Emp Angel and Sohal Looking Stressed From Carbon

  • Thread starter Thread starter 0MNSH1ZLLC
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

0MNSH1ZLLC

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 4, 2023
Messages
349
Reaction score
228
Location
Virginia
Rating - 0%
0   0   0


Long story short, I went on vacation and both my mp40s crapped out. Got a slight bloom. I don't normally run carbon and I added 6 bags of chemipure blue that I rinsed for a few minutes, maybe too short but definitely my normal process for rinsing.

The Emp and Sohal both still eating like pigs and I'm changing water every other day, but they still look bad.

Any thoughts on how I can get them back to looking great again? @Jay Hemdal

There is 285 total gallons of water and the amount of chemipure I added was for 210 gallons. I've removed the carbon a few days ago. This is a well-established tank that doesn't normally have issues. It's been running like this for nearly 4 years no deaths in a while and they normally look excellent.

Thanks in advance!
 
Last edited:


Long story short, I went on vacation and both my mp40s crapped out. Got a slight bloom. I don't normally run carbon and I added 6 bags of chemipure blue that I rinsed for a few minutes, maybe too short but definitely my normal process for rinsing.

The Emp and Sohal both still eating like pigs and I'm changing water every other day, but they still look bad.

Any thoughts on how I can get them back to looking great again? @Jay Hemdal

There is 285 total gallons of water and the amount of chemipure I added was for 210 gallons. I've removed the carbon a few days ago. This is a well-established tank that doesn't normally have issues. It's been running like this for nearly 4 years no deaths in a while and they normally look excellent.

Thanks in advance!

I agree and while I see this often on emperors, Its appears to be ich or flukes, however flukes will offer tell-tale signs such as rapid breathing - same with velvet), loss of appetite, hiding, itching/scratching and sudden darting across tank.
I suspect possible ich but other at least Yet are Not showing signs. I use CP Blue and for years and without issues, Anything change such as type water, temperature, salinity?
 
I agree and while I see this often on emperors, Its appears to be ich or flukes, however flukes will offer tell-tale signs such as rapid breathing - same with velvet), loss of appetite, hiding, itching/scratching and sudden darting across tank.
I suspect possible ich but other at least Yet are Not showing signs. I use CP Blue and for years and without issues, Anything change such as type water, temperature, salinity?

No other issues at all, eating like pigs...here is a 2 minute vid. I thought it was carbon bc of the look of the HLLE on the Sohal.



looking for my refractomer now but checked a few days ago and the salinity was spot on. I've done at least 2 water changes since and everything is pretty much the same. I'm going to put in some new filter floss today.

I used 1 bag on the 90 gallon and noticed a spot on my orange shoulder. This one has a 20-gallon sump.



I've used chemipure in the past without issues, could it be I just didn't rinse it enough?
 
No other issues at all, eating like pigs...here is a 2 minute vid. I thought it was carbon bc of the look of the HLLE on the Sohal.



looking for my refractomer now but checked a few days ago and the salinity was spot on. I've done at least 2 water changes since and everything is pretty much the same. I'm going to put in some new filter floss today.

I used 1 bag on the 90 gallon and noticed a spot on my orange shoulder. This one has a 20-gallon sump.



I've used chemipure in the past without issues, could it be I just didn't rinse it enough?

Orange shoulder has a scar from a small injury and should heal. If it becomes red or sore, will require treatment in a separate tank using Seachem neoplex
The sohal has missing pattern which should show good striping and emperor has many spots which can be as simple as stress from water quality or past disease issue. The fact that its eating is positive. Can carbon play a role, possibly yes
 
Orange shoulder has a scar from a small injury and should heal. If it becomes red or sore, will require treatment in a separate tank using Seachem neoplex
The sohal has missing pattern which should show good striping and emperor has many spots which can be as simple as stress from water quality or past disease issue. The fact that its eating is positive. Can carbon play a role, possibly yes
Thanks, any thoughts on treatment for the big tank?

Or just leave it alone...I'm guessing if they keep eating, they will eventually heal up.

The pattern loss on the Sohal as odd to me also.

I need to change the bulb on the UV, I've been putting it off...
 
Thanks, any thoughts on treatment for the big tank?

Or just leave it alone...I'm guessing if they keep eating, they will eventually heal up.

The pattern loss on the Sohal as odd to me also.

I need to change the bulb on the UV, I've been putting it off...
Unless its a FOWLER tank only, you can use coppersafe if signs of parasite or velvet show up. Observe for change or return of pattern if its a reaction to water quality.
 
Unless its a FOWLER tank only, you can use coppersafe if signs of parasite or velvet show up. Observe for change or return of pattern if its a reaction to water quality.

I've got some OG hermits that are still alive from day 1 and a 3.5 foot tess in here. I'll hold off on the copper until they aren't eating or breathing heavy. I can also QT if it gets worse.

Any thoughts on Prazipro?
 
I've got some OG hermits that are still alive from day 1 and a 3.5 foot tess in here. I'll hold off on the copper until they aren't eating or breathing heavy. I can also QT if it gets worse.

Any thoughts on Prazipro?
You can use prazi. Assure to add O2 as prazi reduces oxygen and appetite slightly
 


Long story short, I went on vacation and both my mp40s crapped out. Got a slight bloom. I don't normally run carbon and I added 6 bags of chemipure blue that I rinsed for a few minutes, maybe too short but definitely my normal process for rinsing.

The Emp and Sohal both still eating like pigs and I'm changing water every other day, but they still look bad.

Any thoughts on how I can get them back to looking great again? @Jay Hemdal

There is 285 total gallons of water and the amount of chemipure I added was for 210 gallons. I've removed the carbon a few days ago. This is a well-established tank that doesn't normally have issues. It's been running like this for nearly 4 years no deaths in a while and they normally look excellent.

Thanks in advance!


The sohal has slight HLLE around the face, did it have those marks prior to the carbon.

Emperor angels are weird - they get those stress spots really easily. Usually it’s a result of flukes or ich, but sometimes they get those for no apparent reason.
 
The sohal has slight HLLE around the face, did it have those marks prior to the carbon.

Emperor angels are weird - they get those stress spots really easily. Usually it’s a result of flukes or ich, but sometimes they get those for no apparent reason.

No, the HLLE and the spots on the angel showed up at the same time right after putting in the chemipure.
 
No, the HLLE and the spots on the angel showed up at the same time right after putting in the chemipure.

Ugh - it could be the Chemipure for the HLLE on the sohal, but that isn’t an immediate thing - even with lots of carbon dust in the tank it takes two to four weeks to see signs of HLLE….
I’ve never seen emperors show stress spots after carbon use, but I haven’t used carbon on any emperors in over 30 years, so maybe?
 
Ugh - it could be the Chemipure for the HLLE on the sohal, but that isn’t an immediate thing - even with lots of carbon dust in the tank it takes two to four weeks to see signs of HLLE….
I’ve never seen emperors show stress spots after carbon use, but I haven’t used carbon on any emperors in over 30 years, so maybe?

I'm done with carbon after this...but the Sohal is improving visually.

They are both exactly the same except they look off...do they ever fully recover from carbon dust OD?

I'm guessing the no water changes and reduced flow from losing the 2 mp40s for a few weeks couldn't have helped. There's definitely still a slight fog.

Anything I can do with diet? Selcon? I've been feeding clams, octopus and nori from the grocery store hoping its better than cubes.
 
I'm done with carbon after this...but the Sohal is improving visually.

They are both exactly the same except they look off...do they ever fully recover from carbon dust OD?

I'm guessing the no water changes and reduced flow from losing the 2 mp40s for a few weeks couldn't have helped. There's definitely still a slight fog.

Anything I can do with diet? Selcon? I've been feeding clams, octopus and nori from the grocery store hoping its better than cubes.

Getting the carbon dust / fines out of the tank is tricky. Using a siphon clean on the sand can help, but the carbon tends to get everywhere. I had one tank years ago that had just a little carbon dust in the amp and it kept giving the fish HLLE until I tore the tank down and washed everything.

I should add that I’ve used well rinsed Chemipure many times with now issues - but I rinse a LOT longer than they say to.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 4.5%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 13 59.1%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new