe and a u-joint with a screen.
Google durso style drain. That will help explain what your going for.
 
Google durso style drain. That will help explain what your going for.

Hopefully not hard to build lol. How do you decide how high up to make the intake? And I've heard one type of pipe is quiter than the other when it comes to PVC vs flex PVC. I know it's cheaper to use PVC, especially when I already have the tools to cut it and stuff.
 
Google durso style drain. That will help explain what your going for.

Actually I probably would just buy one prebuilt from them to save myself the trouble. Although they say that the 1" bulkhead ones are rated for 600 GPH and that's the lowest my return pump goes (I think my HOB is rated at 600 GPH too and it seems like it can barely keep up with the return). Am I wrong in thinking that I would want a higher intake GPH than that?

I have a sicca 4.0 quiet return pump right now and definitely would not want to have to replace it.
 
Hopefully not hard to build lol. How do you decide how high up to make the intake? And I've heard one type of pipe is quiter than the other when it comes to PVC vs flex PVC. I know it's cheaper to use PVC, especially when I already have the tools to cut it and stuff.
True answer is I'm not well versed on durso style drains so I couldn't tell you how to determine water levels. Hopefully somebody who runs them on there will chime in on that question.
 
True answer is I'm not well versed on durso style drains so I couldn't tell you how to determine water levels. Hopefully somebody who runs them on there will chime in on that question.

I appreciate all the information for sure. What are other types of drains are there?
 
There is a herbie style and a bean animal. The herbie requires two dedicated holes to for the drain and the bean animal requires three holes dedicated to the drain. You could run a herbie style with this one but you would have to redirect your return with a hang on the back return nozzel.
 
Personally I would go herbie and bring the return over the back. For me the peace of mind of a backup drain is invaluable. For that reason I run a bean animal. A Herbie will also allow you to fine tune water level for noise reduction

I would use check valves either. Just drill a small hole in your lockline at water level for a siphon break
 
I agree with @Bayareareefer18. You can use the two existing holes for the herbie and just buy a hang return that will come over the back of the tank.

I have an existing return that runs over the back so I guess theoretically I could just continue to use that one if I do a Herbie.

My sump only has one inlet though. So to run a Herbie wouldn't I need to tie the inlets together and then into the sump? I always thought the more junctions you have, the more risk for failure?
 
I have an existing return that runs over the back so I guess theoretically I could just continue to use that one if I do a Herbie.

My sump only has one inlet though. So to run a Herbie wouldn't I need to tie the inlets together and then into the sump? I always thought the more junctions you have, the more risk for failure?
Definitely don't want to tee your drains together. When you say one inlet to your sump do you mean it has a connection to attach drain pipe to? Photo?
 
Definitely don't want to tee your drains together. When you say one inlet to your sump do you mean it has a connection to attach drain pipe to? Photo?
sumppic.jpg
 
Ah gotcha. Looks like that is setup to accept a flex hose. I for one am not a fan of those fled hoses but I know many use them. You could always drop the backup drain into one of the open sections... with a Herbie that line just have a tiny trickle of water going down it unless there is any issue with main siphon line
 
You’ll tie the main drain (shorter stand pipe) into the main inlet of the sump. The emergency just dump anywhere in the sump. The idea is the emergency won’t have much water going down it. In the pic, the one on the right is my main drain and goes into my filter sock. The one on the left just dumps into the next compartment. The reason you don’t want to tie them in, is you would loose the “emergency” part of the second drain. If something is clogging it then it will clog both of them.

7B628679-639A-4CA2-BF5C-52D7F1DAEE10.jpeg
 
Ah gotcha. Looks like that is setup to accept a flex hose. I for one am not a fan of those fled hoses but I know many use them. You could always drop the backup drain into one of the open sections... with a Herbie that line just have a tiny trickle of water going down it unless there is any issue with main siphon line

It may accept flex hosing but it's set up with regular PVC right now. I'm thinking I want to stay with regular PVC so I'm not buying flex hose tools that I'll use once lol.
 
So after talking it over with the significant other, I think we are going to go with a Herbie design. She's ok with the return line staying where it is (on the outside of the tank) if a Herbie system will be safer, more stable and quieter. That also means I don't have to make a new screen top for that side of the tank as it's already made with a cut out for the return. Just will need to make a new one for the other side.

Now to find a good description of how high each drain is, parts needed, etc and start building lol.
 
So after talking it over with the significant other, I think we are going to go with a Herbie design. She's ok with the return line staying where it is (on the outside of the tank) if a Herbie system will be safer, more stable and quieter. That also means I don't have to make a new screen top for that side of the tank as it's already made with a cut out for the return. Just will need to make a new one for the other side.

Now to find a good description of how high each drain is, parts needed, etc and start building lol.
http://gmacreef.com/herbie-overflow-reef-tank-plumbing-method-basics/
 
Replace with 100% new sand during the swap, fully pre rinsed in tap water so it's cloudless like a snowglobe. Final rinse is saltwater... Then use in new reef. This is ideal. Use as much new water in the new tank as you can stand to use.

Merely exchanged old for new sand makes your move safe, dealing in old sand is where the risk lies for recycling + invasion outbreaks in the newer tank.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new