Coal ID at petco

[C4ctus99]

Not into coral yet, but a local petco had some frags for $25 each, just wanted to see if any of these are worth that

 

[Derrick0580]

Bunch of random leather corals, the greenish one is the only one I would consider, no one wants ugly brown ones!

 

[Sharkbait19]

From left to right
Pic 1:
Toadstool leather, green sinularia, sinularia, thick finger lobophytum
Pic 2:
Sinularia, devils hand leather, toadstool, maybe a toadstool but it looks quite unhealthy.

All are very hardy and great beginner corals. I got my leathers at a petco for the same price.

 

[C4ctus99]

Bunch of random leather corals, the greenish one is the only one I would consider, no one wants ugly brown ones!

Thanks, figured as much. Shoulda posted in the soft coral general discussion I guess but new to coral ids

 

[C4ctus99]

The got, I believe, cyano on the base. Also setting up a tank today so no go. I like the look of the toadstool though.

 

[Derrick0580]

The got, I believe, cyano on the base. Also setting up a tank today so no go. I like the look of the toadstool though.

Iodine dip and scrub the base would solve all of that!

 

[C4ctus99]

Iodine dip and scrub the base would solve all of that!

Will definitely remember that, just gonna wait. Bringing home an Acan on Saturday so I’ll wait till then

 

[ryanjohn1]

The toad stools will get very big. I’ve got one from there. Whenever I get something from that place I consider it a rescue

 

[thamnasteroid]

From left to right
Pic 1:
Toadstool leather, green sinularia, sinularia, thick finger lobophytum
Pic 2:
Sinularia, devils hand leather, toadstool, maybe a toadstool but it looks quite unhealthy.

All are very hardy and great beginner corals. I got my leathers at a petco for the same price.

Those are Sclerophytum, not Sinularia. There was a recent reclassification that reduced Sinularia to just S. brassica.