I met Ben at our local shop over the weekend and I have alot of the same problems. I have some colonies of sps that grow amazingly well. For instance i bought a piece of the ora birdsnest, about a 1 inch frag and 6 months later its the size of a grapefruit. I have monti's, validas and chesterfieldensis that grow just as well. Yet, every time i buy small frags of corals, they do great for a month or two then they just develope white band. I'll frag them, they will re-grow and then get white band again. All the while my large colonies are doing fantastic. My tank is a very different setup than Ben's but like him my paramaters are really good. 1400 mag, 480 cal and 9.8 alk. It's very frustrating when you have many sps corals thrive in your system then have frags get white band for unseeable reasons.