Help fishes died even in QT

izzysdn

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 17, 2026
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello everyone! I’m honestly clueless about what could be causing these repeated fish deaths, and I’m hoping someone experienced with fish diseases can help me figure this out.

Here’s what happened:

Early October

I noticed that my purple tang, which I had purchased from local hobbyists in September, had developed some spots. It was a healthy, medium-sized fish when I bought it. I suspected either ich or velvet, but since it was still eating, I initially decided to manage it as ich while waiting for my quarantine tank to arrive.

Two days later, my Midas blenny, which had been eating well the day before, suddenly lost interest in food and died that night.The following evening, one of my clownfish also died.Worried about losing more fish, I quickly performed H₂O₂ dips and transferred the fish to my QT with copper at 2 ppm. Unfortunately, my purple tang died a few hours after the dip. Another clownfish died in quarantine the following day.After my formalin and metronidazole arrived

A few days later, I started performing 30-minute formalin dips every 2–3 days, followed by 100% water changes to provide a clean environment. I also treated the quarantine tank with copper and metronidazole.

I continued the treatment protocol for approximately two weeks before removing the copper. After that, I only did once a week water change with metronidazole.

Fast-forward to now

Two days ago, I noticed one of my anthias had a bulging eye and was breathing extremely rapidly. I performed another water change and added metronidazole, hoping to help it recover. I had also ordered Epsom salt, thinking it might help with the swollen eye, but unfortunately, the anthias died the following day before the Epsom salt arrived. (Forgot to take photos)


Then, this evening, I found another anthias dead. When I checked on the fish that morning, it wasn’t breathing heavily, so its sudden death caught me completely off guard.I’ve attached photographs of my deceased fish because I’m struggling to understand what’s happening.


20261102_171813_66AEA257-A195-48B3-9294-301B5AEB0B90.png


20261102_171813_6B4709E7-1791-47E9-BE62-225C53AF4F8E.png


20261102_171813_8B61F555-D5E4-485F-B3E6-67D5970DE6F2.png


20261102_171813_E4C594D1-3AE5-4A84-B862-5E10A1C3A715.png


20261102_171813_B4EDEC36-A2EB-45B2-930D-3A556A1EFFA8.png


20261102_171814_E401F7E5-34F6-4E73-917B-E09CC29A132F.png


20261102_171814_22FEC5B2-47C4-4473-A8F0-45612B05AB62.png


20261102_171814_BAF2AF2B-4B1A-44B6-85F5-EDEE97B1088C.png


20261102_171814_513A173C-A73F-4C41-A71D-6F02D37C2E34.png


20261102_171814_E2BDDF12-EE84-42EF-8FD3-45DA58E495A9.png
 
Last edited:
How old is your tank? What is the tank size?
Can you show a full tank picture and also the qt tank, lets see both tanks so we know what we are working with.
To me, some of those fish are looking thin and I see at least one tattered tail, so I think there is some level of stress and aggression happening.

#fishmedics for more help
 
Hello everyone! I’m honestly clueless about what could be causing these repeated fish deaths, and I’m hoping someone experienced with fish diseases can help me figure this out.

Here’s what happened:

Early October

I noticed that my purple tang, which I had purchased from local hobbyists in September, had developed some spots. It was a healthy, medium-sized fish when I bought it. I suspected either ich or velvet, but since it was still eating, I initially decided to manage it as ich while waiting for my quarantine tank to arrive.

Two days later, my Midas blenny, which had been eating well the day before, suddenly lost interest in food and died that night.The following evening, one of my clownfish also died.Worried about losing more fish, I quickly performed H₂O₂ dips and transferred the fish to my QT with copper at 2 ppm. Unfortunately, my purple tang died a few hours after the dip. Another clownfish died in quarantine the following day.After my formalin and metronidazole arrived

A few days later, I started performing 30-minute formalin dips every 2–3 days, followed by 100% water changes to provide a clean environment. I also treated the quarantine tank with copper and metronidazole.

I continued the treatment protocol for approximately two weeks before removing the copper. After that, I only did once a week water change with metronidazole.

Fast-forward to now

Two days ago, I noticed one of my anthias had a bulging eye and was breathing extremely rapidly. I performed another water change and added metronidazole, hoping to help it recover. I had also ordered Epsom salt, thinking it might help with the swollen eye, but unfortunately, the anthias died the following day before the Epsom salt arrived. (Forgot to take photos)


Then, this evening, I found another anthias dead. When I checked on the fish that morning, it wasn’t breathing heavily, so its sudden death caught me completely off guard.I’ve attached photographs of my deceased fish because I’m struggling to understand what’s happening.


20261102_171813_66AEA257-A195-48B3-9294-301B5AEB0B90.png


20261102_171813_6B4709E7-1791-47E9-BE62-225C53AF4F8E.png


20261102_171813_8B61F555-D5E4-485F-B3E6-67D5970DE6F2.png


20261102_171813_E4C594D1-3AE5-4A84-B862-5E10A1C3A715.png


20261102_171813_B4EDEC36-A2EB-45B2-930D-3A556A1EFFA8.png


20261102_171814_E401F7E5-34F6-4E73-917B-E09CC29A132F.png


20261102_171814_22FEC5B2-47C4-4473-A8F0-45612B05AB62.png


20261102_171814_BAF2AF2B-4B1A-44B6-85F5-EDEE97B1088C.png


20261102_171814_513A173C-A73F-4C41-A71D-6F02D37C2E34.png


20261102_171814_E2BDDF12-EE84-42EF-8FD3-45DA58E495A9.png
I question the level of formalin used and how long as it is not advised unless used precisely at 37% in addition to the risks to both fish and human. FW dips can be stressful and are only a means of temporary relief mainly for flukes and Brook. Same applies to Metroplex which needs to be applied precise by weight and used Only when absolotely necessary. I see here too many meds in a short span of time.
Were fish breathing normal or labored?
Any sudden darting or scratching? Sounds like ich may have been present and safest use would have been coppersafe at 2.25ppm for 30 days.
 
"H₂O₂ dips"?

Did you really dip in Hydrogen Peroxide or did you mean fresh water?
 
"I noticed that my purple tang, which I had purchased from local hobbyists in September, had developed some spots. It was a healthy, medium-sized fish when I bought it. I suspected either ich or velvet, but since it was still eating, I initially decided to manage it as ich while waiting for my quarantine tank to arrive."

Sounds like that purple tang brought something into your display tank that spread... yea
We may need to know more about your main display - setup and all
 
Hello everyone! I’m honestly clueless about what could be causing these repeated fish deaths, and I’m hoping someone experienced with fish diseases can help me figure this out.

Here’s what happened:

Early October

I noticed that my purple tang, which I had purchased from local hobbyists in September, had developed some spots. It was a healthy, medium-sized fish when I bought it. I suspected either ich or velvet, but since it was still eating, I initially decided to manage it as ich while waiting for my quarantine tank to arrive.

Two days later, my Midas blenny, which had been eating well the day before, suddenly lost interest in food and died that night.The following evening, one of my clownfish also died.Worried about losing more fish, I quickly performed H₂O₂ dips and transferred the fish to my QT with copper at 2 ppm. Unfortunately, my purple tang died a few hours after the dip. Another clownfish died in quarantine the following day.After my formalin and metronidazole arrived

A few days later, I started performing 30-minute formalin dips every 2–3 days, followed by 100% water changes to provide a clean environment. I also treated the quarantine tank with copper and metronidazole.

I continued the treatment protocol for approximately two weeks before removing the copper. After that, I only did once a week water change with metronidazole.

Fast-forward to now

Two days ago, I noticed one of my anthias had a bulging eye and was breathing extremely rapidly. I performed another water change and added metronidazole, hoping to help it recover. I had also ordered Epsom salt, thinking it might help with the swollen eye, but unfortunately, the anthias died the following day before the Epsom salt arrived. (Forgot to take photos)


Then, this evening, I found another anthias dead. When I checked on the fish that morning, it wasn’t breathing heavily, so its sudden death caught me completely off guard.I’ve attached photographs of my deceased fish because I’m struggling to understand what’s happening.


20261102_171813_66AEA257-A195-48B3-9294-301B5AEB0B90.png


20261102_171813_6B4709E7-1791-47E9-BE62-225C53AF4F8E.png


20261102_171813_8B61F555-D5E4-485F-B3E6-67D5970DE6F2.png


20261102_171813_E4C594D1-3AE5-4A84-B862-5E10A1C3A715.png


20261102_171813_B4EDEC36-A2EB-45B2-930D-3A556A1EFFA8.png


20261102_171814_E401F7E5-34F6-4E73-917B-E09CC29A132F.png


20261102_171814_22FEC5B2-47C4-4473-A8F0-45612B05AB62.png


20261102_171814_BAF2AF2B-4B1A-44B6-85F5-EDEE97B1088C.png


20261102_171814_513A173C-A73F-4C41-A71D-6F02D37C2E34.png


20261102_171814_E2BDDF12-EE84-42EF-8FD3-45DA58E495A9.png

Sorry to hear about all that.

It is really difficult to see much on dead fish.

Formalin and peroxide dips are generally not appropriate for quarantine bless the fish are moved to a fresh tank after each dip. These dips are also very stressful.

What copper product did you use and at what concentration?

Did you test for ammonia during this time?

Take a look at the quarantine protocol we developed:

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/current-quarantine-protocol.825055/
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHEN REEFING GETS TOUGH, WHAT KEEPS YOU MOST INVESTED?

  • My livestock depends on me, so I keep showing up for them

    Votes: 10 71.4%
  • I look for small signs that things are improving

    Votes: 2 14.3%
  • I want to figure out what’s going wrong

    Votes: 1 7.1%
  • I remind myself that rough stretches will pass...just keep reefing

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I lean on other reefers for advice or encouragement

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I simplify, step back from tinkering, and give the tank time

    Votes: 1 7.1%
  • Honestly, sometimes I wonder if I want to keep going

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new