- Joined
- Mar 27, 2022
- Messages
- 7,177
- Reaction score
- 10,511
- Location
- Easton
- What state or country do you live in
- Pennsylvania
I have a rebuttal for that. One these bacteria from my understanding and what the manufacturer told me don’t directly colonize inside a fish’s internal environment directly at least long term rather they promote healing and promotion of good gut bacteria. The reason I am doing it is because it was targeting an internal infection directly inside his intestines and swim bladder. In other words his gut microbiome. In humans if you have an infection that is stomach related or intestine related or another health condition probiotics and prebiotics are recommended to recolonize anything meds may unintentionally kill. But the same goes for nearly any antibiotic it is not something that may always be told to a patient but the research in humans supports it but it just depends on antibiotic used and condition treated. That being said you do happen to get this in the foods you eat especially yogurts one of the reasons it is not always necessary to directly take a pill form of them. Some research in humans actually supports taking it with them rather than after. But that doesn’t mean it is absolutely necessary to do it just means doing it can help healing in humans and other gut/digestive issues. But I am not comparing it as a whole because there are so many other factors. My comments were simply stating because it is logical that antibiotics can do more harm than good in all living things they are used for. All this being said neither one of us are doctors or aquatic veterinarians or researchers so I am going to leave it at that and that I do see your points!Even with all those consultations, the core logic still has a few major gaps when applied to a single pet fish in a closed aquarium.
First, commercial farming data doesn't equal pet care. You admitted yourself that there is no support for common saltwater aquarium fish, and extrapolating data from mass aquaculture (where the goal is herd harvest times and profit margins for thousands of fish in open or high-flow systems) to a single pet fish in a closed glass tank is a massive leap.
Second, efficiency is useless without fuel. Probiotics improve the Feed Conversion Ratio (FCR), meaning they help an animal process food more efficiently, but efficiency doesn't create calories out of thin air. If the puffer isn't taking in enough raw food and calories to begin with, optimizing its digestion won't make it gain weight.
Third, guessing that an "anecdotal experiment" with an industrial chemical will rebuild his gut microbiome is a gamble. While antibiotics do strip gut flora, the probiotic you're using (FeedTreat) relies on specific Bacillus strains engineered for commercial aquaculture. You have no way of knowing if these specific strains are even capable of colonizing a porcupine puffer’s native gut microbiome, or if they just pass right through as transient waste.
Fourth, there is a serious dosing nightmare and scale problem. This product is meant to be mixed by the kilogram of commercial feed, and I highly doubt you have a specialized laboratory micro-scale precise enough to accurately scale down an industrial aquaculture dose for a single portion of food. Eyeballing it means you are probably overdosing it.
Lastly, "hoping for a push" with an incorrectly dosed industrial product can actively harm his recovery. Because this product is packed with billions of bacterial spores per gram designed for large-scale systems, overdosing within a closed home aquarium can cause a severe bacterial bloom, cloud the water, and deplete dissolved oxygen. Subjecting a weak, slow-healing fish to that sudden environmental shock and water fouling will actively stress him instead of promoting healing or recovery.
In summary, I still think your efforts are commendable, but the logic is flawed due to the reasons I mentioned above. You previously mentioned that "Similar to humans or mammals antibiotics will always have a risk of killing good and bad". When antibiotics are prescribed to humans, they are rarely advised to take probiotics afterwards because they aren't necessary for recovery post-treatment.

Last edited:

The vet really wants me to weigh him once a day for a week. I have not done this…yet because I think it would be too stressful for him to take him out of his tank daily especially being a pufferfish. I am still on the fence about whether or not if or when I do this because it would be a better comparison rather than me just looking at him and comparing photos. That being said…I am doing an experimental test of probiotics meant for fish. It is my opinion/evidence supported in aquacultured fishies that prolonged sickness and antibiotic treatment can lead to malnutrition/malabsorption. And it could have killed the good bacteria in his gut similar to what happens with humans. Even though it cured or seemed to have cured/fixed the issue that caused him to go upside down which I/his vet team will never know the exact cause. My biggest fear is he is actively dying or in a deficit or has some other unknown disease or factor then all of this would be for nothing and he could just end up dying anyway. I hope not! He is a fairly young puffer only guesstimated to be around 6ish…3 and a half of which I have had him for the rest of his time was in the big blue sea. My plan is to continue to use these probiotics it has only been a few days. I also will be sending his water out for sequencing to get a better idea of the microbiome and what is living in it as a whole. A better picture than what an ICP-OES or standard aquarium testing can reveal which was insignificant. I may send his DNA sample out too simply for my own curiosity. Thank you for all those who are invested in and adore this fish. He truly is the best little guy!