It's interesting to note that many of us had, or still have, some fear of ordering fish over the internet and having them overnighted to us. I know I originally did back in the day. However, this is pretty much what your LFS does. Heck, you maybe even cut out an acclimation or two. So, if you buy from a reputable dealer, and acclimate using that vendor's prescribed method, you will be OK most times. And when you are not, a good vendor will resolve it to your satisfaction. I know that none of us (generally) can look at a bag of water and say "This fish needs to be acclimated by method X, but that one by method y." So you have to go with what the vendor recommends so they will honor their warranty. And as indicated previously, no single method is the only way.
So GatorBen, jump in there and get you a fish or two. Markazadad, take your lumps with R2G and learn a lesson. Maybe use your credit for some of their hardier items that can travel well (I see the have a $1/polyp zoa sale on, and snails and crabs are tough.) Then find you a new vendor for fish. Live Aquaria has been mentioned, as has Saltwaterfish.com, of which I have bought from both. LA always has a good selection and performs admirably IMO, and Saltwaterfish is a professional outfit in warmer climes that may make for easier shipping as we roll into the winter months.