Alkalinity keeps dropping despite more than doubling All-For-Reef dosing

Rick's Reefing Adventures

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 15, 2023
Messages
274
Reaction score
116
Location
the Netherlands
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Over the past two months, I’ve had to steadily increase my liquid All-For-Reef dosing because my alkalinity continues to decline.

I started at approximately 8 dKH while dosing 4 ml per day. The alkalinity then dropped to 7 dKH fairly quickly, so I increased the dose. It subsequently fell to 6.8 dKH, then to 6.5 dKH, and has now reached 6.1 dKH. Each time, I increased the dose in response to the decline.

Over roughly two months, my daily dose has increased from 4 ml to 8.5 ml. I have just raised it again to 9.5 ml, so I do not yet know what effect that change will have.

I haven’t added any new corals or other livestock in the past few months. The corals currently in the tank, however, have been showing exceptionally strong growth—almost visibly noticeable from day to day. I’ve also added three pictures showing their growth progress over the last three months. This makes me wonder whether their increased growth and consumption could be driving the rising alkalinity demand.

Additional information:
  • Tank: 90 L / 25 G, SPS/Acropora dominated
  • Dosing: Tropic Marin liquid All-For-Reef
  • Alkalinity testing: Hanna Checker
  • Dosing pump: calibrated last week
  • All of my SPS have been growing noticeably, with growth almost daily
I understand that growing SPS corals consume more alkalinity, but is it normal for consumption to increase this much over such a short period?

Could the increased growth of the corals already in the tank explain this trend, or should I be investigating another cause?
Flow/lights havn’t changed.

IMG_5732.jpeg
IMG_5963.jpeg
IMG_6115.jpeg
 
I would start by double checking the test. I know that the Hanna reagent can "expire" after being opened a lot faster than the actual expiration date suggests. Keeping it sealed air-tight and shaking it before use apparently helps a bit, but I haven't verified it myself.

Salifert offers a cheap alkalinity test that is titration-based so it offers very good accuracy for our purposes.
 
The explanation is the addition started very low and is still low. It is only 0.5 dKH per day. Very low even if rising.

Dose more
 
Just a friendly reminder if you see all for reef not maintaining your alk, check your dosing line to make sure it’s not blocked. I have to clear the line once a week.
 
Are you adjusting the alkalinity to your target level before increasing the AFR dose? My understanding is that AFR is better at maintaining alkalinity than it is at increasing it.
 
+1 on what Randy said.

If you are seeing visible daily growth in a 25 gallon, alkalinity and calcium are being depleted at a very high rate. 25 gallons is not a lot of water.

If you use the AFR calculator, you started at about 0.2-0.3dkh a day and now are at about 0.5dkh. Consumption of 0.5dkh a day in a well stocked SPS tank isn’t unheard of, especially if you have that many acros in such a small water volume.

I would follow Randy’s advice to up the dosage
 
I second checking your dosing line. I had the exact same problem with my alk dropping despite increasing the dosage. Turns out it had precipitated inside the line and completely clogged it.
 
I would start by double checking the test. I know that the Hanna reagent can "expire" after being opened a lot faster than the actual expiration date suggests. Keeping it sealed air-tight and shaking it before use apparently helps a bit, but I haven't verified it myself.

Salifert offers a cheap alkalinity test that is titration-based so it offers very good accuracy for our purposes.
During those 2 months I have switched to a new reagent as the other one was empty...


Depending on the amount and size of coral demand can increase pretty quickly IME. My AFR has gone from 20ml a day to 50ml in 3 months to keep it stable at 8ish dkH on my SPS tank after moving to a new tank.
Alright good to know. I don't mind increasing the dosage, just wanted to make sure such an increase is normal.

The explanation is the addition started very low and is still low. It is only 0.5 dKH per day. Very low even if rising.

Dose more
Allright! Will do.

Just a friendly reminder if you see all for reef not maintaining your alk, check your dosing line to make sure it’s not blocked. I have to clear the line once a week.
Thanks for the tip! Checked it and it isn't blocked.

Are you adjusting the alkalinity to your target level before increasing the AFR dose? My understanding is that AFR is better at maintaining alkalinity than it is at increasing it.
I do not. Normally when it dropped a bit I would just increase the dosage and it would slowly climb up.

+1 on what Randy said.

If you are seeing visible daily growth in a 25 gallon, alkalinity and calcium are being depleted at a very high rate. 25 gallons is not a lot of water.

If you use the AFR calculator, you started at about 0.2-0.3dkh a day and now are at about 0.5dkh. Consumption of 0.5dkh a day in a well stocked SPS tank isn’t unheard of, especially if you have that many acros in such a small water volume.

I would follow Randy’s advice to up the dosage
Thanks! Good to know. I currently have 13 different SPS in there, and they are all growing so I guess it was expected. Might be worth it to look at a automatic alk doser haha.
 
I do not. Normally when it dropped a bit I would just increase the dosage and it would slowly climb up.

I've been using AFR for 3 years and have no problem raising my alk by increasing my AFR. I think I used 2 part to get alk where I wanted it when I first started using AFR but all adjustments after have been by increasing my AFR. Randy once said ESV 2 part is 1.7 times stronger than AFR . When I need to calculate my increase I use the calculator on BRS site selecting ESV as the additive then multiply the amount x 1.7 to calculate how my much to increase my AFR.
 
During those 2 months I have switched to a new reagent as the other one was empty...



Alright good to know. I don't mind increasing the dosage, just wanted to make sure such an increase is normal.


Allright! Will do.


Thanks for the tip! Checked it and it isn't blocked.


I do not. Normally when it dropped a bit I would just increase the dosage and it would slowly climb up.


Thanks! Good to know. I currently have 13 different SPS in there, and they are all growing so I guess it was expected. Might be worth it to look at a automatic alk doser haha.
Yes 100% invest in a good doser and don't get lazy on maintenance/testing to calibrate. It will save you a lot of time if you want to be successful with SPS in the long term.
 
Yes 100% invest in a good doser and don't get lazy on maintenance/testing to calibrate. It will save you a lot of time if you want to be successful with SPS in the long term.
Agreed. I think AFR is fine manually dosed all at once since it's slow to raise alk but I ended up putting it on a doser after manually dosing for about a year. Doser has been more reliable than my memory.
I love AFR. I recently moved into a new tank. All coral grown from frags. I do very small random WCs.

PXL_20261004_223259853.MP.jpg
 
Last edited:
Just a friendly reminder if you see all for reef not maintaining your alk, check your dosing line to make sure it’s not blocked. I have to clear the line once a week.
One thing I do on my AFR system that seems to help (your mileage may vary) is to simply aim the ATO fill hose at the AFR dosing line exit (so that every time the ATO goes off, it rinses the dosing line).
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 17.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.4%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.5%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 25 26.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.3%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new