Going Old School? Thoughts on an Undergravel Filter?

  • Thread starter Thread starter kolius
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

kolius

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 29, 2024
Messages
53
Reaction score
56
Location
Berlin
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I’ve shared my macroalgae tank build here before. The setup was easy to build, no sump, just a canister filter. After about 1.5 years I’ve been very happy with how the tank has developed. However, now I’m preparing to move, and I’m considering using that moment to upgrade to a larger tank. That has me rethinking filtration.

Earlier, @GARRIGA suggested combining my existing canister filter with an undergravel filter, essentially using the canister to drive the undergravel system.

@GARRIGA:
Basic Under Gravel filter all that's needed. Don't need wave makers although HOB would be nice for easy maintenance of mechanical and chemical such as floss and GAC as well as providing additional flow.

One other option is use that canister to drive the UG and periodically stir the bottom to loosen detritus and force it into the canister. Let it decompose naturally as that will feed the macro. Keep the HOB for floss and GAC thereby eliminating the need to open the canister assuming large coarse media used. Let nature do nature. KISS

As far as I understand, @Paul B is also running a setup along these lines. The main appeal, as I understand it, is biodiversity: small organisms that would otherwise be sucked into a filter have a better chance of surviving.

Does it make sense to lean into a more old-school approach and experiment with an UG filter? Or should I take the opportunity to go in the opposite direction and upgrade to a sump-based system, which help keeping more demanding corals?
 
Last edited:
I’ve shared my macroalgae tank build here before. The setup was easy to build, no sump, just a canister filter. After about 1.5 years I’ve been very happy with how the tank has developed. However, now I’m preparing to move, and I’m considering using that moment to upgrade to a larger tank. That has me rethinking filtration.

Earlier, @GARRIGA suggested combining my existing canister filter with an undergravel filter, essentially using the canister to drive the undergravel system.

@GARRIGA:


As far as I understand, @Paul B is also running a setup along these lines. The main appeal, as I understand it, is biodiversity: small organisms that would otherwise be sucked into a filter have a better chance of surviving.

Does it make sense to lean into a more old-school approach and experiment with an UG filter? Or should I take the opportunity to go in the opposite direction and upgrade to a sump-based system, which help keeping more demanding corals?
My 75G display with two canister filters, one reverse flow UG filter using 2” of aroggonite substrate and one 30G cryptic refugium using live rock and spongy mud crawling with worms.
has operated for 25 years.

I will quibble with your main advantage of the reverse flow being “not being sucked into a filter have a better chance of survival”. In my experience, providing an oxygenated substrate is an advantage that favors multiple, diverse nutrient pathways that move carbon up the microbial food web. With respect to an external sump used as a refugium, the return pump would do the same thing. I see this as an advantage: it makes it easier for fish to capture disoriented microorganisms.
 
My 75G display with two canister filters, one reverse flow UG filter using 2” of aroggonite substrate and one 30G cryptic refugium using live rock and spongy mud crawling with worms.
has operated for 25 years.

Wow! Is it possible to show how it looks? Is this the kind of filtration you would recommend? I think I might give it a try..
 
Hi kolius, not trying to steer you away from Patrick's set up as he is an excellent, experienced reef keeper of macroalgae, and my friend. But should you decide to stay with what you have been successfully doing I will show you my 75g macro/softie dominated aquarium, which is like your current tank.
20260130_133350.jpg
 
I will show you my 75g macro/softie dominated aquarium

Wow, thanks for sharing! Fantastic! looks absolutely gorgeous, following your thread
but I can’t see any macroalgae in your tank?

I really enjoy using a canister filter. The last time I opened mine, it was full of different life forms—I think I even saw sponges in there.

That said, I’ve also had a disaster. I once had to turn it off for a full day due to leak (it's an old fluval 307), and when I opened it, everything inside was dead due to lack of oxygen. It was terrible. As soon as the flow stop (e.g. blackout?), it's the end!

Now I’m thinking about the best way to move my canister filter to a new apartment – I’ll probably put an air stone inside during the move.
 
Wow, thanks for sharing! Fantastic! looks absolutely gorgeous, following your thread
but I can’t see any macroalgae in your tank?

I really enjoy using a canister filter. The last time I opened mine, it was full of different life forms—I think I even saw sponges in there.

That said, I’ve also had a disaster. I once had to turn it off for a full day due to leak (it's an old fluval 307), and when I opened it, everything inside was dead due to lack of oxygen. It was terrible. As soon as the flow stop (e.g. blackout?), it's the end!

Now I’m thinking about the best way to move my canister filter to a new apartment – I’ll probably put an air stone inside during the move.
My most flourishing macroalgae now is codium which I have a lot. I also have shaving brush, mermaids fan, halimeda opuntia, pom pom, a little dragons breath, and gracilaria hayi. I am having trouble getting all the other macros to take off since I transferred in Sept. I am also having a little trouble keeping my nutrients up.

When you move, take the baskets in your canister and put them in a bucket/s with rock from your tank. The added surface area should help aerated and keep the biolife viable. Your idea of an airstone should work too.
I know when I go out of town I figured that I would put the canister baskets in my tank where I have an auto backup aerator pump to protect against an outage. I would then just run the canister totally empty. I also am growing 2 small mangroves.
20251222_122039.jpg
20251114_124231.jpg
20251219_072750.jpg
20260130_133155.jpg
20251205_112954.jpg
 
Both of these systems are skimmerless, both have cryptic refugiums and reverse flow UG filter”: 120G on left is 5 years mature and 75G on the right is 25 years mature.

Wow! Is it possible to show how it looks? Is this the kind of filtration you would recommend? I think I might give it a try..

image.jpg image.jpg image.jpg
 
I’ve shared my macroalgae tank build here before. The setup was easy to build, no sump, just a canister filter. After about 1.5 years I’ve been very happy with how the tank has developed. However, now I’m preparing to move, and I’m considering using that moment to upgrade to a larger tank. That has me rethinking filtration.

Earlier, @GARRIGA suggested combining my existing canister filter with an undergravel filter, essentially using the canister to drive the undergravel system.

@GARRIGA:


As far as I understand, @Paul B is also running a setup along these lines. The main appeal, as I understand it, is biodiversity: small organisms that would otherwise be sucked into a filter have a better chance of surviving.

Does it make sense to lean into a more old-school approach and experiment with an UG filter? Or should I take the opportunity to go in the opposite direction and upgrade to a sump-based system, which help keeping more demanding corals?

I think it is well worth asking yourself what exactly you want either a regular or reverse undergravel filter to accomplish, and whether there is any evidence that either is a paarticularly useful idea in a typical reef tank.

I personally see no reason to want either one in most situations.
 
I think it is well worth asking yourself what exactly you want either a regular or reverse undergravel filter to accomplish, and whether there is any evidence that either is a paarticularly useful idea in a typical reef tank.

I personally see no reason to want either one in most situations.
Would you expound on this?

In using a reverse flow UG filter,
I do see an increased emphases on nutrient uptake by anabolic bacteria competing with coral nutrient uptake as well as algae nutrient uptake.
 
Would you expound on this?

In using a reverse flow UG filter,
I do see an increased emphases on nutrient uptake by anabolic bacteria competing with coral nutrient uptake as well as algae nutrient uptake.

OK, but before doing so, I'd ask what you believe that system does that is beneficial for an organism living in the world above the filter.
 
I run a 650 gal system with 300gal stock tank that is a regular undergravel filter. It's only a year + old and is performing way better than I ever thought and the maintenance is nothing. I overfeed a blend of homemade fish food/coral food and flake to about 50 fish including a few big eaters and only had to add a skimmer this week because I have been throwing a lot of food in and I can't order hermits for a few weeks due to the weather. I have a 150 and a 125 that I'm polishing up and they will both have UG filters in them. The other thing about UG filters they add a lot of buffer to the system so they are very stable once they age a bit. I might try a reverse on one of the tanks I'm setting up just to see how it compares side to side with a regular UG filter.
 
OK, but before doing so, I'd ask what you believe that system does that is beneficial for an organism living in the world above the filter.

Under gravel filters have been around a long time and their pros and cons are pretty well known.... subsea has posted a lot about what he thinks about his underground filter, here and in many other threads.

Personally, I'm more curious about the opinion you expressed because I have not heard you expound on it before... and of course you brought the point up making us all curious about it. 😎
 
OK, but before doing so, I'd ask what you believe that system does that is beneficial for an organism living in the world above the filter.
With respect to reverse flow, I know that supplying oxygen across all substrate supports multiple nutrient pathways for micro fauna & fana.
For 20 years, I operated a Jaubert Plenum which focused on reduction chemistry to convert nitrate to free nitrogen gas molecules. Five years ago, I converted Jaubert plenum to reverse flow.


@Randy Holmes-Farley
I operate reverse flow UG filter to promote diverse multiple nutrient pathways of micro fauna & fana thereby enhancing the diversity of the microbial loop which feeds diverse filter feeders: sponges, feather dusters, flame scallops, sea apples, tunicates, bryozones …
 
With respect to reverse flow, I know that supplying oxygen across all substrate supports multiple nutrient pathways for micro fauna & fana.
For 20 years, I operated a Jaubert Plenum which focused on reduction chemistry to convert nitrate to free nitrogen gas molecules. Five years ago, I converted Jaubert plenum to reverse flow.


@Randy Holmes-Farley
I operate reverse flow UG filter to promote diverse multiple nutrient pathways of micro fauna & fana thereby enhancing the diversity of the microbial loop which feeds diverse filter feeders: sponges, feather dusters, flame scallops, sea apples, tunicates, bryozones …

Of course, having things happen in a filter are all well and good, but if the goal is to have an organism elsewhere in the tank benefit (presumably that is the goal), the question is what exactly is in, or not in, the water that touches them. That is the only way they can benefit.

So, you are suggesting the reverse undergravel filter increases bacteria in the water? It's possible that its true. It is also possible it is not true. Do you have any evidence that it is true? Do you have any evidence that it happens to a greater degree than a normal undergravel filter, or even a simple sand bed? One can make the identical arguments for those, and if one is claimed to be better, some evidence of that claim would seem useful.

I'm not sure I buy the idea that a reverse undergravel filter supplies more diverse micro flora and fauna, since I think it more likely a stratified substrate could provide more diverese nutrient pathways than one that is mostly aerobic. But I could easily be convinced it supplies more sites for aerobic organisms to live, if that is the goal. But I'm just not sure that necessarily drives the health of an organism a foot away.
 
Under gravel filters have been around a long time and their pros and cons are pretty well known.... subsea has posted a lot about what he thinks about his underground filter, here and in many other threads.

Personally, I'm more curious about the opinion you expressed because I have not heard you expound on it before... and of course you brought the point up making us all curious about it. 😎

The claims about them, pro and con, have certainly been around a long time. Data is much more lacking, IMO. Have you see any data showing them to be beneficial?

FWIW, most posts I see about reverse undergravel filters are about why they are better than normal undergravel filters. Not, at least that I have seen, about why they are better than no undergravel filter at all.

I will add here an idea that I have been promoting in the past couple of years that is a potential detriment to both regular and reverse undergravel filters: excessive potential for nitrification. They are stealing ammonia from corals.

I think the hobby has long had an unhealthy obsession with promoting nitrifiers, which I consider the thieves of the reef community. That has been pushed by sellers of both bacteria, and supposed substrates for them.
I beleive we are better off not trying to optimize places for them to go, and are perhaps are not well served when we do it accidentally, such as in undergravel filters (unless the purpose is nitrification, in which case it is, IMO, an unforced error)..

Do I have data supporting that? Only weakly, from, say, the differences observed in dosing ammonia vs dosing nitrate. So I am certainly agreeing that it is my opinion that they are undesirable.

That is why i asked the OP what exactly he was wanting an undergravel filter to accomplish. If it is nitrification, then I think it's a mistake. Almost no reef tank needs more nitrification. If it is something else, then maybe its a fine plan if such filters do that something else.
 
The claims about them, pro and con, have certainly been around a long time. Data is much more lacking, IMO. Have you see any data showing them to be beneficial?

FWIW, most posts I see about reverse undergravel filters are about why they are better than normal undergravel filters. Not, at least that I have seen, about why they are better than no undergravel filter at all.

I will add here an idea that I have been promoting in the past couple of years that is a potential detriment to both regular and reverse undergravel filters: excessive potential for nitrification. They are stealing ammonia from corals.

I think the hobby has long had an unhealthy obsession with promoting nitrifiers, which I consider the thieves of the reef community. That has been pushed by sellers of both bacteria, and supposed substrates for them.
I beleive we are better off not trying to optimize places for them to go, and are perhaps are not well served when we do it accidentally, such as in undergravel filters (unless the purpose is nitrification, in which case it is, IMO, an unforced error)..

Do I have data supporting that? Only weakly, from, say, the differences observed in dosing ammonia vs dosing nitrate. So I am certainly agreeing that it is my opinion that they are undesirable.

That is why i asked the OP what exactly he was wanting an undergravel filter to accomplish. If it is nitrification, then I think it's a mistake. Almost no reef tank needs more nitrification. If it is something else, then maybe its a fine plan if such filters do that something else.
Randy,
I will respond to this post because it is at the heart of the discussion. I agree with your point about not needing more nitrification bacteria to steal ammonia away from coral. I dose ammonia.

When you asked me why I favored reverse flow undergravel filter, none of my answer focused on bacteria. I focused on micro fauna & micro fana moving carbon up the food chain feeding the microbial loop.
Of course, having things happen in a filter are all well and good, but if the goal is to have an organism elsewhere in the tank benefit (presumably that is the goal), the question is what exactly is in, or not in, the water that touches them. That is the only way they can benefit.

So, you are suggesting the reverse undergravel filter increases bacteria in the water? It's possible that its true. It is also possible it is not true. Do you have any evidence that it is true? Do you have any evidence that it happens to a greater degree than a normal undergravel filter, or even a simple sand bed? One can make the identical arguments for those, and if one is claimed to be better, some evidence of that claim would seem useful.

I'm not sure I buy the idea that a reverse undergravel filter supplies more diverse micro flora and fauna, since I think it more likely a stratified substrate could provide more diverese nutrient pathways than one that is mostly aerobic. But I could easily be convinced it supplies more sites for aerobic organisms to live, if that is the goal. But I'm just not sure that necessarily drives the health of an organism a foot away.
where to start:

“But I'm just not sure that necessarily drives the health of an organism a foot away.“

We put activated carbon & other resins in remote reactors and expect that to effect water parameters in display tank, thereby effecting tank performance.

“But I could easily be convinced it supplies more sites for aerobic organisms to live, if that is the goal.”

That is the goal. Diversity & density of micro fauna & fana.

“So, you are suggesting the reverse undergravel filter increases bacteria in the water.”

NO. I am saying there are higher trophic levels of carbon than bacteria. And because I don’t use a protein skimmer, I consider this an important feeding strategy for filter feeders, which is not limited to coral.
 
Last edited:
The claims about them, pro and con, have certainly been around a long time. Data is much more lacking, IMO. Have you see any data showing them to be beneficial?
Well, "beneficial" has to be described historically I guess....it meant that ammonia had a reliable (almost foolproof) way to be detoxified/oxidized and so we could have lots of nice fish (instead of just one or a few). UGF's were (are) very beneficial, as anyone who's run one knows first hand.

But to your point I don't remember if I've seen anyone quantify it. Maybe it depends what you really want to see.

If anyone, maybe Moe? He deals with them (UGF and rfUGF) in both books (mostly echoing our sentiments IMO), but on p.64 of the Third Edition, he states that he dealt "extensively with the form, function, and maintenance of undergravel filters" in the First Edition and Chapter 4 Appendix (p.114) is dedicated to UGF's in the Third Edition. Can you check out "Marine Aquarium Handbook: Beginner to Breeder" ThirdAny Edition to see if any of this addresses what you were wondering?

Interestingly for our tangent, Moe points out (with some citations) that biofiltration wasn't even a topic or was outright dismissed in aquariums/aquarium literature up to the 70's or so.

I will add here an idea that I have been promoting in the past couple of years that is a potential detriment to both regular and reverse undergravel filters: excessive potential for nitrification. They are stealing ammonia from corals.

I think the hobby has long had an unhealthy obsession with promoting nitrifiers, which I consider the thieves of the reef community. That has been pushed by sellers of both bacteria, and supposed substrates for them.
I beleive we are better off not trying to optimize places for them to go, and are perhaps are not well served when we do it accidentally, such as in undergravel filters (unless the purpose is nitrification, in which case it is, IMO, an unforced error)..

Do I have data supporting that? Only weakly, from, say, the differences observed in dosing ammonia vs dosing nitrate. So I am certainly agreeing that it is my opinion that they are undesirable
I think your idea dovetails with all the informal (but voluminous) data accrued on dino's in the nuisance algae forum. Tanks with excess filtration (eg carbon dosing, extra bio-media, et al) seem to be especially susceptible to dino outbreaks. Also: The more excess, the more severe the outbreak.

It has been my opinion from that thread and all the associated reading that dino's behave that way (ie blooming) under starvation/deprivation conditions...low P is crucial, but low N also serves as a trigger (among other factors, depending on the dino).

Starving the tank of ammonia may be a crucial aspect of that tipping point, or even the main cause...as you point out nitrate and ammonia are not equal N-sources to all critters.

Corals can seemingly make use of most forms of N pretty well and even seem to "make" some of their own via symbiosis. But not everything we want to grow in a reef tank is a coral, right? We want an ecosysstem.

Some rock/sand bed citizens (or maybe even most?) may require, or struggle less, when assimilating ammonia, since there's no oxygen to deal with unlike NO2 and NO3.

These may be of interest: Link. Link. Link. Link. Link.

More data would be needed to draw definitive conclusions, but IMO there is already a preponderance of evidence in favor of your idea about ammonia....(and the associated "obsession" with nitrification...and I think ammonia toxicity in general).
 
My most flourishing macroalgae now is codium which I have a lot. I also have shaving brush, mermaids fan, halimeda opuntia, pom pom, a little dragons breath, and gracilaria hayi. I am having trouble getting all the other macros to take off since I transferred in Sept. I am also having a little trouble keeping my nutrients up.

When you move, take the baskets in your canister and put them in a bucket/s with rock from your tank. The added surface area should help aerated and keep the biolife viable. Your idea of an airstone should work too.
I know when I go out of town I figured that I would put the canister baskets in my tank where I have an auto backup aerator pump to protect against an outage. I would then just run the canister totally empty. I also am growing 2 small mangroves.
20251222_122039.jpg
20251114_124231.jpg
20251219_072750.jpg
20260130_133155.jpg
20251205_112954.jpg
The seahorse cave paint is callin
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.8%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 24 36.4%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new