Convince me why All For Reef is worth it

I use TM hydrometer and usually check weekly, at least.
Prior to dosing, my salinity was always staying consistent.
Once I got to a point of consistent/daily dosing, I kept noticing weekly rise from 1.0264 to 1.0265 so started wondering and then, after much reading, came to the conclusion that it must be from 2-part.
*not 100% sure but observations seem to make sense to me

Also, my 0.5 dKH/day estimate is just rough guess,,, so that could be inaccurate.
I really just dose a specific amount and monitor, then adjust if necessary.

Whatever the exact rate of increase, that plan seems appropriate. :)
 
As a complete noob, coming up on my one year anniversary. AFR is the first and only product I have used for Alkalinity. I'm only using 20ml a day in a Mariner M180 so not much. I also started dosing Triton MYTE three months ago for the balance of trace elements. So I see a monthly ICP and AFR with the additional trace elements is keeping everything in check. Alkalinity, Calcium, and Magnesium are staying steady. I dose everything through a Hydros Blenny. Its easy and its working. The only reason I have thought of switching to something else is to get a pH bump. Maybe Randys DIY or Not a Feesh 2 part. Just because I could use more pH and I get tired of changing my CO2 scrubber every week.
 
As a complete noob, coming up on my one year anniversary. AFR is the first and only product I have used for Alkalinity. I'm only using 20ml a day in a Mariner M180 so not much. I also started dosing Triton MYTE three months ago for the balance of trace elements. So I see a monthly ICP and AFR with the additional trace elements is keeping everything in check. Alkalinity, Calcium, and Magnesium are staying steady. I dose everything through a Hydros Blenny. Its easy and its working. The only reason I have thought of switching to something else is to get a pH bump. Maybe Randys DIY or Not a Feesh 2 part. Just because I could use more pH and I get tired of changing my CO2 scrubber every week.
Doesn't sound like you have a lot of SPS so curious what you want to accomplish by bumping pH? Nothing wrong with bumping it but the only benefit I have seen from raising pH is faster growth of stoney corals. It was a very noticeable increase in growth but really if someone doesn't have the need or type of coral that do grow faster from the bump I'm not sure its worth the hassle. I ran a tank mostly acros for 2 years running 7.6-7.9 daily and the tank did surprisingly well. I bumped pH by adding an outside air line to the skimmer out of curiosity and went to 8.0-8.3 daily. I didn't bother running the airline when I moved tanks.
 
Doesn't sound like you have a lot of SPS so curious what you want to accomplish by bumping pH? Nothing wrong with bumping it but the only benefit I have seen from raising pH is faster growth of stoney corals. It was a very noticeable increase in growth but really if someone doesn't have the need or type of coral that do grow faster from the bump I'm not sure its worth the hassle. I ran a tank mostly acros for 2 years running 7.6-7.9 daily and the tank did surprisingly well. I bumped pH by adding an outside air line to the skimmer out of curiosity and went to 8.0-8.3 daily. I didn't bother running the airline when I moved tanks.

I currently have 10 SPS frags growing in the tank. Raising pH would just be to try and increase growth for those. I didn't say I was going to switch just that if I did that would be why. I'm more if if its not broke don't fix it kind of reefer. LOL
 
I currently have 10 SPS frags growing in the tank. Raising pH would just be to try and increase growth for those. I didn't say I was going to switch just that if I did that would be why. I'm more if if its not broke don't fix it kind of reefer. LOL
Sorry I didn't realize your growing some SPS. I see people that have softies wanting to raise it and I like to ask. If you can raise it without a lot of hassle it would probably be worth it. My frags had already grown into small colonies when I added the airline and my growth increased so much my AFR amount doubled the first two months. I could see growth looking at coral where before I would have to look at before and after pics.
 
Im using about 0.5ml a day on this tank and things have been relatively stable since set up. I think it’s a great option for someone looking for a single-solution option.

DSC05438_Original.jpeg
 
As a complete noob, coming up on my one year anniversary. AFR is the first and only product I have used for Alkalinity. I'm only using 20ml a day in a Mariner M180 so not much. I also started dosing Triton MYTE three months ago for the balance of trace elements. So I see a monthly ICP and AFR with the additional trace elements is keeping everything in check. Alkalinity, Calcium, and Magnesium are staying steady. I dose everything through a Hydros Blenny. Its easy and its working. The only reason I have thought of switching to something else is to get a pH bump. Maybe Randys DIY or Not a Feesh 2 part. Just because I could use more pH and I get tired of changing my CO2 scrubber every week.
I made the switch a few months ago to Not a Feesh for the same reasons you outlined. No complaints.
 
Probably something folks continuously monitoring may notice
Prolly closer to true if you said not testing is required. ;)

The ticket is **heavy** usage of sodium- and chloride-based ingredients (e.g. Randy's Recipes, etc) in a reef system that's not getting regular water changes. The calcium and carbonates get used up, but not the sodium or the chlorides.

At least that's how I got there. :)

Calling it a problem would be exaggerating things because even under heavy usage conditions it happens slowly. It is something to know about tho!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 5 16.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 3 10.0%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 3 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 2 6.7%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 5 16.7%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 5 16.7%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 5 16.7%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 2 6.7%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new