Algae Scrubber vs Refugium

[saltwaterfish.com Verified Sponsor]

I've played around with the idea of getting a algae scrubber for my tank since they have become more affordable and common in the hobby, but I already have decent sized refugium that has been set up and established for about a year or so growing dragons breath and grape caulerpa. My biggest concern is that the algae scrubber will not do as well as the refugium, or will need more upkeep and maintenance. To those of you that have experience with both what would you recommend?

 

[exnisstech]

My experience is probably useless because I've found both to be poor at nutrient reduction.l if that is your goal. I'm sure it's my overfeeding having 9 tangs begging all day. In my 180g with a chaeto fuge harvesting about 1/2 of a 5g bucket every 7-10 days and NO3 was alway 40-50 and PO4 0.4 0.6. I moved to a 330 running a Santa Monica surf4 and a cryptic fuge with all live rock and NO3 is 40-50 and PO4 0.4-0.9. as mentioned I'm sure its my feeding and don't really fret over it because the tank looks fine. If i had to choose one over the other i would choose a macro algae fuge just for the ability of pods to reproduce.
With a surf floating ATS you could probably run both which might be interesting The surf takes seconds to clean and produces a lot of tang food.
Just reach in and pull the algae out. Gloves are recommended if bristle worms bother you lol

 

[saltwaterfish.com Verified Sponsor]

My experience is probably useless because I've found both to be poor at nutrient reduction.l if that is your goal. I'm sure it's my overfeeding having 9 tangs begging all day. In my 180g with a chaeto fuge harvesting about 1/2 of a 5g bucket every 7-10 days and NO3 was alway 40-50 and PO4 0.4 0.6. I moved to a 330 running a Santa Monica surf4 and a cryptic fuge with all live rock and NO3 is 40-50 and PO4 0.4-0.9. as mentioned I'm sure its my feeding and don't really fret over it because the tank looks fine. If i had to choose one over the other i would choose a macro algae fuge just for the ability of pods to reproduce.
With a surf floating ATS you could probably run both which might be interesting The surf takes seconds to clean and produces a lot of tang food.
Just reach in and pull the algae out. Gloves are recommended if bristle worms bother you lol

Awesome advice thank you, I think I will stick with my refugium then for now.

 

[Tangdora]

Team scrubber only because I’m a clean freak and can’t be blasting light all over my sump and later have to deal with scraping algae and coraline off everything. Easier to just remove the scrubber and clean that. The tank itself is enough cleaning

 

[exnisstech]

Team scrubber only because I’m a clean freak and can’t be blasting light all over my sump and later have to deal with scraping algae and coraline off everything. Easier to just remove the scrubber and clean that. The tank itself is enough cleaning

The only time I've cleaned a sump was when I moved to a new tank. I scraped 6 years worth of mulm out and dumped it in the new sump for a jump start. It was full of life.

 

[VintageReefer]

I ran a chaeto fuge for 2 years then added a surf2 scrubber. The chaeto was dead and gone in 4 months. I like scrubbers better because they’re self contained, easy to clean, and easy to adjust. The fuge really isn’t adjustable, but I can change the duration of my scrubber hours to directly raise or lower my nutrient levels

 

[PPBlimpy]

I have ran both and happy with the results. To me it depends on tank size and space availability.

currently running both between my two systems

My big tank with large sump has a dedicated area for a macro chamber, most people call refugium now a days, I also use this chamber as a hospital chamber and if i need to introduce a finicky eating fish to the system. doubling down making this area very useful.

Now on my little tank, a 54g corner with a 10G sump, I had no room with a macro chamber and decided to run an ATS. It works great and actually kept bottoming out my nutrients and have pulled it temporarily to install on the big tank along with the macro chamber to help bring down the nutrients a bit faster.

it will be transferred back shortly.

I do have plans to setup a real old school above tank refugium like we did back in the early 2000s.

Feed from the sump to a refugium above the DT, letting it overflow and flow back into the DT. This will have macro and hopefully mangroves, some CUC and a DSB