What level nutrients you running for reef tank?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ctylermast
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Tank with ‘high’ nutrients.
IMG_1589.jpeg
1000014307.jpeg
 
Nitrate 10-20ppm
Phosphate .1 to .2ppm
Also get sunlight into the reef lol

I try to always have a good amount of nitrate / phosphate for the nems
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3369.jpeg
    IMG_3369.jpeg
    287.4 KB · Views: 71
Nitrate 10-20ppm
Phosphate .1 to .2ppm
Also get sunlight into the reef lol

I try to always have a good amount of nitrate / phosphate for the nems
I am setting up my new tank so that it will get the evening sun. I love how tanks look under natural sunlight. Yours looks fantastic sir!
 
For years I kept all my systems at:
Po4 <.1.
No3 < 5.
New range is
Po4 .1-.2
No3 10-20
Current level today
Po4- .117
No3 10
I adjust po4 when it gets to .2 with 1/2 cup gfo. This slowly brings it down to .1 then it goes back to .2 over a 2 week period, rinse repeat.

No3 is kept between between 10- 20 with Vodka dosing.
Visually no differene at either levels.
20260124_163305.jpg
 
I am setting up my new tank so that it will get the evening sun. I love how tanks look under natural sunlight. Yours looks fantastic sir!
Thank you! I’m glad my tank is by huge open windows , easy to stabilize ph and free lighting
 
I think the idea that one can deter algae by keeping nutrients low has limited utility since to drive nutrients low enough that algae is killed is also hurting corals.
Not to derail the thread, but what then would cause an algae bloom in a "mature" tank that was consistent otherwise?

I recently saw an outbreak of ulva. The only thing I noticed was my nutrients which were usually 5ppm NO3 and <0.05 po4, had shot up to about 20ppm NO3 and 0.27 po4 over the course of 2 months. Feeding and fish bioload remained constant.

My theory was I had a cUc that worked for a lower nutrient level, but with this increased level, I needed a larger cUc.
 
How do you avoid algeas when keeping your nutrients in those levels
I've never found high nutrients to be a cause of nuisance algae. Two tank with N and P at or near 0

PXL_20240713_002223951~2.jpg


PXL_20250629_175245566.jpg


This tank runs NO3 15-40 PO4 0.4-0.9+ (not 0.04)

PXL_20251108_012602277~2.jpg



EDIT:: I may as well add this one since its a tweener and runs N and P near 0 and I have to dose ammonium and PO4 but has little to no nuisance algae unlike the tanks above. I can't explain the reasons because understanding why tanks can run similar levels but look so different is a mystery to me.

At or near 0 N and P for 3 years in this one.

PXL_20251108_014004983~2.jpg
 
Last edited:
Not to derail the thread, but what then would cause an algae bloom in a "mature" tank that was consistent otherwise?

I recently saw an outbreak of ulva. The only thing I noticed was my nutrients which were usually 5ppm NO3 and <0.05 po4, had shot up to about 20ppm NO3 and 0.27 po4 over the course of 2 months. Feeding and fish bioload remained constant.

My theory was I had a cUc that worked for a lower nutrient level, but with this increased level, I needed a larger cUc.

Not sure how all encompassing you want the "consistent otherwise", but certainly if nothing, meaning actual nothing, else changes except nitrate or phosphate rise, and algae worsens, then yes, it is from the nutrients.

But that's more of a theoretical question, not real question. There's no scenario in a reef tank where nutrients rise and nothing else happened unless you changed nothing for an extended period and then dosed one or both of those chemicals. If your nutrients rose that large amount, why was that, and why assume it did not impact all sorts of other things, such as organics, trace elements, bacterial and other species present, etc.?.

That said, I certainly agree that if phosphate is low enough (you just give an upper limit not a value) then it can certainly limit corals and algae. If phosphate is 0.001 ppm and then becomes 0.27 ppm, then phosphate was likely limiting algae growth and then stopped being the limiting factor in algae growth.

I also agree that the more conducive the tank is to algae growth, for a large range of reasons, the larger of a clean up crew is needed.
 
Not sure how all encompassing you want the "consistent otherwise", but certainly if nothing, meaning actual nothing, else changes except nitrate or phosphate rise, and algae worsens, then yes, it is from the nutrients.

But that's more of a theoretical question, not real question. There's no scenario in a reef tank where nutrients rise and nothing else happened unless you changed nothing for an extended period and then dosed one or both of those chemicals. If your nutrients rose that large amount, why was that, and why assume it did not impact all sorts of other things, such as organics, trace elements, bacterial and other species present, etc.?.

That said, I certainly agree that if phosphate is low enough (you just give an upper limit not a value) then it can certainly limit corals and algae. If phosphate is 0.001 ppm and then becomes 0.27 ppm, then phosphate was likely limiting algae growth and then stopped being the limiting factor in algae growth.

I also agree that the more conducive the tank is to algae growth, for a large range of reasons, the larger of a clean up crew is needed.
I see what you're saying, in a theorictical situation where literally nothing else changes except for nitrate and phosphate, while algae worsened, then one could conclude it was nutrients.

I made the mistake of not including it in my original question, but the one thing that changed during this time, was not cleaning my skimmer cup. I was trying to increase nutrient levels to give myself a buffer. But in doing so, it seems I suffered from some unintended side effects.

Since my nutrients during this period were generally within that wide range you recommended, I think I can conclude I could've likely avoided the outbreak with a larger clean up crew.
 
Since my nutrients during this period were generally within that wide range you recommended, I think I can conclude I could've likely avoided the outbreak with a larger clean up crew.

A large enough clean up crew will keep just about any tank clean, but they then risk starvation when its totally clean. It's a balancing act. :)
 
I don't usually talk about my nutrients....

Last night's check was:

Nitrates - 17
Phosphates - 0.59 😬

1000008755.jpg
Mine too. Last week my nitrates were 20 and phosphates were .5 or a bit more. But my tank does fine, just like yours which seems to be flourishing!

 
A large enough clean up crew will keep just about any tank clean, but they then risk starvation when its totally clean. It's a balancing act. :)
It's definitely a balancing act that comes from experience.
Fish, snails, crabs, urchins, star fish and others all play a role no matter what nutrient levels you decide to run.
It's one of the cool parts of reefing when you get it dialed in. Not much to do but clean the glass.
 
Mine too. Last week my nitrates were 20 and phosphates were .5 or a bit more. But my tank does fine, just like yours which seems to be flourishing!


I love the Leafy Sea Dragons!
 
I love the Leafy Sea Dragons!
Aw thanks! Its an acknowledgement to my 6 years of keeping seahorses! I did love them but not a low maintenance aquatic pet.
 
Two years in after a 22 year hiatus. Just wrapped up 6 months of unexpected hair algae.

Nitrates are now stabilize around 11ppm Abdul is about where I’ve wanted to see them. Managing phosphate with Lanthium currently around .06ppm looking to stay under .1
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 15 35.7%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 1 2.4%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 33.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 12 28.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new