ANOTHER PROBLEM ONE AFTER THE OTHER!!!!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter puccie1
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

puccie1

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Messages
292
Reaction score
75
Location
Palm Beach County
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Looks like I have my big tank cleared up but now my 200 gallon tank I have fish dying almost every day, no signs of fluke or Ick, they are not rubbing against the rocks.
Should I do a 30 day of copper treatment, please someone give me an insight to it, usually I can't tell not this time. Thanks ahead for your input!!! They all appear to look even when their dead.
 
How old is the 200 gallon tank? When and what was the last addition to the tank?
 
Looks like I have my big tank cleared up but now my 200 gallon tank I have fish dying almost every day, no signs of fluke or Ick, they are not rubbing against the rocks.
Should I do a 30 day of copper treatment, please someone give me an insight to it, usually I can't tell not this time. Thanks ahead for your input!!! They all appear to look even when their dead.
Please post a video using bright white light intensity
Did you notice if fish were breathing normal or labored. Additionally you often cannot see flukes visually but some signs will be elevated breathing rate, yawning effect, sudden darting and loss of appetite.
Any inverts in the tank and how are they doing as well as any coral?
 
Looks like I have my big tank cleared up but now my 200 gallon tank I have fish dying almost every day, no signs of fluke or Ick, they are not rubbing against the rocks.
Should I do a 30 day of copper treatment, please someone give me an insight to it, usually I can't tell not this time. Thanks ahead for your input!!! They all appear to look even when their dead.

I’m so sorry to hear, you are sure having more than your fair share of issues!

How did this angel work out:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/does-anyone-know-what-this-is.1174252/
 
I’m so sorry to hear, you are sure having more than your fair share of issues!

How did this angel work out:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/does-anyone-know-what-this-is.1174252/
My question since everyone giving me about video it there's nothing visible really, my question if you can answer since your advice been always perfect should I use copper power for 30 days in tank, I have a couple now not eating and just staying in one spot. It's not ick for sure the fish are clean as can be. I appreciate any advice, I figure it would eliminate:
    • Marine Velvet (Amyloodinium ocellatum)
    • External Fungal Infections (certain forms)
    • Suppresses other organisms like flukes and Brooklynella
    The Angel passed away once I put it back in the tank that now Im having problems with. Thanking you ahead for your time in this matter. Carl
 
Please post a video using bright white light intensity
Did you notice if fish were breathing normal or labored. Additionally you often cannot see flukes visually but some signs will be elevated breathing rate, yawning effect, sudden darting and loss of appetite.
Any inverts in the tank and how are they doing as well as any coral?Fish only I have to Butterflys that dart their head but they are always near the wave maker on the side
 
My question since everyone giving me about video it there's nothing visible really, my question if you can answer since your advice been always perfect should I use copper power for 30 days in tank, I have a couple now not eating and just staying in one spot. It's not ick for sure the fish are clean as can be. I appreciate any advice, I figure it would eliminate:
    • Marine Velvet (Amyloodinium ocellatum)
    • External Fungal Infections (certain forms)
    • Suppresses other organisms like flukes and Brooklynella
    • The Angel passed away once I put it back in the tank that now Im having problems with. Thanking you ahead for your time in this matter. Carl

If the fish aren’t breathing fast, you can rule out velvet. Since the fish don’t have ich spots, you can rule that out. Those are the two diseases that copper treats.

Fungal issues in marine fish are very rare - and those show a brown fuzzy lesion.

I’m sorry, but I’m not sure what else is left. I once had a 300 gallon system of temperate marine fish that I slowly lost over 6 months. Even histopathology didn’t show what the issue was. We ended up just leaving the remaining fish in the tank until the mortality stopped, the few fish that remained recovered. The only thing this could have been was a virus…..
 
Like suggested by @vetteguy53081, some video may add some context to your situation.

Your “nothing really visible” and others may in fact be different.

Are you sure your substrate is not leaching any heavy metals into your water? Some substrates can do that. Easy to rule out. Just run a poly filter for heavy metals to see picks anything up.

If decide to post video, you may get some more feedback.
 
Last edited:
I picture or Video is worth a thousand words. Since you have not be able to determine what is wrong, I would post video and pics of your fish, Tank, and entire setup. The Medics can sometime speculate but in this case more data is needed.
 
lighting maybe to strong over the tank which could cause higher metabolism rate in the fish and would make it worse if they aren't already eating. could be fungus, virus, bacteria in the water. could be bad salt, could be what ever your dosing or maybe a short in one of the tanks equipment
 
lighting maybe to strong over the tank which could cause higher metabolism rate in the fish and would make it worse if they aren't already eating.

Lighting doesn't drive metabolism and if it did raising metabolism would induce non eating fish to eat.

The rest of your list is not diagnostic, it just a list of things that could be wrong.
 
If the fish aren’t breathing fast, you can rule out velvet. Since the fish don’t have ich spots, you can rule that out. Those are the two diseases that copper treats.

Fungal issues in marine fish are very rare - and those show a brown fuzzy lesion.

I’m sorry, but I’m not sure what else is left. I once had a 300 gallon system of temperate marine fish that I slowly lost over 6 months. Even histopathology didn’t show what the issue was. We ended up just leaving the remaining fish in the tank until the mortality stopped, the few fish that remained recovered. The only thing this could have been was a virus…..
Good morning, I medicating the tank with copper power because I believe my Blue jaw has ick or like a whitish film not sure since he won't come near the front. My question is running my protein skimmer will it weaken the concentration of the copper power I have it at 2.40 I remember when I used it in my big tank I had to add more copper everyday because the strength would drop daily. Again Thanks for your time in this matter, Carl
 
I trust you mean “the tank” is your QT where you have deployed Copper Power.

As you know, it’s deadly to all corals, shrimps, and inverts, but “can” be used in a fish only tank.

However, It may absorb into porous rock and substrate making these, unusable far into the future as it may leach out into the water over time.

It would kill, any biological films you’ve built.

I have not run any skimmer when using it.
 
Last edited:
I trust you mean “the tank” is your QT where you have deployed Copper Power.

As you know, it’s deadly to all corals, shrimps, and inverts, but “can” be used in a fish only tank.

However, It may absorb into porous rock and substrate making these, unusable far into the future as it may leach out into the water over time.

It would kill, any biological films you’ve built.

I have not run any skimmer when using it.
No its fish only tank,
 
Good morning, I medicating the tank with copper power because I believe my Blue jaw has ick or like a whitish film not sure since he won't come near the front. My question is running my protein skimmer will it weaken the concentration of the copper power I have it at 2.40 I remember when I used it in my big tank I had to add more copper everyday because the strength would drop daily. Again Thanks for your time in this matter, Carl

Copper isn’t removed by protein skimmers, except the small amount in the collected effluent.

Copper binds with any calcium based solid material in the water. A small amount may “plate out” on the tank surfaces, but in tanks with no coral sand or rock, the copper may drop the first day, but when you do a partial redose to the typical 2.25 ppm, it stays there pretty well for weeks.
 
Copper isn’t removed by protein skimmers, except the small amount in the collected effluent.

Copper binds with any calcium based solid material in the water. A small amount may “plate out” on the tank surfaces, but in tanks with no coral sand or rock, the copper may drop the first day, but when you do a partial redose to the typical 2.25 ppm, it stays there pretty well for weeks.
Thank you
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 3 60.0%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new