Epsom salt with copper treatment?

Cjud7982 · Mar 22, 2018

Just wondering if it is safe to add epsom salt to a qt tank that is currently under copper treatment. I am not a chemist and want to make sure the sulfates from the epsom salt will not interfere with my copper and throw the levels off. I dont think it will be a problem but worth double checking.

Big G · Mar 22, 2018

Let's ask our reef chemist @Randy Holmes-Farley

Randy Holmes-Farley · Mar 22, 2018

It’s no concern, but why are you adding it?

Cjud7982 · Mar 22, 2018

I am qt all if my fish and treating with copper to fight ich and other parasites. My yellow tang is showing a single popeye and I would like to try and give him some relief.

4FordFamily · Mar 22, 2018

It won’t be an issue

Randy Holmes-Farley · Mar 23, 2018

Cjud7982 said:
I am qt all if my fish and treating with copper to fight ich and other parasites. My yellow tang is showing a single popeye and I would like to try and give him some relief.

I could be mistaken, but I don't think that will be beneficial in seawater. Seawater already contains way, way more magnesium and sulfate than the popeye recommendation for freshwater treatment. Such an addition will hardly budge the values of magnesium and sulfate.

Cjud7982 · Mar 23, 2018

Randy, thank you for your response. I understand that in the seawater the levels of magnesium are high, around 1400 ppm and I am not sure what the values for sulfates are. Nor do I really know what sulfates are as silly as that sounds. So I do follow your logic. Be aware that I barely passed my chemistry 101 class in college lol. I was never very good at balance equations, positively charged ions, or any thing like that even though I find it interesting. Can you explain your reasoning? Does the magnesium sulfate bond of the Epsom salt immediately break apart into free magnesium and sulfates once mixed into an aqueous solution? If so, why is it so openly recommended for small bacterial infections as well as popeye if it doesnt effect the water chemistry significantly? I am not doubting your response, just wish to understand the chemistry a bit more.
Whether it was coincidence or not, I have no clue, but I added the recommended dosage to my qt tank last night and my yellow tangs eye appears significantly better. Which regardless of the reason, I am happier :)