Zoa Troubleshooting

corlando

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 30, 2026
Messages
12
Reaction score
3
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Good Afternoon everyone,

I’ve recently been struggling to get my zoanthids to open. For context I have 11 different zoa types, a torch, (2) candy canes, duncan, (3) hammers, toadstool, (2) gsp, (2) blastos, a pulsing xenia, an acan, a favia and a sympodia. Everyone is thriving, shrimps are molting, fish are happy. One of my zoas even developed a new polyp, but for some reason they either intermittently open and close right back up or won’t open at all, a couple of my colonies are open however. The tank is roughly 3 months old. Lighting is via a Nicrew 135w with a controller utilizing a consistent schedule to mimic sunrise and sunset. Below I have attached a photo of one of the zoa frags. Any ideas what it could be?

Thank you

Recent Parameters via Hannah Checkers

Alk- 9.1
Calcium- 405
Mag- 1285
Ph- 8.0
Phos- 0.04
Nitrate- 10
Salinity 1.026
Temp- 79.1 F
20261118_143817_0E8C2A14-C402-4795-9AA3-6E76B256E822.png
 
Any chances recently? What sort of clean up crew? Something is possibly aggravating it or nibbling....
Peppermint shrimp, hermit crabs, trochus snails. No major changes. I ever so slightly lowered the arch the zoas are on but they werent open even before I moved it.
 
Peppermint shrimp, hermit crabs, trochus snails. No major changes. I ever so slightly lowered the arch the zoas are on but they werent open even before I moved it.
by changes do you mean parameters? the peppermint is a low chance culprit
 
I'm having something similar with a few Zoas. Most in the tank are open, but a few specific ones have been closed for several days. No idea why.
 
when taking pics, it really helps to turn the blue's down to zero and leave only the white lights, everything is blued out and hard to make out any details.

I'm curious why your running your lights at only 45% and why for only 3 hours of peak? How big is your tank?
 
Peppermint shrimp, hermit crabs, trochus snails. No major changes. I ever so slightly lowered the arch the zoas are on but they werent open even before I moved it.
by changes do you mean parameters? the peppermint is a low chance culprit
No, just lower placement of the rock the zoas are on.
 
when taking pics, it really helps to turn the blue's down to zero and leave only the white lights, everything is blued out and hard to make out any details.

I'm curious why your running your lights at only 45% and why for only 3 hours of peak? How big is your tank?
Tank is 40 gallons. Nicrew is 7 inches away from the tank. To be honest I lowered the intensity. I had different settings initially when I got the controller and thought it might of been too bright
20261119_000802_0FD3B295-E9F3-4EA9-8B8A-92D6B2944187.png

These the previous numbers
 
Tank is 40 gallons. Nicrew is 7 inches away from the tank. To be honest I lowered the intensity. I had different settings initially when I got the controller and thought it might of been too bright
20261119_000802_0FD3B295-E9F3-4EA9-8B8A-92D6B2944187.png

These the previous numbers
try raising those lights to 11 inches above waterline. How many pucks are those nicrew? I have a 150 3 puck on my 32 but I feel they're too strong. Have you measured par? drop them down to 25% and leave it for a week. My zoas been looking better since I've lowered my lights
 
Tank is 40 gallons. Nicrew is 7 inches away from the tank. To be honest I lowered the intensity. I had different settings initially when I got the controller and thought it might of been too bright
20261119_000802_0FD3B295-E9F3-4EA9-8B8A-92D6B2944187.png

These the previous numbers
try raising those lights to 10. How many pucks are those nicrew? I have a 150 3 puck on my 32 but I feel they're too strong. Have you measured par? drop them down to 25% and leave it for a week. My zoas been looking better since I've lowered my lights
Just ordered a par checker, not too sure how accurate it will be but its a 135 two puck light.
 
Tank is 40 gallons. Nicrew is 7 inches away from the tank. To be honest I lowered the intensity. I had different settings initially when I got the controller and thought it might of been too bright
20261119_000802_0FD3B295-E9F3-4EA9-8B8A-92D6B2944187.png

These the previous numbers
WE can't judge the brightness by eyesight, the best way is to rent a par meter.

I also have a 40 gallon tank, my light is 150 watt I run at full power. I feel your light is a little uderpowered for the tank size so I would not run it so low. I feel you should be at 80%+, but if it was me I would run it at full power.

Further, my peak period is 12 hours, 3 hour of peak lighting is just not sufficient, the sun is in the sky longer than 3 hours.

Just my 2 cents good luck
 
Tank is 40 gallons. Nicrew is 7 inches away from the tank. To be honest I lowered the intensity. I had different settings initially when I got the controller and thought it might of been too bright
20261119_000802_0FD3B295-E9F3-4EA9-8B8A-92D6B2944187.png

These the previous numbers
WE can't judge the brightness by eyesight, the best way is to rent a par meter.

I also have a 40 gallon tank, my light is 150 watt I run at full power. I feel your light is a little uderpowered for the tank size so I would not run it so low. I feel you should be at 80%+, but if it was me I would run it at full power.

Further, my peak period is 12 hours, 3 hour of peak lighting is just not sufficient, the sun is in the sky longer than 3 hours.

Just my 2 cents good luck
I ended up purchasing a par checker from amazon I will return it once I determine par levels. Thank you for the insight. I initially thought the PAR was too intense but it might just not be intense enough.
 
I would run your P04 closer to .1 if was me. Don't know about your par or mine for that matter but I run my lights at a consistent setting except for ramping up in the morning and ramping down in the evening. Mine run 12 hours total.
 
hermits can be problematic.

I wouldn't think this is specifically par related since they'd still open, but stretch/reach for more light if it were PAR... But, it was a change you made, so possibly....
 
What are your parameters and large swings in those?
 
I would run your P04 closer to .1 if was me. Don't know about your par or mine for that matter but I run my lights at a consistent setting except for ramping up in the morning and ramping down in the evening. Mine run 12 hours total.
Not too long ago phos was 0.7 per aquaspin, so I added a phos pad. Turns out the aquaspin was giving me inaccurate readings so I bought hannah checkers and they range anywhere from 0.04-0.07. I just started dosing reef roids once a week but so far it hasnt spiked my phos
 
hermits can be problematic.

I wouldn't think this is specifically par related since they'd still open, but stretch/reach for more light if it were PAR... But, it was a change you made, so possibly....
Im starting to think it could be PAR as well
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 15 34.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 32.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 13 30.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new