Why dont i have any lps growth?

  • Thread starter Thread starter 2FUSouls
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

2FUSouls

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2025
Messages
230
Reaction score
141
Location
USA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
20250805_095007.jpg
20250805_095013.jpg
Ok so billy bob has like no growth only one group of paly and a toadstool my mini reef is growing like crazy! Why does my big tank not grow? Am i missing something?
 
Fwiw i am running 1ppm nitrates and .2 phosphate and am getting great growth on my lps. I have definitely found that they do better when the tank is a bit dirtier.
 
Magnesium is low
Phosphate is low
Are you feeding them?
How established is the tank?
Tank will be a year in november here is a current photo
20250805_100504.jpg

I water change roughly 10 gallons every three to 4 weeks and feed once a day a mix of coral frenzy mermaid delight prime reef and herboivore cube. Everything is nice and open with feeding response just no growt. I was dosing all for reef but i need to get more.
 
What are your lights and flow like? Light is the most important for coral growth, flow is also important. How old is the tank? What kind of lps are you trying to grow? Some lps like chalice for example have extremely slow growth. What is the time period, how long you had the tank set up, how long the corals been in your tank that are not growing? Need more info......
 
Fwiw i am running 1ppm nitrates and .2 phosphate and am getting great growth on my lps. I have definitely found that they do better when the tank is a bit dirtier.
Ok so maybe increase feeding? We fought dinos in march so i have been leary on over feeding
 
LPS like a “dirtier” tank…bring up nitrate and phosphates…I run magnesium at 1440 and I had to just upgrade my tank bc of the tremendous growth…do this all slowly though!! Bottomed out nitrates and phosphates are also likely to cause dinos so start this sooner than later!
 
Ph is low, nitrate is nonexistent, phos is low possibly 0 as your number is with in margin of error for most tests, Mag is low, alk is high for the lack of nutrients you have. Dinos are typically more possible in lower nutrient instances which is probably why you got them. Safe happy range is 10+n and .05+p My tank with the fish and coral load I have (lots of coral not a ton of fish) seems to have found a happy place where it stays pretty consistent without me having to do much at around 25-30n and .09-.12p. I pull excess macro about every 2 weeks feed the fish daily and dose afr daily. If I wasnt upgrading tanks soon...ish I would probably need to start looking at fragging, at least the hammers probably most of the zoas too.
 
What are your lights and flow like? Light is the most important for coral growth, flow is also important. How old is the tank? What kind of lps are you trying to grow? Some lps like chalice for example have extremely slow growth. What is the time period, how long you had the tank set up, how long the corals been in your tank that are not growing? Need more info......
Vipraspectra 165w two of them 15 inches from wawater runs 12 hours blue at 100% and 6 hours white at 40% i have three wave makers 1110 gph. Tank is almost a year corals have been 5-6 months fought dino in march.
 
Ph is low, nitrate is nonexistent, phos is low possibly 0 as your number is with in margin of error for most tests, Mag is low, alk is high for the lack of nutrients you have. Dinos are typically more possible in lower nutrient instances which is probably why you got them. Safe happy range is 10+n and .05+p My tank with the fish and coral load I have (lots of coral not a ton of fish) seems to have found a happy place where it stays pretty consistent without me having to do much at around 25-30n and .09-.12p. I pull excess macro about every 2 weeks feed the fish daily and dose afr daily. If I wasnt upgrading tanks soon...ish I would probably need to start looking at fragging, at least the hammers probably most of the zoas too.
My ph did comcome up to 8 that test was right as lights came on. Do you recommend in crease feeding or dosing? And I do have macro in my display, I've got grape, I did just pull some, but there's still quite a bit. Left I have considered getting a rabbit fish. A smaller version to try to eat it. But I was concerned that if I pulled all my macro, then ugh it would cause a bigger issue, long run
 
My LPS were pretty stagnant growth wise when I had low nitrates and phosphates. They really started growing like crazy when my nitrates got into the 20's, and phosphates into the .2's (not .02). Your pH is also pretty low. My tank is pretty consistent at 8.1. Anything lower than 7.8 and I'd be concerned. I also like to see alk at least 8dkh (143ish ppm), calcium in the mid 400's. If both of those are ok, there's really no need to test magnesium.
 
Ok so maybe increase feeding? We fought dinos in march so i have been leary on over feeding

Lack of feeding can drive dinos, and they are often cured by raising nutrients.
 
I can attest to the above statement, when I bottomed out nutrients I had all sorts of problems.

You need to feed more, and/or dose both nitrate and phosphate to get them. Nitrates 5-20 is a good range, phos the low end target seems to be .06, but I like anything from .1-.3..... I do not like to be on the ragged edge of bottoming out.
 
My ph did comcome up to 8 that test was right as lights came on. Do you recommend in crease feeding or dosing? And I do have macro in my display, I've got grape, I did just pull some, but there's still quite a bit. Left I have considered getting a rabbit fish. A smaller version to try to eat it. But I was concerned that if I pulled all my macro, then ugh it would cause a bigger issue, long run
I would not feed less for sure. You can dose either ammonia or nitrate and phosphate to get the numbers up. I still have not figured out how people have an issue keeping nitrates and phosphate from bottoming out. My tank is about 120g with 4 fish, I feed 1 cube of either mysis or enriched brine shrimp a chunk of nori and if I get home at lunch time some algae flake food. I was starting to worry my numbers were high but I watch the corals flourish all of them lps, zoas and sps, colors are good fish are happy and healthy looking. I really stopped worrying about it. I test maybe once a month at most now, and its typically the same every time range 25-30n and .09-.12p every time. The tank has been pretty much on autopilot. Im not saying thats a good thing its just good as I am really busy with work stuff atm.
 
My ph did comcome up to 8 that test was right as lights came on. Do you recommend in crease feeding or dosing? And I do have macro in my display, I've got grape, I did just pull some, but there's still quite a bit. Left I have considered getting a rabbit fish. A smaller version to try to eat it. But I was concerned that if I pulled all my macro, then ugh it would cause a bigger issue, long run
I would not feed less for sure. You can dose either ammonia or nitrate and phosphate to get the numbers up. I still have not figured out how people have an issue keeping nitrates and phosphate from bottoming out. My tank is about 120g with 4 fish, I feed 1 cube of either mysis or enriched brine shrimp a chunk of nori and if I get home at lunch time some algae flake food. I was starting to worry my numbers were high but I watch the corals flourish all of them lps, zoas and sps, colors are good fish are happy and healthy looking. I really stopped worrying about it. I test maybe once a month at most now, and its typically the same every time range 25-30n and .09-.12p every time. The tank has been pretty much on autopilot. Im not saying thats a good thing its just good as I am really busy with work stuff atm.
I dont get how it is bottom out either i feed 3 scoops of coral frenzy one cube prime reef one cube herbovore reef mix a good chuck of mermaid delight daily and frozen krill every 3 days for nem! And my tank is only 55 gallon and i dont feel like i am heavily stocked either
 
In all seriosuness can i house sps? Dont they like sterile tanks lol i mean i can move my softies to my other tank and lps. I havent tried sps because i didn't think my tank was sterile enough 😅
 
In all seriosuness can i house sps? Dont they like sterile tanks lol i mean i can move my softies to my other tank and lps. I havent tried sps because i didn't think my tank was sterile enough 😅

No, most grow perfectly well at levels well above yours.
 
When my tank was set up, I had GHA issues when my nutrients were sky high (nitrates over 100). So to combat this I lowered the nitrates, but did it so fast on accident that it bottomed them out. Had Dinos mixed with GHA because of this. Anyways, I would just work on bringing your nutrients up slowly, combating the dinos before they get worse, and you will be alright!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 17.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.4%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.5%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 25 26.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.3%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new