What's your most important advice for getting a mandarin for a beginner

  • Thread starter Thread starter Redbird5
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
I may have missed it but what size tank do you have and how long has it been running?
 
"If you have to ask this many questions, I would not get a mandarine yet."
This is what I'm talking about.

Fist of all, I was not the person who said that. Even more odd that you quoted my posts and still didn't catch your error.

Secondly, the advice that you misattributed to me is reasonable in context, even if a bit brash.

1757446650651.png


His advice was to ask more questions ad do more research before moving forward.

The underlying fact here is that these are extremely popular fish, but most perish in captivity because people convince themselves, and allow others to convince them that they can be trained to eat prepared food and that providing ample pods is easy.
 
Second TDO Cromaboost Pellets. Mine eats those also. Experts say that these WC fish feed on exclusively live PODS may not be entirely true. I suspect they also sometimes eat small bits of dead food in the wild. While else would they accept dead food in an Aquarium. Sure, Pods are preferred, however when they are hungry like mine in the morning before the lights come on, Pellets will do. And no offense to Bean, but you have examples in this Post alone of Hobbyists feeding food other that Pods.
 
Safe to assume those pellets sink then even though small? I have some small Hikari pellets and I hate them they float on top of water until they make their way to the overflow
 
Over the years I've brought in many Mandarins, both wild collected and tank-raised from a couple different sources.

Unfortunately, the tank-raised can be very small and I've had many tank-raised come in that were paper thin and never ate any prepared foods. I've spoken with the folks that raise them numerous times about how thin they are when they arrive and they simply say feed pellets. It's absurd that any truly tank-raised fish shouldn't arrive fat and eat all types of food. Unfortunately, this is definitely not always the case, so be a bit careful. In my opinion, all tank-raised Mandarins should be at least 1.5 inches when sold, even if the price must be higher, and be eating all types of prepared foods. If not, my opinion is don't buy them. Certainly some survive and thrive, but a lot more don't.

While the wild collected can be more difficult to get to eat, they are much larger and can be more substantial, so if they don't eat right away they won't die as quickly as a super thin tiny tank-raised Mandarin. My most successful initial food is frozen Spirulina Enhanced Brine Shrimp, many will eat it. From there you can get them to eat a variety. If you can see them eating at a local store, then go for them. Personally, I never bring in wild collected, just too few really thrive.

Overall, in my experience of handling a lot of them, they can be difficult whether tank-raised or wild collected. Your best bet is to go to a store that sells tank-raised and ask them to feed them and then pick one that's eating and fat, and not too tiny.
 
Just grow your own phyto. Dosing phyto will sustain a pod population. I've had a wild mandarin for 3 years in a 32 gallon AIO, but I've been growing my own phyto for that length of time as well. I've never had to spot feed my mandarin and it hasn't taken to prepared foods at all.
Did you have a refugium?
 
Did you have a refugium?
No, it's a 32g all in one. I have pods everywhere though.
P_20250412_154025.jpg


I have too much coral, so to be fair if I see my mandarin, it's a rare sighting. I actually do spot feed baby brine shrimp with the pumps off to get a good sighting of her, but I don't have to. She's plump.
 
I just got my first mandarin a few months ago. I spent almost a year stocking it with pods. I also added a hotel to the display and fuge. I also about to start culture my own pods and phytoplankton just to be safe. Plus, pods are great for any tank.
 
No, it's a 32g all in one. I have pods everywhere though.
P_20250412_154025.jpg


I have too much coral, so to be fair if I see my mandarin, it's a rare sighting. I actually do spot feed baby brine shrimp with the pumps off to get a good sighting of her, but I don't have to. She's plump.
holy coral batman lol
 
I have my heart set on getting a mandarin goby. I'm not going into this blind, as I know they have a special diet that they need. I've been seeding my aquarium with pods for a few months. I've added two bottles of pods over the last two months. I've added plankton to the aquarium.

My LFS said that I should be fine if I add another bottle of pods.

I'm thinking in November I'll get my mandarin. During that two months I want to research everything I can about mandarins.

Other than seeding my aquarium with pods what else can I do? What is something you wished you had known about mandarins before you got one? Should I spot feed them directly?
Since I lost my lawnmower blenny on Tuesday I've been spot feeding everyone in my aquarium, so I know everyone gets food.

I intend to set up a pico reef aquarium, can I add copepods to it so I don't have to constantly buy bottles of them for my big aquarium?
This is so simple and easy that it’s sick. Just add a few pieces of densely branched coralheads to your rocks. It has too be tightly branched so that fish can’t get into the gaps in the middle. Pods will have a secure place to hide away. And when they feel secure, they multiply like crazy. One note, if you add coralheads, you always have to have a mandarin, a pipefish, seahorse or some other dedicated pod predator. The tank gets really “buggy” if you don’t.
 
I have my heart set on getting a mandarin goby. I'm not going into this blind, as I know they have a special diet that they need. I've been seeding my aquarium with pods for a few months. I've added two bottles of pods over the last two months. I've added plankton to the aquarium.

My LFS said that I should be fine if I add another bottle of pods.

I'm thinking in November I'll get my mandarin. During that two months I want to research everything I can about mandarins.

Other than seeding my aquarium with pods what else can I do? What is something you wished you had known about mandarins before you got one? Should I spot feed them directly?
Since I lost my lawnmower blenny on Tuesday I've been spot feeding everyone in my aquarium, so I know everyone gets food.

I intend to set up a pico reef aquarium, can I add copepods to it so I don't have to constantly buy bottles of them for my big aquarium?
Just get a pair from biota they eat pellets
 
Don’t over think it, I buy pods from algae barn to constantly ensure a good population in my reef. Some will say it gets expensive this way but everything in this hobby is expensive. It’s a cost I’m happy to pay to ensure a healthy and happy fish. I have 2 pod hotels in my sump and they are always chock full, but I’ll still add more to always ensure it never goes hungry.
 
I have my heart set on getting a mandarin goby. I'm not going into this blind, as I know they have a special diet that they need. I've been seeding my aquarium with pods for a few months. I've added two bottles of pods over the last two months. I've added plankton to the aquarium.

My LFS said that I should be fine if I add another bottle of pods.

I'm thinking in November I'll get my mandarin. During that two months I want to research everything I can about mandarins.

Other than seeding my aquarium with pods what else can I do? What is something you wished you had known about mandarins before you got one? Should I spot feed them directly?
Since I lost my lawnmower blenny on Tuesday I've been spot feeding everyone in my aquarium, so I know everyone gets food.

I intend to set up a pico reef aquarium, can I add copepods to it so I don't have to constantly buy bottles of them for my big aquarium?
I’m sorry, but I do not think you should try and keep a mandarin in a 2 1/2 gallon aquarium if that’s what you’re planning.
 
I’m sorry, but I do not think you should try and keep a mandarin in a 2 1/2 gallon aquarium if that’s what you’re planning.
It's not going into that aquarium. It'll be going in a 45g. I know it won't be happy in a 2.5g aquarium. That's for the pods.
When I first started studying saltwater aquariums I read a book that advised to consider the happiness, health and lifestyle I could provide a fish. With that said I'd never ever consider adding a mandarin to anything under 30 gallons.
I do exhaustive research before I buy a fish.
 
I’m sorry, but I do not think you should try and keep a mandarin in a 2 1/2 gallon aquarium if that’s what you’re planning.
It's not going into that aquarium. It'll be going in a 45g. I know it won't be happy in a 2.5g aquarium. That's for the pods.
When I first started studying saltwater aquariums I read a book that advised to consider the happiness, health and lifestyle I could provide a fish. With that said I'd never ever consider adding a mandarin to anything under 30 gallons.
I do exhaustive research before I buy a fish.
That’s good
 
I'm sure there's no harm in using them but pod hotels seem like an unnecessary waste of plastic to me. If you want additional surface area for pods, filter sponges have way more surface area and use less plastic.

Commercial operations don't bother with substrate or extra surface area though and the nauplii spend most of their time in the mulm on the bottom of the culture. I'm sure in a sump or refugium though the extra surface area can't hurt.
 
I've heard a lot about giving the captive bred mandarins pellets, but I've never heard what kind of pellets to use. I feed my fish a variety of food, pellets, flakes, frozen mysis and marine cousine with krill, and other stuff I don't remember offhand. I'm seeding the aquarium with pods, I've got live rock in the back of my AIO with lots of live rock in the front of it. Is there's anything else I can do? I'm trying to make a good home for my mandarin and all my fish.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 23.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 10 8.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 45 40.2%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 3 2.7%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 28 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new