Under-Inflated Anemones...

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
6,375
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Currently, I have two tanks that contain Anemones. The first is a 125-gallon tank with sump for a total of 145 gallons. In this tank, the Anemones seem healthy except for their size; they are grossly under-inflated and have been this way since being placed in the tank. This is what they look like:

IMG_9932.jpeg

The second tank is a total of 25 gallons between tank and sump. And this is what the Anemones in this tank look like:

IMG_9933.jpeg

I have attached my water test results for the 125-gallon. The only difference in the water quality of the 125 and the 25 is that the 125 has no detectable nitrates, while the 25 gallon tank has nitrates of 20.

I've been supplementing https://www.bulkreefsupply.com/neon...D=4575&indexName=brs_prod_m2_default_products. in effort to get my nitrates up. Since starting this, I've developed some algae on the back of the tank, but my nitrates are only at 1.

I've also pulled my protein skimmer and all mechanical filtration, but still my nitrates are not coming up.

Not to mention that I don't know if lack of nitrates is the issue with the Anemones in question.

Any suggestions?

Thank you,
Dom



DateTimeSalinitypHNitrateAlkalinityCalciumMagnesiumNotes
04/16/202312:00 PM36.007.130.0013.00350.001,520.00Pre Water Change
04/18/202312:00 PM33.008.000.0010.10350.001,600.00Post Water Change. Skimmer off to elevate Nitrates.
04/20/202312:00 PM33.008.000.008.40320.001,600.00(40ml Foundation A - Calcium) (10ml Foundation B – Alkalinity)
04/21/202312:15 PM35.008.010.007.60320.001,600.00(15gms baking soda – Alkalinity)
04/22/202312:10 PM34.008.000.008.70350.001,500.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/23/202303:00 PM33.008.050.008.10360.001,600.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/24/202311:30 AM33.008.000.008.40390.001,680.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/25/202302:40 PM34.008.080.009.50420.001,520.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/26/202302:00 PM35.008.040.008.40400.001,520.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (30ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/27/202312:30 PM34.008.02x8.70380.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/28/202312:30 PMx8.01x8.40400.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/29/202301:35 PMx8.04xxxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/30/202301:20 PMx8.00x7.80440.00x(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/01/202312:20 PMxxx8.55620.00x(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/02/202311:30 AMxxx9.80450.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/03/202302:00 PM35.008.050.008.10450.001,880.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (5ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/04/202312:40 PM34.008.010.007.90480.001,600.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/05/202301:10 PM35.008.000.00xxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/06/202312:00 PMxx0.00xxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/07/202303:10 PMxxxxxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/08/202311:10 AM35.007.960.007.60500.001,600.00(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (15ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/09/202312:20 PM35.008.011.507.60500.001,720.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/10/202301:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/11/202302:50 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/12/202301:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/13/202302:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/14/202301:45 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/15/202311:15 AM35.007.971.008.10490.001,680.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/16/202301:30 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (5ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/17/202302:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (5ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
 

MAH

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 24, 2022
Messages
57
Reaction score
18
Location
Baltimore, MD
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
You might try posting this in the clownfish/anemone forum if you haven't already.
 

vetteguy53081

Well known Member and monster tank lover
View Badges
Joined
Aug 11, 2013
Messages
91,939
Reaction score
203,069
Location
Wisconsin -
Rating - 100%
13   0   0
Currently, I have two tanks that contain Anemones. The first is a 125-gallon tank with sump for a total of 145 gallons. In this tank, the Anemones seem healthy except for their size; they are grossly under-inflated and have been this way since being placed in the tank. This is what they look like:

IMG_9932.jpeg

The second tank is a total of 25 gallons between tank and sump. And this is what the Anemones in this tank look like:

IMG_9933.jpeg

I have attached my water test results for the 125-gallon. The only difference in the water quality of the 125 and the 25 is that the 125 has no detectable nitrates, while the 25 gallon tank has nitrates of 20.

I've been supplementing https://www.bulkreefsupply.com/neon...D=4575&indexName=brs_prod_m2_default_products. in effort to get my nitrates up. Since starting this, I've developed some algae on the back of the tank, but my nitrates are only at 1.

I've also pulled my protein skimmer and all mechanical filtration, but still my nitrates are not coming up.

Not to mention that I don't know if lack of nitrates is the issue with the Anemones in question.

Any suggestions?

Thank you,
Dom



DateTimeSalinitypHNitrateAlkalinityCalciumMagnesiumNotes
04/16/202312:00 PM36.007.130.0013.00350.001,520.00Pre Water Change
04/18/202312:00 PM33.008.000.0010.10350.001,600.00Post Water Change. Skimmer off to elevate Nitrates.
04/20/202312:00 PM33.008.000.008.40320.001,600.00(40ml Foundation A - Calcium) (10ml Foundation B – Alkalinity)
04/21/202312:15 PM35.008.010.007.60320.001,600.00(15gms baking soda – Alkalinity)
04/22/202312:10 PM34.008.000.008.70350.001,500.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/23/202303:00 PM33.008.050.008.10360.001,600.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/24/202311:30 AM33.008.000.008.40390.001,680.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/25/202302:40 PM34.008.080.009.50420.001,520.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/26/202302:00 PM35.008.040.008.40400.001,520.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (30ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/27/202312:30 PM34.008.02x8.70380.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/28/202312:30 PMx8.01x8.40400.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/29/202301:35 PMx8.04xxxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/30/202301:20 PMx8.00x7.80440.00x(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/01/202312:20 PMxxx8.55620.00x(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/02/202311:30 AMxxx9.80450.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/03/202302:00 PM35.008.050.008.10450.001,880.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (5ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/04/202312:40 PM34.008.010.007.90480.001,600.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/05/202301:10 PM35.008.000.00xxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/06/202312:00 PMxx0.00xxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/07/202303:10 PMxxxxxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/08/202311:10 AM35.007.960.007.60500.001,600.00(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (15ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/09/202312:20 PM35.008.011.507.60500.001,720.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/10/202301:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/11/202302:50 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/12/202301:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/13/202302:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/14/202301:45 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/15/202311:15 AM35.007.971.008.10490.001,680.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/16/202301:30 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (5ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/17/202302:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (5ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
The anemones look good. Its not6 always do bubble-tips inflate. The concern is color and eating and yours look ok other than the typical bulbs we often by them to enjoy
 
OP
OP
Dom

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
6,375
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The anemones look good. Its not6 always do bubble-tips inflate. The concern is color and eating and yours look ok other than the typical bulbs we often by them to enjoy

So you're saying that this could be normal?

I was thinking about moving them to the 25 and see if they inflate. This would be a good way to tell if it was water quality.
 
OP
OP
Dom

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
6,375
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
You might try posting this in the clownfish/anemone forum if you haven't already.
Hadn't thought of that. Typically, I post here because of the high volume of traffic.
 

vetteguy53081

Well known Member and monster tank lover
View Badges
Joined
Aug 11, 2013
Messages
91,939
Reaction score
203,069
Location
Wisconsin -
Rating - 100%
13   0   0
So you're saying that this could be normal?

I was thinking about moving them to the 25 and see if they inflate. This would be a good way to tell if it was water quality.
Mine come and go with inflation but not inflated for the most part over two years
 

Nano_Man

Anemone L
View Badges
Joined
Jan 7, 2023
Messages
4,447
Reaction score
18,979
Location
Usa
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
You carnt second guess them
In the photo they look fine . The only things to watch out for are gaping mouth for a length of time. Not able to foot anything and bits dropping off them . My nems close up at night and open up during the day . I feed them once a week with mysis and look to see if there eating. Yours look healthy and happy .
Dom is your nitrate 0
My nitrate is 10 and phosphate 0.03
I’ve read a lot of people saying nems like some nitrate and phosphate this only my experience with them
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
Dom

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
6,375
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Dom is your nitrate 0
My nitrate is 10 and phosphate 0.03
I’ve read a lot of people saying nems like some nitrate and phosphate this only my experience with them

Yes, I've read the same. It is why I've pulled my protein skimmer and started adding Nitro. I'd like to get my Nitrates up to 20, which is where the 25 gallon tank currently sits.
 

FisheRare

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Messages
53
Reaction score
8
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Currently, I have two tanks that contain Anemones. The first is a 125-gallon tank with sump for a total of 145 gallons. In this tank, the Anemones seem healthy except for their size; they are grossly under-inflated and have been this way since being placed in the tank. This is what they look like:

IMG_9932.jpeg

The second tank is a total of 25 gallons between tank and sump. And this is what the Anemones in this tank look like:

IMG_9933.jpeg

I have attached my water test results for the 125-gallon. The only difference in the water quality of the 125 and the 25 is that the 125 has no detectable nitrates, while the 25 gallon tank has nitrates of 20.

I've been supplementing https://www.bulkreefsupply.com/neon...D=4575&indexName=brs_prod_m2_default_products. in effort to get my nitrates up. Since starting this, I've developed some algae on the back of the tank, but my nitrates are only at 1.

I've also pulled my protein skimmer and all mechanical filtration, but still my nitrates are not coming up.

Not to mention that I don't know if lack of nitrates is the issue with the Anemones in question.

Any suggestions?

Thank you,
Dom



DateTimeSalinitypHNitrateAlkalinityCalciumMagnesiumNotes
04/16/202312:00 PM36.007.130.0013.00350.001,520.00Pre Water Change
04/18/202312:00 PM33.008.000.0010.10350.001,600.00Post Water Change. Skimmer off to elevate Nitrates.
04/20/202312:00 PM33.008.000.008.40320.001,600.00(40ml Foundation A - Calcium) (10ml Foundation B – Alkalinity)
04/21/202312:15 PM35.008.010.007.60320.001,600.00(15gms baking soda – Alkalinity)
04/22/202312:10 PM34.008.000.008.70350.001,500.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/23/202303:00 PM33.008.050.008.10360.001,600.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/24/202311:30 AM33.008.000.008.40390.001,680.00(10gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (40ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/25/202302:40 PM34.008.080.009.50420.001,520.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/26/202302:00 PM35.008.040.008.40400.001,520.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (30ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/27/202312:30 PM34.008.02x8.70380.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/28/202312:30 PMx8.01x8.40400.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/29/202301:35 PMx8.04xxxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
04/30/202301:20 PMx8.00x7.80440.00x(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (25ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/01/202312:20 PMxxx8.55620.00x(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/02/202311:30 AMxxx9.80450.00x(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium)
05/03/202302:00 PM35.008.050.008.10450.001,880.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (5ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/04/202312:40 PM34.008.010.007.90480.001,600.00(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/05/202301:10 PM35.008.000.00xxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/06/202312:00 PMxx0.00xxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/07/202303:10 PMxxxxxx(5gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (20ml Foundation A – Calcium) (10ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/08/202311:10 AM35.007.960.007.60500.001,600.00(6gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (15ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/09/202312:20 PM35.008.011.507.60500.001,720.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/10/202301:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/11/202302:50 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/12/202301:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/13/202302:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/14/202301:45 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (15ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/15/202311:15 AM35.007.971.008.10490.001,680.00(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (10ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/16/202301:30 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (5ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
05/17/202302:00 PMxxxxxx(7gms baking soda – Alkalinity) (5ml Foundation A – Calcium) (20ml Nitro – Nitrates)
I like the way you set up your chart
 

Reefing threads: Do you wear gear from reef brands?

  • I wear reef gear everywhere.

    Votes: 46 16.5%
  • I wear reef gear primarily at fish events and my LFS.

    Votes: 18 6.5%
  • I wear reef gear primarily for water changes and tank maintenance.

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • I wear reef gear primarily to relax where I live.

    Votes: 35 12.6%
  • I don’t wear gear from reef brands.

    Votes: 159 57.2%
  • Other.

    Votes: 19 6.8%
Back
Top