Cycling my first saltwater tank

  • Thread starter Thread starter danny4440
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

danny4440

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 8, 2025
Messages
19
Reaction score
8
Location
nova scotia
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello everyone I am new to the saltwater side of this hobby and I am currently cycling via method of ghost feeding (flakes) I understand ammonia dosing may be superior but I am taking a shot using this method. I have Carib sea arag alive sand and 4 pounds of caribsea life rock (nano tank) today (day 4) I have an ammonia spike of nearly 8ppm (using api liquid test) I would say around 6ppm as not quite as dark green my ph is 7.8 my nitrite is zero my nitrate spiked to 20 ppm today (10 yesterday) why do I have nitrate already (started at zero) and do I stop ghost feeding for awhile where ammonia is quite high? Thank you for any input or advice (:
 
I think many would say just to ride it out, but personally I'd do a water change to try and bring the ammonia down. The danger of letting the ammonia get too high is that it can start to impact the bacteria you're trying to grow, and it can stall your cycle. So I'd get the ammonia down to about 2ppm or so.

Did you add anything for bottled bacteria?
 
yes you can stop ghost feeding until all ammonia is converted to nitrate.
Thank you it is my understanding that I should have ammonia spike then nitrite later on then nitrate is it normal that I already have nitrate but zero or near zero nitrite thanks again
 

This is worth watching. I also replied to your other post.

You may be seeing nitrite giving a false reading for nitrate at this point, especially with the API test kit, so don't worry about that too much right now.
 
Did you add nitrifying bacteria after the ammonia showed up?
 
I think many would say just to ride it out, but personally I'd do a water change to try and bring the ammonia down. The danger of letting the ammonia get too high is that it can start to impact the bacteria you're trying to grow, and it can stall your cycle. So I'd get the ammonia down to about 2ppm or so.

Did you add anything for bottled bacteria?
Thank you I added nutrafin cycle for three days before adding my sand and rock I only count it as four days cycling because that’s how long it’s been since I added fish food first I do not know if this is a good product I read mixed reviews but I didn’t trust the claim that it makes it immediately safe for fish then decided to go ghost feeding route
 
This is worth watching. I also replied to your other post.

You may be seeing nitrite giving a false reading for nitrate at this point, especially with the API test kit, so don't worry about that too much right now.
Will do thank you new to reef to reef and thought my first post didn’t post
 
Thank you it is my understanding that I should have ammonia spike then nitrite later on then nitrate is it normal that I already have nitrate but zero or near zero nitrite thanks again
nitrate shouldn't be zero if it spiked previously, unless you are doing water changes or using some sort of chemical media to reduce nitrate - I'd suspect testing error here
 
Did you add nitrifying bacteria after the ammonia showed up?
All I have on hand is nutrafin cycle I don’t think it’s correct bacteria so I stopped adding it when I started ghost feeding thank you
 
nitrate shouldn't be zero if it spiked previously, unless you are doing water changes or using some sort of chemical media to reduce nitrate - I'd suspect testing error here
It’s is my nitrate currently at 20 ppm and nitrite near zero thank you
 
Thank you I added nutrafin cycle for three days before adding my sand and rock I only count it as four days cycling because that’s how long it’s been since I added fish food first I do not know if this is a good product I read mixed reviews but I didn’t trust the claim that it makes it immediately safe for fish then decided to go ghost feeding route
I'm not familiar with the Nutrafin product, but I'm assuming it adds beneficial bacteria to the system? If so, those bacteria need the rocks and sand to live on, so they really weren't doing much without the rock and sand. I would say with that in mind day 1 of your cycle was when you added rocks and sand. I may even add more bacteria now that the rocks are in place. The only product like this that seems to live up to the claim of adding fish "immediately" is Fritz TurboStart. Most others are going to take quite some time.
 
It’s is my nitrate currently at 20 ppm and nitrite near zero thank you
I see, that makes sense. You should see nitrate continue up as ammonia drops, and when ammonia is zero, you'll do a water change to get nitrate to a manageable level and be ready to add your first creatures.
 
All I have on hand is nutrafin cycle I don’t think it’s correct bacteria so I stopped adding it when I started ghost feeding thank you
Did this product specifically say it's for saltwater?
 
I see, that makes sense. You should see nitrate continue up as ammonia drops, and when ammonia is zero, you'll do a water change to get nitrate to a manageable level and be ready to add your first creatures.
I carbon dosed to bottom out nitrates. Did need to add phosphates but no way I'm wasting all that water or dealing with buckets. Surprised this isn't mainstream already. Seems crazy throwing the baby out with the bath water :rolling-on-the-floor-laughing:
 
I see, that makes sense. You should see nitrate continue up as ammonia drops, and when ammonia is zero, you'll do a water change to get nitrate to a manageable level and be ready to add your first creatures.
Thank you very much
 
I carbon dosed to bottom out nitrates. Did need to add phosphates but no way I'm wasting all that water or dealing with buckets. Surprised this isn't mainstream already. Seems crazy throwing the baby out with the bath water :rolling-on-the-floor-laughing:
Definitely an option! I just recommend water changes for newer hobbyists because it is harder to make mistakes.
 
Says for fresh and saltwater use
That's a bit of a red flag to me. The bacteria for freshwater denitrification are not the same species as the ones for saltwater. I'm not sure, but I don't know if both can be packaged in the same bottle.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.3%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.4%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.8%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.4%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.1%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 11 11.8%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 24 25.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.5%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new