Sellers beware of Ladybug5234
- Thread starter Madreef
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Please read here before posting. Outside comments are not permitted per R2R's feedback forum policy. This is to allow the buyer and seller to have a streamlined conversation and hopefully come to a mutually satisfactory resolution in a negative transaction. If you would like to contribute your own feedback experience with either the buyer or seller, you may do so by creating your own feedback thread. Only the thread starter and vendor will have posting access. Thank you.
- Status
Ladybug5234
Active Member
A chargeback is when a buyer tries to have his or her credit card charge back a purchase made. In this case, Madreef sold me a decaying hockey puck that was supposed to be full of zoas. I tried communicating with him to no avail, so I filed a Paypal DISPUTE not a chargeback. As a matter of fact, I couldn't file a chargeback even if I wanted to because I paid via eCheck, not a credit card (I didn't notice that when I paid).
But as usual, Madreef isn't telling the whole story, so read it here...
https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/seller-trader-feedback/114754-madreef-sucks.html
And if you want to see how bad he really sucks, read more here...
https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/pr...ussion/87147-delayed-package-wwyd-seller.html
Had I seen this before, I would've saved $155. BUYER BEWARE!
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
Feedback discussion is for those involved directly with the transaction.
Ladybug5234
Active Member
And yes, you are right about one thing... the "after receiving the item part". THAT IS IT. You are right because I did receive the "item"... a decaying hockey puck! How silly of me to actually buy and expect to receive LIVE CORALS!!!
OP
OP
Madreef
Active Member
I have photos of the coral open, healthy, and growing the day of shipping, in case anyone cares to see. I really dont need to prove anything in this situation. I'm sorry you had a bad experience. Once a coral leaves my care I have no control over what happens to it. I will not refund a $100 18 polyp rasta fragment that died in your care.
I extended a great deal towards another fellow hobbiest, only to be verbally abused and harassed by you. I sent out 4 other healed rasta frags one was even delayed 24hours, all arrived alive and are doing fine. I'm not a business, I have no inventory, just a hobbiest trying to help other hobbiest with beautiful healthy tank grown corals at a reasonable price.
I extended a great deal towards another fellow hobbiest, only to be verbally abused and harassed by you. I sent out 4 other healed rasta frags one was even delayed 24hours, all arrived alive and are doing fine. I'm not a business, I have no inventory, just a hobbiest trying to help other hobbiest with beautiful healthy tank grown corals at a reasonable price.
Ladybug5234
Active Member
$155, not $100 and the coral did not die in my care. It arrived damaged & melted by the next day. They never opened, not once! You kept saying that & I kept correcting you. You are a liar and as I said before, I wouldn't buy a penny frag with free shipping from you!
Btw, I have pictures also. The only difference is mine were taken the day it arrived. God knows when you took yours!
Btw, I have pictures also. The only difference is mine were taken the day it arrived. God knows when you took yours!
Last edited:
OP
OP
Madreef
Active Member
Pardon me, what I should have said was you bought a $100 15+ polyp zoanthid frag of "Rastas" and payed $55 to have it shipped to your doorstep FedEx overnight.
The coral arrived by your own account in your PM, on the day of March 20th. It was only 5 days after that you had problems with the fragment, the PM is dated March 25th. If you check on my for sale threads you can see how I hold onto my frags for weeks, if not months before sending them out; something most retail vendors don't do. I make sure they are growing and healthy before they are sent.
I was never sent these DOA photos you are now mentioning, I was never notified that there was a problem with the shipment. I have never received any photos from you. You only notified me that the coral had stopped opening up and died in your care after several days of receiving it.
I will have the person who personally packed your coral chime in here because my credibility is on the line apparently, and I will defend it because I will not have these misnomers and false accusations be made without response.
The coral arrived by your own account in your PM, on the day of March 20th. It was only 5 days after that you had problems with the fragment, the PM is dated March 25th. If you check on my for sale threads you can see how I hold onto my frags for weeks, if not months before sending them out; something most retail vendors don't do. I make sure they are growing and healthy before they are sent.
I was never sent these DOA photos you are now mentioning, I was never notified that there was a problem with the shipment. I have never received any photos from you. You only notified me that the coral had stopped opening up and died in your care after several days of receiving it.
I will have the person who personally packed your coral chime in here because my credibility is on the line apparently, and I will defend it because I will not have these misnomers and false accusations be made without response.
Last edited:
Ian
Valuable Member
I shipped this frag and when I packed it, it was a frag disc full of open and healthy Rasta zoanthids that had been fragged for no less than 6 weeks from the look of the growth. I've shipped literally thousands of packages containing tens of thousands of coral fragments. To my knowledge the package arrived on time with a message thanking Madreefer. Not until 5 days later did she contact Madreefer to say that they had melted (with no photo showing so).
$155 for 18 Rastas ($8.60pp shipped) is a steal to start off with, I'd say that proves Madreef isn't out to get anyone and I really don't know anyone that would offer any kind of guarantee after 5 days of no contact.
Sometimes zoas don't fair well in new water, that's just a fact in this hobby and if the problem isn't apparent after a couple days I don't think the seller can be blamed. If there's even a chance that there's a problem I would assume the buyer would contact the seller immediately, expecting anything after 5 days of them being in the tank just isn't realistic.
Though I am Madreef's friend, if he was at fault I would suggest he rectify the situation (though I wouldn't have to) and in this case with the facts that have been presented, I'd say he's in the clear. It sucks the coral died, that happens to everyone at some point in this hobby, but if it were the sellers fault he should have been contacted immediately, not 5 days later.
$155 for 18 Rastas ($8.60pp shipped) is a steal to start off with, I'd say that proves Madreef isn't out to get anyone and I really don't know anyone that would offer any kind of guarantee after 5 days of no contact.
Sometimes zoas don't fair well in new water, that's just a fact in this hobby and if the problem isn't apparent after a couple days I don't think the seller can be blamed. If there's even a chance that there's a problem I would assume the buyer would contact the seller immediately, expecting anything after 5 days of them being in the tank just isn't realistic.
Though I am Madreef's friend, if he was at fault I would suggest he rectify the situation (though I wouldn't have to) and in this case with the facts that have been presented, I'd say he's in the clear. It sucks the coral died, that happens to everyone at some point in this hobby, but if it were the sellers fault he should have been contacted immediately, not 5 days later.
Ladybug5234
Active Member
I don't see how Ian is allowed to post on this behalf & state what he thinks are "facts", which are not. He doesn't know anything for a fact since I didn't send him any pm's. He only knows what he's been told happened, which is not the entire truth. also Ian, it doesn't matter what kind of a deal someone gets, if they don't get what they paid for, it's still STEALING.
I don't have a lot of feedback here because I don't conduct much business here, but if anyone cares to see what kind of seller/buyer/honest person I am, feel free to look for my screen name on RC, eBay, PBMAS, FMAS, and N-R (I'm phishyaly on N-R). I recently purchased some frags from Ryan803 on here as well. Shipment was delayed & some frags didn't make it, but he was a gentleman about it. Nothing has come by way of any resolution for the frags I lost but you don't see me bashing him, filing negative feedback, or talking smack. Why? Because I'm not like that. I resolve matters like an adult. I'm done with you; karma will catch up to you soon ;)
I don't have a lot of feedback here because I don't conduct much business here, but if anyone cares to see what kind of seller/buyer/honest person I am, feel free to look for my screen name on RC, eBay, PBMAS, FMAS, and N-R (I'm phishyaly on N-R). I recently purchased some frags from Ryan803 on here as well. Shipment was delayed & some frags didn't make it, but he was a gentleman about it. Nothing has come by way of any resolution for the frags I lost but you don't see me bashing him, filing negative feedback, or talking smack. Why? Because I'm not like that. I resolve matters like an adult. I'm done with you; karma will catch up to you soon ;)
Last edited by a moderator:
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
I have removed the name calling from both threads. Please keep it civil and only post facts.
OP
OP
Madreef
Active Member
Facts:
Price shipped in listing $175
Actual selling amount $155 shipped overnight FedEx arrive alive guarantee
Item shipped on 3-19
I sent wrong tracking number on accident (I didn't have shipping paper) Ian shipped packages and texted me info and I mixed up some of the numbers on her box.
Item received 3-20, No DOA photo of mention of problems
PM sent 3-25 "All zoas melted off plug"
Apologized and asked about introduction procedure and skill level.
I have had nothing, but problems with this sale. Hopefully this can stand as public record as I've followed all standard procedures for coral sales. I'm not making any profit off my labors and expenses of having my aquariums. I do this to help others, but once an item leaves my care I can't control what happens to it, and will not guarantee the item when shipping is successful.
Considering Ian packed and shipped the coral, and given his hobby experience I would say his post is valid. I believe his opinion is also valid in the thread. If my credibility hadn't been attacked and harassed I would not brought him into this. I'm a very generous reefkeeper if you ask locals or the Ccrk club.
Price shipped in listing $175
Actual selling amount $155 shipped overnight FedEx arrive alive guarantee
Item shipped on 3-19
I sent wrong tracking number on accident (I didn't have shipping paper) Ian shipped packages and texted me info and I mixed up some of the numbers on her box.
Item received 3-20, No DOA photo of mention of problems
PM sent 3-25 "All zoas melted off plug"
Apologized and asked about introduction procedure and skill level.
I have had nothing, but problems with this sale. Hopefully this can stand as public record as I've followed all standard procedures for coral sales. I'm not making any profit off my labors and expenses of having my aquariums. I do this to help others, but once an item leaves my care I can't control what happens to it, and will not guarantee the item when shipping is successful.
Considering Ian packed and shipped the coral, and given his hobby experience I would say his post is valid. I believe his opinion is also valid in the thread. If my credibility hadn't been attacked and harassed I would not brought him into this. I'm a very generous reefkeeper if you ask locals or the Ccrk club.
Last edited:
OP
OP
Madreef
Active Member
Dana my previous post contains facts, if I need to post actual photos, tracking information, and screen shots of dated PMs I will; but I hardly deem that necessary over $100 worth of coral. I've put in way more then $100 worth of my time into being civil and reasonable about this. If it were a larger dollar amount or if the facts were different I'd be rethinking my approach, but I did nothing wrong in the sense of my guarantee and what I sold was legitimate.
SeahorseKeeper
Where's the mysis?
- Joined
- May 27, 2012
- Messages
- 12,807
- Reaction score
- 3,714
- Location
- Wandering somewhere in NC
- What state or country do you live in
- North Carolina
This thread has run it's course and is closed. If either party feels the need to add anything, please PM any staff member to open the thread.
The reason Ian's post is allowed is because he was involved in the transaction, packing and shipping.
- Status
Similar threads
