I've been struggling with this same issue. I've read a lot about it and have had a lot of great comments from others about it, but the numbers I get don't match what I keep hearing. I have a heavy SPS tank and use Instant Ocean Reef Crystals and my Alk dosing is considerably higher (over twice as much per day) than my calcium dosing. I tried matching the two amounts for a few days and my calcium shot way up. I tried dosing less alk and sure enough my values droped way below where I want them. In just a couple of days it was 150ppm vs the 180 ppm I had before. With stability being so important, I was afraid I was going to start killing off corals. I went back to the daily does that keeps each value where I want it. Everything in the tank looks happy and the numbers test properly. I've calibrated my test kits and believe the results I'm seeing.
However, my sandbed is clumping up in some places, and I think the extra alk is going towards that. I dose magnesium by the gallon when I use up a gallon of Alk and it seems to keep the mag value where I want it. I'm not sure what the answer is.