- Joined
- Aug 27, 2015
- Messages
- 1,296
- Reaction score
- 979
You guys seemed to have diagnosed his problem. As soon as he said wife said it smelled like rotten eggs and he said sulfur it became clearer. The smell of the tank is always a good indicator. Why I never tightly cover tank. The smell can even tell you when it is time to change your granulated carbon. Also why I think a skimmer is needed for gas exchange.The filter sock looks pretty normal to me, except with the addition of red cyanobacteria. Based on your descriptions, I'd highly recommend that you uncover the sump, and uncover the tank to allow as much gas exchange as you can. Open a window near the tank to allow off-gassed hydrogen sulfide out of your home.
Here's the best theory I can come up with in regards to what happened. You had an extensive mat of cyanobacteria on your rocks and/or sand, and it was thick enough to prevent free water exchange, and the substrate underneath went anoxic. Anoxic zones in reef tanks can produce hydrogen sulfide, which was the case here. As soon as the new wavemaker was introduced, it blew the cyano mats apart, which allowed the release of hydrogen sulfide into the tank. Since the tank and the sump were tightly covered, the skimmer just couldn't keep up with expelling the hydrogen sulfide, and also couldn't supply enough oxygen to the water to make up for the consumption of oxygen that was occurring from the oxidation of sulfide to sulfate.
I'm happy that most of your fish seemed to have made it. Most of the time, this sort of event kills everything in the tank.