Using ChatGPT to acclimate a new fish with a big salinity change

  • Thread starter Thread starter ajmckay
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

ajmckay

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 29, 2016
Messages
72
Reaction score
58
Location
SE Michigan
What state or country do you live in
Michigan
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
1000015657.jpg


Got a shark nose goby! I've been looking around for one for a while with no luck until I stopped at a PetCo of all places...

Adding it to a pico with only inverts currently.

The issue is the water in the bag is 28ppt (1.021sg) and my tank is at 35ppt (1.026 SG). That's way too big a change for a standard drip acclimation and if I'm not careful could end up causing osmotic shock. I haven't found a specific rate of increase that's known to be safe, but my experience is that ~3ppt (~0.002 sg) increase over 24 hrs is safe. Haven't experimented beyond that until now.

My QT is currently in use. So I decided to meet in the middle. I'm going to drop the salinity of my pico tank to 33ppt (1.025 sg) over some hours. That way the new fish only has to go up 5ppt vs 7ppt. That's 1.021 to 1.025. still a huge change but it will be over 16 transfusions. I was going to do every 30 min but now I'm thinking per hour. Including sleep time total acclimation will be roughly 24hrs.

Anyways I could do the math if I wanted but decided to use ChatGPT. First it gave me the wrong number for lowering the tanks salinity. It wanted me to change out 3.8L of water for fresh, in a 4g pico!! After I pointed that out it changed to 380ml which seems more realistic.

For the bag, it said 26ml per transfusion which I think seems about right given the roughly 250ml in the bag. Note this is maintaining a constant water amount in the bag not the usual method of doubling then halving. I show that as 0.3ppt per transfusion or 0.0002 sg.

So that's the plan seeing as I don't have a QT available. I thought it was a useful utilization of AI compared to the sea of mostly useless things people do with it. Obviously you still have to know the process but while I was freaking out the salinity difference was so high using this to do the math was indeed helpful.

Still in the middle of this but seems to be going well so far. Will update with results.
 
As an update read this and it helped put things in perspective a bit. https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/acclimation-methods.903/

Normally I use a QT and adjust the water to exactly what the bag water is and put the fish in with pretty quick acclimation. This time I figured I wouldn't need to QT since it's going to be the only fish for a bit and it's captive bred to boot.

Also of importance, the fish was in transport for ~10 minutes in an insulated container.

So what I wish I would have known earlier was 0.004 difference is actually okay. I initially had 0.005 but lowered the tank by 0.001 so I'm within the 0.004 threshold. I think I'm still going to keep doing what I have been, but I'm going to probably speed it up 4x until I hit 90% equilibration.
 
Last edited:
Chat Gpt is poor at math and seems to make unit of measure errors in calculations. I do not recommend using it.
 
Just dump the fish in the tank next time. They are way less sensitive to salinity changes than ppl think.
Some vendors seem to love low salinity for SW fish; disease mitigation I believe…
Anyway, this seems to be the norm and is irritating from a acclimation POV…
Anyway, yeah some fish can be touchy but 28ppt to 35ppt shouldn't take that long…Id be more worried about the water going south
 
Chat Gpt is poor at math and seems to make unit of measure errors in calculations. I do not recommend using it.
I was actually surprised to find this. You know - since it's a computer. But yes it did make a pretty big error. And even then the 380mL was wrong because after 2 transfusions the salinity was 33.5ppt.
For reference here's the chat with the calcs: https://chatgpt.com/share/678d971c-733c-800f-9923-ae82d6dba66b

agree that ChatGPT is poor with math problems but some of that is due to poor units be used by companies in literature
I haven't used it much for that - I guess it's too busy making fake images and scamming people to improve the math aspect. I've also tried to use it for 3D modeling and the results are never useable. Granted I'm using the free version so it's probably nerfed.

Just dump the fish in the tank next time. They are way less sensitive to salinity changes than ppl think.
That seems like a big change to just dump immediately. Though I agree I was probably taking too long. The stores I usually buy from keep their salinity higher though. It was unexpected and my QT was already in use.

Some vendors seem to love low salinity for SW fish; disease mitigation I believe…
Anyway, this seems to be the norm and is irritating from a acclimation POV…
Anyway, yeah some fish can be touchy but 28ppt to 35ppt shouldn't take that long…Id be more worried about the water going south
Yeah lesson learned. I feel like it would be helpful for stores to post their water parameters for people to see. Salinity in particular. Just so people are aware. I'm sure there are some animals which don't handle the change as well. Like there were snails, anemones, and crabs in the same tank at PetCo. IME that's too big a change for inverts, which I always acclimate slow.

Thanks everyone for the replies. It was an interesting experiment for me, and at the very least an attempt to use ChatGPT for something useful. I doubt it will be much longer before we have AI washing in the aquarium world.
 
Yeah lesson learned. I feel like it would be helpful for stores to post their water parameters for people to see. Salinity in particular. Just so people are aware. I'm sure there are some animals which don't handle the change as well. Like there were snails, anemones, and crabs in the same tank at PetCo. IME that's too big a change for inverts, which I always acclimate slow.
I take a Hanna salinity tester and test the water in any lfs before purchasing. Or I only buy fish kept with corals and / or inverts. Many lfs keep salinity low and tell people it prevents disease when in fact it just suppresses it. I got burned years ago buying an emperor angel from a tank than unknown to me was at 1.015 salinity. Shortly after the fish was acclimated to 1.025 it ended up with velvet.
 
I take a Hanna salinity tester and test the water in any lfs before purchasing. Or I only buy fish kept with corals and / or inverts. Many lfs keep salinity low and tell people it prevents disease when in fact it just suppresses it. I got burned years ago buying an emperor angel from a tank than unknown to me was at 1.015 salinity. Shortly after the fish was acclimated to 1.025 it ended up with velvet.
Not a bad idea especially if you're at a store you don't normally go to.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new