Helfrichi firefish dead, line spot dying, don't know why

  • Thread starter Thread starter BSej
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

BSej

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 3, 2024
Messages
307
Reaction score
57
Location
Chicago
What state or country do you live in
Illinois
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi all,

I came home today and found one of my three helfrichi firefish dead. 1 of the 3 would hide since I got it and the other 2 would behave aggressively towards it, a couple of them have fin damage (assuming from fighting). One of them has a black marking on its face (still alive) and I'm not sure what it is or if it's an issue. I tried to get a video of the dead fish before a shrimp took him away, but you can't really see anything in the video. His belly looks like it has a slit carved out, but doesn't penetrate. His gills were pretty open? kinda red inside but I could be making that up.

Also just today my line spot flasher wrasse is hiding and laying on the sand (never done this before). I imagine he will die soon as well. He does have this sort of larger, white gradient marking on his forehead. I'm not sure what that is either but it's been there for a bit and I don't know if it's harmful. Maybe lympho? It looks like a cluster of larger white spots.

If it was just the bullied firefish, and I did not see problems with the wrasse, I probably would shake it off. I sense something else is going on here.

The tank does have ich, and the fish typically have a few spots here and there, but it hasn't been an issue so far that I know of.

150 gal
Stock:
Sailfin tang
Blue damsel
Clown x 2
Yellow tang
3 x Helfrich’s firefish
Purple tang
Line Spot Flasher Wrasse
2 x Lyretail Anthias
African Midas blenny

Params:
Temp: 77-78F
Salinity: 34ppt
Nitrates: ~10-15ppm
Phosphates: near 0 (just ordered hannah checker because the seachem test is not helpful lol)

recent changes:
1. I switched to AFR instead of seachem fusion 1/2 (shouldn't affect the fish)
2. Started dosing NOPox, about 15mL daily for a couple weeks. I just hooked it up to the apex DOS as well (possible malfunction?). I hear NOPox can deplete the oxygen? I doubt it at this dosage, but stopped dosing just in case. I do run a skimmer.

Any help is appreciated!
 
Last edited:
Hi all,

I came home today and found one of my three helfrichi firefish dead. 1 of the 3 would hide since I got it and the other 2 would behave aggressively towards it, a couple of them have fin damage (assuming from fighting). One of them has a black marking on its face (still alive) and I'm not sure what it is or if it's an issue. I tried to get a video of the dead fish before a shrimp took him away, but you can't really see anything in the video. His belly looks like it has a slit carved out, but doesn't penetrate. His gills were pretty open? kinda red inside but I could be making that up.

Also just today my line spot flasher wrasse is hiding and laying on the sand (never done this before). I imagine he will die soon as well. He does have this sort of larger, white gradient marking on his forehead. I'm not sure what that is either but it's been there for a bit and I don't know if it's harmful.

If it was just the bullied firefish, and I did not see problems with the wrasse, I probably would shake it off. I sense something else is going on here.

The tank does have ich, and the fish typically have a few spots here and there, but it hasn't been an issue so far that I know of.

150 gal
Stock:
Sailfin tang
Blue damsel
Clown x 2
Yellow tang
3 x Helfrich’s firefish
Purple tang
Line Spot Flasher Wrasse
2 x Lyretail Anthias
African Midas blenny

Params:
Temp: 77-78F
Salinity: 34ppt
Nitrates: ~10-15ppm
Phosphates: near 0 (just ordered hannah checker because the seachem test is not helpful lol)

recent changes:
1. I switched to AFR instead of seachem fusion 1/2 (shouldn't affect the fish)
2. Started dosing NOPox, about 15mL daily for a couple weeks. I just hooked it up to the apex DOS as well (possible malfunction?). I hear NOPox can deplete the oxygen? I doubt it at this dosage, but stopped dosing just in case. I do run a skimmer.

Any help is appreciated!
NoPox can pose an issue but as of now, will assume not unless this onset occured right after dosing. You have three different fish that can pose a threat as far as aggression (blenny, damsels and clowns) and yes, a trio of firefish may invite fighting. Ich will be the other issue and you are likely looking at 1-2 yanks to begin treatment as it will affect their gills, and overall behavior, leading to death.
Recommended treatment is coppersafe as Hypo will have impact on some of the smaller fish. Run coppersafe at 2.15 - 2.25ppm and monitor this level with a Hanna Brand Copper test kit. Add aeration with air atone during treatment and leave the display tank fishless (FALLOW) for 6-8 weeks to assure the existing parasites go through their life cycle without a host fish and die off and with occupants exposed
A quarantine tank can be as simple as a tank from a second hand store or a starter kit from Walmart which most of the needed essentials.
 
NoPox can pose an issue but as of now, will assume not unless this onset occured right after dosing. You have three different fish that can pose a threat as far as aggression (blenny, damsels and clowns) and yes, a trio of firefish may invite fighting. Ich will be the other issue and you are likely looking at 1-2 yanks to begin treatment as it will affect their gills, and overall behavior, leading to death.
Recommended treatment is coppersafe as Hypo will have impact on some of the smaller fish. Run coppersafe at 2.15 - 2.25ppm and monitor this level with a Hanna Brand Copper test kit. Add aeration with air atone during treatment and leave the display tank fishless (FALLOW) for 6-8 weeks to assure the existing parasites go through their life cycle without a host fish and die off and with occupants exposed
A quarantine tank can be as simple as a tank from a second hand store or a starter kit from Walmart which most of the needed essentials.
Thank you for your reply.
I started NOPOx a few weeks ago, but I set up the Apex DOS just yesterday.

I've done hypo before (removed corals) and lost most of my coral and most of my fish, only for ich to return. I followed the guide on this site and did everything as best I could. I also quarantined all my new fish following the guide here. Who knows if I never rid of it with hypo or if I introduced it again some other way. I can't go through that process again. Removing the fish is also not an option.

The blenny is very peaceful, the damsel minds his own business for the most part, and the clowns only bother each other from time to time, same with the anthias, and tangs. The firefish fought the most of all my fish.

If removal of the fish was possible, and I had a big enough tank for quarantine, I would.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your reply.
I started NOPOx a few weeks ago, but I set up the Apex DOS just yesterday.

I've done hypo before (removed corals) and lost most of my coral and most of my fish, only for ich to return. I followed the guide on this site and did everything as best I could. I also quarantined all my new fish following the guide here. Who knows if I never rid of it with hypo or if I introduced it again some other way. I can't go through that process again. Removing the fish is also not an option.

The blenny is very peaceful, the damsel minds his own business for the most part, and the clowns only bother each other from time to time, same with the anthias, and tangs. The firefish fought the most of all my fish.

If removal of the fish was possible, and I had a big enough tank for quarantine, I would.
Then you have no other choice assuming its ich - and I don't know that it is - but to re-do hyposalinity. Have you put anything else new into the tank that could have brought something besides Ich? - I don't hear you talking about any spots on the fish that you're worried about correct. This suggests your helfrichi died of 'fighting'/aggression - Can you send pictures of the fish you think have problems (the black spot and the wrasse?)
 
Then you have no other choice assuming its ich - and I don't know that it is - but to re-do hyposalinity. Have you put anything else new into the tank that could have brought something besides Ich? - I don't hear you talking about any spots on the fish that you're worried about correct. This suggests your helfrichi died of 'fighting'/aggression - Can you send pictures of the fish you think have problems (the black spot and the wrasse?)
Here are some videos. If it's hard to see I can take some in white light this week. Ignore the shrimp eating the now dead helfrichi :grimacing-face:.
(dead helfrichi)
(wrasse white blotch on head)
(helfrichi w black patch on face)

There aren't any spots that I'm worried about.

I can't re-do hyposalinity either, I don't have a tank to fit all the corals in. The tank I did it in previously was thrown away, and most of them died in there anyways.
 
Here are some videos. If it's hard to see I can take some in white light this week. Ignore the shrimp eating the now dead helfrichi :grimacing-face:.
(dead helfrichi)
(wrasse white blotch on head)
(helfrichi w black patch on face)

There aren't any spots that I'm worried about.

I can't re-do hyposalinity either, I don't have a tank to fit all the corals in. The tank I did it in previously was thrown away, and most of them died in there anyways.

Then - I guess since you cant treat the ich - you could try good feeding, and UV?
 
Then - I guess since you cant treat the ich - you could try good feeding, and UV?
That's what I'm doing now. I feed several times per day, including two nori clips around the clock, and they all eat aggressively.
 
How old is this tank? A full tank shot can also be helpful.


This video is a couple weeks old.

13 months since I converted to reef tank from fish only (I consider this the start because it was under different *management* before). I had the first tank crash with the hypo situation a couple months in. Been going pretty well *more or less because this hobby is crazy* since then.
 


13 months since I converted to reef tank from fish only (I consider this the start because it was under different *management* before). I had the first tank crash with the hypo situation a couple months in. Been going pretty well *more or less because this hobby is crazy* since then.

Why are you trying to keep a group of fire fish? They don't do well in groups.
 
Why are you trying to keep a group of fire fish? They don't do well in groups.
Good question. Didn't know that at the time :/

You can see the one is missing in the video. He used to hide all the time. He started coming out / more active recently so I thought that was a good thing.
 
Fair, aggression is the most likely contributor.
Ok. I am a bit surprised that this can kill a fish without any visible damage? Especially when it was out a lot and eating all the time and suddenly dropped dead.
 
Ok. I am a bit surprised that this can kill a fish without any visible damage? Especially when it was out a lot and eating all the time and suddenly dropped dead.
Sometimes they just disappear, and you never see them again.
 
Sometimes they just disappear, and you never see them again.
I actually had 4 and this is what happened to #1 immediately after they entered the tank after full QT. I suspect he could've entered the overflow or something though not sure.
 
That's what I'm doing now. I feed several times per day, including two nori clips around the clock, and they all eat aggressively.
Then I guess you can try a UV sterilizer. Again - assuming this is ich - which I'm not sure it is - I'm tending to agree with the rest that it's aggression. My recommendations were based on the fact that you wanted options to treat ich. If you were seeing spots that would be another issue on the other sick fish.
 
Then I guess you can try a UV sterilizer. Again - assuming this is ich - which I'm not sure it is - I'm tending to agree with the rest that it's aggression. My recommendations were based on the fact that you wanted options to treat ich. If you were seeing spots that would be another issue on the other sick fish.
He does have some spots on his head (not ich). I don't know what it is. It's like a small cluster of larger white spots.
 
Good question. Didn't know that at the time :/

You can see the one is missing in the video. He used to hide all the time. He started coming out / more active recently so I thought that was a good thing.

That was my take on this - the dying firefish has been attacked by something, possibly another firefish, but your tank has a number of fish that could do this. The second firefish looks a bit "tattered", I couldn't tell if that was from video pixelation though.

I just don't know about compatibility of this species because I've always only had one per tank.....
 
That was my take on this - the dying firefish has been attacked by something, possibly another firefish, but your tank has a number of fish that could do this. The second firefish looks a bit "tattered", I couldn't tell if that was from video pixelation though.

I just don't know about compatibility of this species because I've always only had one per tank.....
He is tattered. I’ve only seen the fire fish nip at each other and no other fish nip at them. I guess I’m slightly relieved that it’s likely due to aggression. Won’t make that stocking mistake again!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 28.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new