- Joined
- Sep 29, 2024
- Messages
- 53
- Reaction score
- 56
- Location
- Berlin
- What state or country do you live in
- Other International
I’ve shared my macroalgae tank build here before. The setup was easy to build, no sump, just a canister filter. After about 1.5 years I’ve been very happy with how the tank has developed. However, now I’m preparing to move, and I’m considering using that moment to upgrade to a larger tank. That has me rethinking filtration.
Earlier, @GARRIGA suggested combining my existing canister filter with an undergravel filter, essentially using the canister to drive the undergravel system.
@GARRIGA:
As far as I understand, @Paul B is also running a setup along these lines. The main appeal, as I understand it, is biodiversity: small organisms that would otherwise be sucked into a filter have a better chance of surviving.
Does it make sense to lean into a more old-school approach and experiment with an UG filter? Or should I take the opportunity to go in the opposite direction and upgrade to a sump-based system, which help keeping more demanding corals?
Earlier, @GARRIGA suggested combining my existing canister filter with an undergravel filter, essentially using the canister to drive the undergravel system.
@GARRIGA:
Basic Under Gravel filter all that's needed. Don't need wave makers although HOB would be nice for easy maintenance of mechanical and chemical such as floss and GAC as well as providing additional flow.
One other option is use that canister to drive the UG and periodically stir the bottom to loosen detritus and force it into the canister. Let it decompose naturally as that will feed the macro. Keep the HOB for floss and GAC thereby eliminating the need to open the canister assuming large coarse media used. Let nature do nature. KISS
As far as I understand, @Paul B is also running a setup along these lines. The main appeal, as I understand it, is biodiversity: small organisms that would otherwise be sucked into a filter have a better chance of surviving.
Does it make sense to lean into a more old-school approach and experiment with an UG filter? Or should I take the opportunity to go in the opposite direction and upgrade to a sump-based system, which help keeping more demanding corals?
Last edited:




