Test Kits

IAmGroot420

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 5, 2025
Messages
30
Reaction score
11
Location
Sourhern California (Orange County)
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hey! Noobie here. I have a 20 gallon tank with 2 clown fish, an anemone, 6 snails, hermit crab, and a daisy polyp. Tank is fully cycled.

Question about testing water parameters… Which test kits do you prefer? I have the Hanna Master Kit but it seems overwhelming to use and also seems like it’ll be expensive (other than the big $450 price tag) with all the raedant packets to buy. I also have API master kits (Reef and Saltwater). I’m thinking about returning one of these, but not sure. Or maybe a different brand?

Also, how often should I be checking? And which parameters are the most important to check?

TIA
 
The API isn't good for much of anything except a paperweight. The Master Hanna kit is the standard for sure but that depends on how deep you are going to go into the hobby and what you intend to keep. Personally, I use a Hanna high range nitrate and Hanna ultra low range phosphate, Salifert alkalinity, calcium and mag, I have a Milwaukee pH meter, an accurate thermometer and a salinity refractometer. Oh and forgot about Hanna copper that's used for QT purposes. The reagents really aren't that big of a deal, you shouldn't have to test often enough for their expense to be of concern. If you're testing anything other than nitrate, phosphate and alkalinity more often than once a week you're testing far too often.

Doesn't the master kit come with 25 count packs of reagent? When you buy the checkers separately you only get 10 reagents packets I think. The master kit is expensive but it does come with some perks that make it a good buy.
 
If you're just starting out, I wouldn't spend the money on Hanna testers. There's just no need for them at this point. Most people use different brands for different tests. For example, Aquaforest for phosphate and nitrate, Salifert for alkalinity, etc. Just look into which type of test you'd prefer doing on a regular basis (most are either colorimetric or titration tests).
 
You can always upgrade in the future if you really want to since most test kits are fairly inexpensive. Personally, I prefer Aquaforest and Salifert. They're good brands and not very costly per kit.
 
The API isn't good for much of anything except a paperweight. The Master Hanna kit is the standard for sure but that depends on how deep you are going to go into the hobby and what you intend to keep. Personally, I use a Hanna high range nitrate and Hanna ultra low range phosphate, Salifert alkalinity, calcium and mag, I have a Milwaukee pH meter, an accurate thermometer and a salinity refractometer. Oh and forgot about Hanna copper that's used for QT purposes. The reagents really aren't that big of a deal, you shouldn't have to test often enough for their expense to be of concern. If you're testing anything other than nitrate, phosphate and alkalinity more often than once a week you're testing far too often.

Doesn't the master kit come with 25 count packs of reagent? When you buy the checkers separately you only get 10 reagents packets I think. The master kit is expensive but it does come with some perks that make it a good buy.

I agree here and pretty much test the exact same way as you do. Hanna for specific needs like phosphate, nitrate and copper that we truly need a pinpoint value on. The remaining of my kits are salifert as well

If I was you OP and thinking of returning them I would suggest the same kits as above if you planned on furthering your reefing journey. But if you just wanted an easy softy tank or something simple as you currently have really I probably wouldnt even test and just do bi weekly 10% water changes with a low alkalinity salt to keep up with parameters and nutrients.
 
The API isn't good for much of anything except a paperweight. The Master Hanna kit is the standard for sure but that depends on how deep you are going to go into the hobby and what you intend to keep. Personally, I use a Hanna high range nitrate and Hanna ultra low range phosphate, Salifert alkalinity, calcium and mag, I have a Milwaukee pH meter, an accurate thermometer and a salinity refractometer. Oh and forgot about Hanna copper that's used for QT purposes. The reagents really aren't that big of a deal, you shouldn't have to test often enough for their expense to be of concern. If you're testing anything other than nitrate, phosphate and alkalinity more often than once a week you're testing far too often.

Doesn't the master kit come with 25 count packs of reagent? When you buy the checkers separately you only get 10 reagents packets I think. The master kit is expensive but it does come with some perks that make it a good buy.
Gotcha. Yeah I think that may be a problem for me. I tend to test all parameters about 3-4 times a week.
 
You can always upgrade in the future if you really want to since most test kits are fairly inexpensive. Personally, I prefer Aquaforest and Salifert. They're good brands and not very costly per kit.
Thanks! I appreciate the feedback. I’ll look into these. I tend to prefer digital readers just because they’re easier for me
 
I agree here and pretty much test the exact same way as you do. Hanna for specific needs like phosphate, nitrate and copper that we truly need a pinpoint value on. The remaining of my kits are salifert as well

If I was you OP and thinking of returning them I would suggest the same kits as above if you planned on furthering your reefing journey. But if you just wanted an easy softy tank or something simple as you currently have really I probably wouldnt even test and just do bi weekly 10% water changes with a low alkalinity salt to keep up with parameters and nutrients.
Gotcha. Thank you. I do plan on making this a permanent hobby, so I’m down to get some kits. I’ll look into your suggestions, much appreciate your time
 
Gotcha. Thank you. I do plan on making this a permanent hobby, so I’m down to get some kits. I’ll look into your suggestions, much appreciate your time
Your Welcome!
If you like the hanna kits and plan to get deeper into the hobby than there is nothing wrong with keeping them 🙂 They are great kits and regiments would last a long time if not testing so often as you do

Unless you have coralline algae or hard corals consuming alk/cal really you shouldnt have to test alk every 1-2 weeks, then cal/mag every couple weeks along with nitrate and phosphate. Once the tank is dialed in and you dont see any large swings just keep performing your same routine everyday with regular weekly/bi weekly testing.

This is how I maintain my 29g nano cube that only has zoas. 99% of the time regular water changes keep up with everything but Mag seeing I use purple instant ocean, so I typically just dose my new saltwater to the desired mag level.
 
Since you have the Master, stick with it. I use all of the hanna individual test kits, but I have multiple tanks, so I am testing multiple test at once. The reagents are expensive, but that price can be reduced, by watching out for sales. IE; Hanna just had a 20% off.
On the API note, They tend to get a bad rap because they are difficult to read. But when I use the calcium test for example it falls in line with my Hanna or Red Sea test kit.
 
The Hanna regeants replacements get very expensive since they only contain 25 tests. I own only use Hanna for phosphate and occasionally to double check the alk test but the salifert tests are always spot on. I would suggest to get salifert tests and use the Hanna sparingly.
 
I always recommend people to get salifert or Red Sea test kits if you don't want to spend the money on hannas
 
Your Welcome!
If you like the hanna kits and plan to get deeper into the hobby than there is nothing wrong with keeping them 🙂 They are great kits and regiments would last a long time if not testing so often as you do

Unless you have coralline algae or hard corals consuming alk/cal really you shouldnt have to test alk every 1-2 weeks, then cal/mag every couple weeks along with nitrate and phosphate. Once the tank is dialed in and you dont see any large swings just keep performing your same routine everyday with regular weekly/bi weekly testing.

This is how I maintain my 29g nano cube that only has zoas. 99% of the time regular water changes keep up with everything but Mag seeing I use purple instant ocean, so I typically just dose my new saltwater to the desired mag level.
When do you typically run the water testing? A couple of days after a water change?
 
Your Welcome!
If you like the hanna kits and plan to get deeper into the hobby than there is nothing wrong with keeping them 🙂 They are great kits and regiments would last a long time if not testing so often as you do

Unless you have coralline algae or hard corals consuming alk/cal really you shouldnt have to test alk every 1-2 weeks, then cal/mag every couple weeks along with nitrate and phosphate. Once the tank is dialed in and you dont see any large swings just keep performing your same routine everyday with regular weekly/bi weekly testing.

This is how I maintain my 29g nano cube that only has zoas. 99% of the time regular water changes keep up with everything but Mag seeing I use purple instant ocean, so I typically just dose my new saltwater to the desired mag level.
When do you typically run the water testing? A couple of days after a water change?
So for a new system I'm mainly worried about testing alk until i have everything dialed in.

Alk ill test every 2-3 days but only if i have corals in tank. No corals then water changes will take care anything needed since there will be no consumption unless you have something like coralline algae consuming it.

Mag/cal ill only test 1 time a week. And again only when i have corals.

Nitrate/phosphate also 1 time a week unless I'm having issues keeping them stable then I'm testing every 2-3 days as well.

Salinity once a week just for peace of mind even though it shouldn't fluctuate as long as you have an ATO

When it comes to parameters after a water change i typically know around what the new saltwater is at so i personality do not test after. I use instant oceans purple bag which typically runs around 9.5 alk, i like to test alk on a new batch of salt just to know what its running at. But a 10% wc on my system hardly fluctuates any parameters seeing its around 100g total volume
 
So for a new system I'm mainly worried about testing alk until i have everything dialed in.

Alk ill test every 2-3 days but only if i have corals in tank. No corals then water changes will take care anything needed since there will be no consumption unless you have something like coralline algae consuming it.

Mag/cal ill only test 1 time a week. And again only when i have corals.

Nitrate/phosphate also 1 time a week unless I'm having issues keeping them stable then I'm testing every 2-3 days as well.

Salinity once a week just for peace of mind even though it shouldn't fluctuate as long as you have an ATO

When it comes to parameters after a water change i typically know around what the new saltwater is at so i personality do not test after. I use instant oceans purple bag which typically runs around 9.5 alk, i like to test alk on a new batch of salt just to know what its running at. But a 10% wc on my system hardly fluctuates any parameters seeing its around 100g total volume
Cool. I currently have 2 clown fish, 1 anenome, 1 daisy polyp (think it's technically a coral?), 7 snails, and 1 hermit crab. Also I have macroalgae and about 18 pounds of Live Rock
 
So for a new system I'm mainly worried about testing alk until i have everything dialed in.

Alk ill test every 2-3 days but only if i have corals in tank. No corals then water changes will take care anything needed since there will be no consumption unless you have something like coralline algae consuming it.

Mag/cal ill only test 1 time a week. And again only when i have corals.

Nitrate/phosphate also 1 time a week unless I'm having issues keeping them stable then I'm testing every 2-3 days as well.

Salinity once a week just for peace of mind even though it shouldn't fluctuate as long as you have an ATO

When it comes to parameters after a water change i typically know around what the new saltwater is at so i personality do not test after. I use instant oceans purple bag which typically runs around 9.5 alk, i like to test alk on a new batch of salt just to know what its running at. But a 10% wc on my system hardly fluctuates any parameters seeing its around 100g total volume
Thanks for the info! I don't have an ATO. I use salt/ocean water from my LFS. I do 2 cups water change ever day and then 10% wc once a week
 
Cool. I currently have 2 clown fish, 1 anenome, 1 daisy polyp (think it's technically a coral?), 7 snails, and 1 hermit crab. Also I have macroalgae and about 18 pounds of Live Rock

Yea the polyp is just a soft coral typically easier to care for, just ensure you have plenty of nutrients in the system and stable parameters

Thanks for the info! I don't have an ATO. I use salt/ocean water from my LFS. I do 2 cups water change ever day and then 10% wc once a week

Welcome! And is there a reason why you do a daily and weekly wc? Being a small tank I would watch your nitrate and phosphate to ensure you dont strip the nutrients, and id recommend a ATO for stability. I run HydroFill ATO on both my tanks, it has the conductivity sensors and I really like how it works. Id recommend a good ATO that runs the conductivity sensors to anyone that plans to add one to a tank
 
Yea the polyp is just a soft coral typically easier to care for, just ensure you have plenty of nutrients in the system and stable parameters



Welcome! And is there a reason why you do a daily and weekly wc? Being a small tank I would watch your nitrate and phosphate to ensure you dont strip the nutrients, and id recommend a ATO for stability. I run HydroFill ATO on both my tanks, it has the conductivity sensors and I really like how it works. Id recommend a good ATO that runs the conductivity sensors to anyone that plans to add one to a tank
I was told by my LFS to do weekly 10% wc’s and 16 oz wc every day for best results. Idk I’m just going off what they told me. I think I tend to obsess a little too much on water parameters and need to learn to let the tank run its course (of course with supervision). I’m new, but wanting to learn and keep these tank healthy and everything in it.
 
I was told by my LFS to do weekly 10% wc’s and 16 oz wc every day for best results. Idk I’m just going off what they told me. I think I tend to obsess a little too much on water parameters and need to learn to let the tank run its course (of course with supervision). I’m new, but wanting to learn and keep these tank healthy and everything in it.

Usually most use 1 or the other when it comes to water changes, not saying both can not be done or shouldnt be done. Best advice I can give is do what works for you and your system, if this works and you see no negatives performing wc this way then keep it up! More than 1 way to skin a cat 😉

Are you keeping track of your salinity daily? And what do you use to measure salinity? 1 problem I can see coming from no ATO and daily wc with another source of water that is not made by you is salinity especially in a small system can easily fluctuate
 
Hey! Noobie here. I have a 20 gallon tank with 2 clown fish, an anemone, 6 snails, hermit crab, and a daisy polyp. Tank is fully cycled.

Question about testing water parameters… Which test kits do you prefer? I have the Hanna Master Kit but it seems overwhelming to use and also seems like it’ll be expensive (other than the big $450 price tag) with all the raedant packets to buy. I also have API master kits (Reef and Saltwater). I’m thinking about returning one of these, but not sure. Or maybe a different brand?

Also, how often should I be checking? And which parameters are the most important to check?

TIA
I love my hanna master and other good option - Salifert but prefer the digital readouts
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT KIND OF REEFING DEAL ARE YOU HOPING TO PICK UP THIS BLACK FRIDAY?

  • A whole new aquarium or complete system

    Votes: 2 9.5%
  • Lighting, pumps, or other major equipment

    Votes: 3 14.3%
  • Controllers, testing, dosing, or automation gear

    Votes: 2 9.5%
  • Dry goods and restocks, like salt, media, or food

    Votes: 2 9.5%
  • Corals! Must...Have...CORALS!!!

    Votes: 5 23.8%
  • Fish or other livestock

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Rock, sand, or other aquascaping supplies

    Votes: 1 4.8%
  • I’m browsing, but don’t have a specific target

    Votes: 4 19.0%
  • I’m not shopping for reef deals this year

    Votes: 1 4.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 1 4.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new