White worm breeding and culture.

  • Thread starter Thread starter atoll
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
As you know Randy I also breed pods, brine shrimp and make many other of my own foods not just white worms. They are great for conditioning fish and getting finicky feeds to start. I also dlfeed commercial fish foods like frozen pods, mysis. clam etc.

White worms are also a good food for weight gain for newly introduced fish that are often had a far from healthy diet since capture at the reef to you. Man cannot live by bread alone, fish cannot live by white worms alone.

We also have to remember its not just the worms themselves but also what you feed them with. The best white worms will be gut loaded. I feed various foods to my worms including yeast flakes, yoghurt, organic Sprilina powder and oats.
People often forget about the foods we feed our feed.

Copepods and various shrimp are little different in that respect. I can't back it up with scientific evidence but it makes much sense to me and others.
 
I also feed white worms to the fish in my small pond. My goldfish and white cloud mountain minnows all enjoy them and eat them with gusto. A very cheap and not so difficult food to breed.
 
I know Paul claims that, but it is certainly an unproven hypothesis, especially for an organisms that may have totally different bacteria than exist in the GI tracts of marine fish. But if that is the rationale for the claim, OK. :)

This is true, but despite popular opinion, Paul doesn't make this stuff up as he goes along. (Well, sometimes he does) 🙄
He also doesn't blatantly take the word of a scientist or researcher unless they have an old, healthy reef tank.
Their years in a classroom don't impress me, as there aren't too many "worm courses" and not too many PhDs given out for worms.

I used "blackworms" on my fish for about 50 years, and that's how I discovered " one" aspect of immunity that I have posted numerous times, and one big reason that I do not have to quarantine. But it is only "one"
aspect.

I moved here to eastern Long Island 8 years ago and can't get blackworms here so I discovered whiteworms and tried them. As Atoll said, they are not for every meal because like feeding goldfish, they are lacking in some important nutrients. But I also don't eat cereal or bananas at every meal because I know they also don't supply everything.

We all started this hobby with fresh water and the first thing we read was to get fish to spawn you should feed live foods. Flake and dry foods will keep fish alive, but just barely, as all of it, no matter how much you pay, is ultra-processed with almost 100% manufactured or artificial ingredients, including colors, vitamins, preservatives, and anti-clumping chemicals. In other words, it is garbage and I only sometimes, but rarely, use it to feed my worms.

I feed my worms whole wheat bread with yogurt and nutritional yeast, so they are very healthy and have been spawning and reproducing for about 15 years. The same batch.

I think my 70 years of experience in this hobby allowed me to learn a few things, even if you say it is un-proven. And white worms are one thing I learned about. But I still don't eat them myself. 🤮

People who don't feed whiteworms have to prove something, not us with the oldest tanks on here and every forum. 😎
 
Last edited:
Just wondering . i made Paul's MS juice today . So I have beet leaves carrot leaves and parts celery parts and leaves apple parts , and all the pulp from all of that from juicing . Would that make good worm food ? How can I compost it ( I would assume I have to without a composter ? Can I put it in a sealed container , and let it rot ? I have never used an actuall composter I have just always turned stuff int the ground before spring planting
 
I also feed white worms to the fish in my small pond. My goldfish and white cloud mountain minnows all enjoy them and eat them with gusto. A very cheap and not so difficult food to breed.
Perfect my 12 by12 by 6 foot deep pond has all sorts of things in it . Especially my feeder goldfish which some are 8 -10 inches long and breed
 
Just wondering . i made Paul's MS juice today . So I have beet leaves carrot leaves and parts celery parts and leaves apple parts , and all the pulp from all of that from juicing . Would that make good worm food ? How can I compost it ( I would assume I have to without a composter ? Can I put it in a sealed container , and let it rot ? I have never used an actuall composter I have just always turned stuff int the ground before spring planting
Sorry am no horticulturalist lol.
I wish I could answer you questions knowledgeablely but all veg should be OK to make compost. Hard things like carrots I would grate or chop up before adding. However, the veg and plants take quite a while to be in a position to be used as worm compost even with my composer. @Paul B should be able to help you further I suspect

I have had a garden composter for about 4 years that I used for my worms compost. However, once extracted from my composer I microwaved it to kill any bugs or eggs that could be in it that I don't want in my worm cultures.

I may try well rotted farm manure next time I need to change the compost as I heard good things about it and apparently also provides some food for them.
 
Not sure what red wiggles or night crawlers are. However earth worms chopped up or very small ones are taken by most fish.
Red wigglers are a type of earthworm. Just smaller. Night crawlers are the same but get pretty big.
 
Red wigglers are a type of earthworm. Just smaller. Night crawlers are the same but get pretty big.
Both would provide good food in bite size pieces. Some put them in damp conditions to clean them like mosses but I don't think it's necessary
 
Not sure what red wiggles or night crawlers are. However earth worms chopped up or very small ones are taken by most fish.
night Crawlers as it suggests come out at night . Can be quit long 8 Inches and about2/8 thick . You hunt them with a red headlamp .They can regrow themselves if you break them . are very fast as they stay partially in there hole and have a snake like propulsion system so when you grab one you have to wait for it to tire and release which you can actually feel. Used for fishing . Red wigglers are a about 2 -3 inches long and very skinny . Look a lot like the white worms but are red . You can get dozens simply by digging in the ground
 
night Crawlers as it suggests come out at night . Can be quit long 8 Inches and about2/8 thick . You hunt them with a red headlamp .They can regrow themselves if you break them . are very fast as they stay partially in there hole and have a snake like propulsion system so when you grab one you have to wait for it to tire and release which you can actually feel. Used for fishing . Red wigglers are a about 2 -3 inches long and very skinny . Look a lot like the white worms but are red . You can get dozens simply by digging in the ground
Don't think I would use the night crawlers lol.
 
Paul isn't the only one to claim this. I know being a scientist you need proof for everything but sometimes things just work without needing pages upon pages of studies. I understand your position but your need to question everything gets tiring.

Who else claims that the bacteria in terrestrial white worms usefully boosts the immune system of marine fish?

Is there is single one paragraph study anywhere? No need to exaggerate the requirement. Any evidence would be welcome.

I’m sorry you are fatigued, but I will never apologize for asking anyone making any claim whether there is ANY evidence to support it, and in this case there is none that I have seen presented.
 
Last edited:
I think my 70 years of experience in this hobby allowed me to learn a few things, even if you say it is un-proven. And white worms are one thing I learned about. But I still don't eat them myself. 🤮

People who don't feed whiteworms have to prove something, not us with the oldest tanks on here and every forum. 😎

I’m not going down this endless rabbit hole again.

You fail to acknowledge the critical difference between some set of procedures having an observable effect, and your hypothesized reasons it happens.

All you have is the former. Nothing you have done supports the idea that white worms boost the immune system of marine fish.
 
I’m not going down this endless rabbit hole again.

You fail to acknowledge the critical difference between some set of procedures having an observable effect, and your hypothesized reasons it happens.

All you have is the former. Nothing you have done supports the idea that white worms boost the immune system of marine fish.
Nothing most of us have done has proved anything in a scientific way because we don't have the scientific instrument. We don't have the know how or ability. All we can rely on it years and years of experience doing what we do.

We have tried different things, watching the results which is what we have been doing for many years. What can't be denied is the fact we have very healthy tanks and fish.

To some it will always be a coincidence, lucky or even that we are lairs in what we see and have in our tanks. This while others experience the opposite doing other things like QTing and medicating. I am not denying some have success with QTing but one look at the disease forum or the water house of horrors will tell much.

We aren't on here to prove anything other than what we have, how long we have had it our experience with what we have achieved by doing what we do. Maybe current science can't prove nor disprove what we believe and yes its a belief a belief founded on many years of experience.

That is all we can provide. I understand as a scientist that is simply not enough for you. Paul did have a sample of his tank water analysed which did prove a lot of doubters about exactly how healthy it was with no nasties within.

It maybe years till science proves or disproves our beliefs if so, so be it. It isn't a simple hobbiests goal to become a qualified scientist and lay the evidence before you or anybody else for the reasons above.

40 plus years ago scientists said you couldn't keep a Magnifica anemone alive for anything other than a few weeks. They were wrong then as I had a very healthy one in my aquarium as I have now. All pre interweb of course.
 
Nothing most of us have done has proved anything in a scientific way because we don't have the scientific instrument. We don't have the know how or ability. All we can rely on it years and years of experience doing what we do.

We have tried different things, watching the results which is what we have been doing for many years. What can't be denied is the fact we have very healthy tanks and fish.

To some it will always be a coincidence, lucky or even that we are lairs in what we see and have in our tanks. This while others experience the opposite doing other things like QTing and medicating. I am not denying some have success with QTing but one look at the disease forum or the water house of horrors will tell much.

We aren't on here to prove anything other than what we have, how long we have had it our experience with what we have achieved by doing what we do. Maybe current science can't prove nor disprove what we believe and yes its a belief a belief founded on many years of experience.

That is all we can provide. I understand as a scientist that is simply not enough for you. Paul did have a sample of his tank water analysed which did prove a lot of doubters about exactly how healthy it was with no nasties within.

It maybe years till science proves or disproves our beliefs if so, so be it. It isn't a simple hobbiests goal to become a qualified scientist and lay the evidence before you or anybody else for the reasons above.

40 plus years ago scientists said you couldn't keep a Magnifica anemone alive for anything other than a few weeks. They were wrong then as I had a very healthy one in my aquarium as I have now. All pre interweb of course.

You all seem to find it easiest to criticize my position by mischaracterizing it.

I never once said the methods you use do not work. EVER.

If you said the following, I’d be perfectly happy with it:

I use white worms as part of a set of methods I use, and my fish do not have apparent diseases. One possibly contributing factor is the hypothesis that the white worms help boost the fish immune system.

Since you aren’t here to prove anything, which is perfectly appropriate, then folks should not make statements that indicate they have proof when there is none:

White worms boost the immune system of marine fish.

The latter is an unqualified statement of fact. You do not have the evidence so should not claim it as fact. You do have the former, and that is what you should claim. I’m not saying you said that, but others have.

I do not just apply this to others. I apply it to all kinds of hypothesis I have. I make it very clear when I am stating facts, and when I think something may be true but do not know with certainty.
 
You all seem to find it easiest to criticize my position by mischaracterizing it.

I never once said the methods you use do not work. EVER.

If you said the following, I’d be perfectly happy with it:

I use white worms as part of a set of methods I use, and my fish do not have apparent diseases. One possibly contributing factor is the hypothesis that the white worms help boost the fish immune system.

Since you aren’t here to prove anything, which is perfectly appropriate, then folks should not make statements that indicate they have proof when there is none:

White worms boost the immune system of marine fish.

The latter is an unqualified statement of fact. You do not have the evidence so should not claim it as fact. You do have the former, and that is what you should claim. I’m not saying you said that, but others have.

I do not just apply this to others. I apply it to all kinds of hypothesis I have. I make it very clear when I am stating facts, and when I think something may be true but do not know with certainty.
Am not sure how you come to some of those conclusions.
I have no axe to grind. You seem very reactionary. I did say we can't prove our beliefs in a scientific way, thats it. I talked about beliefs and experience only. The only facts I pointed out was how long we have been having success doing what we do and why we'd believe in them.

You insist on scientific proof. I informed you we didn't have such. No criticism implied just pointing out you can't prove our beliefs wrong anymore than we can prove them right.

However if you can disporve them then let's see the proof and the scientific papers disproving our beliefs. Beliefs which are built on years of experience and success doing what we do.

You challenged us but have a problem when the boot is on the other foot you can't call challanged criticism you should accepted challenge as a scientist as we have without having a moan. Thats what it sounds like.

I never claimed facts in the way you would like for reasons I have already stated only with the above, EG our experience.
I never criticised your stand. I posted an opinion with what I believe to be the case. I never said you are wrong. I stand by my opinion untill proven without doubt I am wrong.

Now if you want facts on building say a house then I will be able to provide you with many. That is where my qualifications and EXPERIENCE lie.
 
Am not sure how you come to some of those conclusions.
I have no axe to grind. You seem very reactionary. I did say we can't prove our beliefs in a scientific way, thats it. I talked about beliefs and experience only. The only facts I pointed out was how long we have been having success doing what we do and why we'd believe in them.

You insist on scientific proof. I informed you we didn't have such. No criticism implied just pointing out you can't prove our beliefs wrong anymore than we can prove them right.

However if you can disporve them then let's see the proof and the scientific papers disproving our beliefs. Beliefs which are built on years of experience and success doing what we do.

You challenged us but have a problem when the boot is on the other foot you can't call challanged criticism you should accepted challenge as a scientist as we have without having a moan. Thats what it sounds like.

I never claimed facts in the way you would like for reasons I have already stated only with the above, EG our experience.
I never criticised your stand. I posted an opinion with what I believe to be the case. I never said you are wrong. I stand by my opinion untill proven without doubt I am wrong.

Now if you want facts on building say a house then I will be able to provide you with many. That is where my qualifications and EXPERIENCE lie.
How did I conclude my position is being mischaracterized?

You started off with several paragraphs defending the methods as if that is what I’m criticizing. Paul does the same, touting his oldest tank as if that is any sort of evidence for the hypothesis.

It’s easy to defend that the method works, which is fine, but is totally unrelated to my point here about immunity (it may be a fine way to claim the worms can be part of a diet that leads to healthy fish).

Why would I need to prove the worm/immunity link is wrong? I’m not even saying it is wrong.

I don’t say it’s wrong so don’t need to prove anything.

Paul says it is right. That is unjustified by his tank, even if there were thousands of people doing the same thing.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new