Help! Duncan getting nibbled constantly by clown

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jeph
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Jeph

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 30, 2024
Messages
4
Reaction score
2
Location
Melbourne
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi there, not sure if this is the correct part of the forum to ask for help - I'm having an issue where the resident female clown (ocellaris) is constantly harassing my Duncan coral.

The Ducan has been in our mixed reef 42gal (160L) tank for almost 6 months now, and has been spot-fed with a squirt of artemia daily where possible. It is about 5 inches tall and has put out a few new heads and growing healthy. We have a mated pair of Ocellaris clowns who have up until two weeks ago, had zero interest in the Duncan coral, even during feeding time. During feeding time, the fish are fed pellets first (both clowns have a healthy appetite and consume most of it), then the fish are distract-fed with some artemia/mysis, while the Duncan & Torch corals are spot fed the same.

The behaviour of the female clown change two weeks ago, when she suddenly decided to start pecking at the Duncan. Initially this was for artemia crumbs hanging on the tentacle tips after spot feeding, but now she is constantly inspecting the Duncan outside of feeding time. She frequently nibbles the tentacles, causing them to appear squished or "chewed on" (like when someone chews the edge of a pen cap??) The Duncan so far hasn't retraced any of its heads, but the tentacles are visibly stubbier and less showy. I'm worried about the Duncan coral in the long-run.

She has so far managed to steal artemia directly from the Duncan's mouths before, so nowadays I have to hover around the Duncan after spot feeding, and only walk away after the Duncan has "swallowed" their food and opened up again. Aside from the nibbling, she has not tried to rest/nestle on the Duncan. (The torch is relatively new and has been ignored so far)

Notably her male mate does not do this, but would just chill out near her while she has her go at the Duncan.

View attachment 3804936
(photo of Duncan tentacle in her mouth - sorry for the resolution! She stops doing this and acts like an angel when I get close to the tank)

Also tonight was the first time I've seen her try to "mouth"/bite one of the appendages from the Sinularia (located at the other end of the tank)?? She was literally stuck there with the sinularia in her mouth (like a dog with a chew toy), and I had to use a turkey baster to disturb her into dropping the Sinularia. The Sinularia has been in the tank for about as long as she is: she likes swimming through it but has never tried to physically put it in her mouth.

View attachment 3804939
(photo of her "mouthing" the sinularia and looking very ridiculous)

Has anyone had similar experiences with a very "nibblely/bitey" Ocellaris clown? Is she trying to host?? Will this behaviour evolve into where she's eating/destroying the corals that she chooses? Will the Duncan (& sinularia) survive? What is the recommended action going forward? All and any advice is greatly welcomed :loudly-crying-face:

image0 (3).jpeg image4.jpeg
 
This is highly unusual for clowns but it sounds like she’s developed a taste for corals. The fact that she’s going after multiple different types of corals is particularly concerning.
 
i've had clowns who end up pairing with torches - which does not end well for the torch. Also with Goni's - but they seem to be able to take the constant clown interactions. Never heard of a clown nibbling on corals.
 
My clowns beat up their new Duncan roommate up within 2 weeks.
2 Heads down, 2 still up but barely coming out :crying-face:
Maybe if it was bigger, it could have been a host...
Here's before and after.
20240918_115404.jpg
20241001_144234.jpg
 
Just found this thread while searching for this same issue so figured I'd vent...

My clownfish just started biting off my Duncan's tentacles about 5 days ago.
Sucks because the Duncan was pretty much my favorite coral and doesn't look likely to recover (to me).

I've had the clown since she was juvenile for 3.5+ years (from previous tank).
I've had the Duncan for just about 1 year and it had grown nicely and gone from 1 head to 6 in that time.

My initial theory was that my clown had gotten aggressive towards my tailspot blenny over the last year or so and the blenny likes to hang out under the Duncan so wondered if the clown was just trying to clear away the cover.
 
A little update... For the past few months both clowns decided to host on the duncan: lots of perching and brushing against the duncan heads. The duncan survived but I won't say it was thriving, tentacles either looked nibbled on, or were stubby-looking and retracted. I decided to buy 2 more duncan frags, with the plan to help "diffuse" the hosting behaviour across more duncan heads. It seemed like it helped and the clowns were overjoyed with their larger duncan nest.

Flash forward to this early week, the female clown suddenly went on an aggressive rampage and started harassing the other tank mates - a court jester goby and a firefish - completely stressing them out (she usually ignores the jester while the firefish intentionally avoids the clowns' territory). She then went berserk on the larger duncan, ripping the tentacles off (while I was monitoring her aggression). I caught her and placed her in a time-out breeder box along with the male, who had begun copying her aggression. Sadly she took out her boyfriend overnight (!!), and now I don't know if I can trust her murderous self around other fish for the time being. On the other hand the duncan corals have made a great recovery and I have never seen it look better.

It's disheartening when it looked like it was working and then fell apart. I think I'll take a break from clowns and just focus on corals for now.

the duncan and clowns dec 24
878cf61e-7890-4cea-8a4a-365eddafab1b.jpg

The duncans this week jan 25 (repositioned after clowns went to jail). A cardinal has moved into the corner but just enjoys chilling out near the duncans
cb73bcf7-f058-4e33-900d-efdcae70e872.jpg
 
Clowns bite anemone tentacles helps build resistance to sting. Highly suspect your clowns is going to host the Duncan.
 
Completely normal behaviors. Clowns nibble and mouth their host Anemones, it's what they do. Unfortunately some mature female Clowns will also kill anything that ventures into her territory. It's what they do, nature of the beast.
If a Clown decides it's going to reside in a specific coral you can try moving that coral, acquiring another coral, acquire the appropriate Anemone for that specific Clown type.
The larger the system the easier to defuse and distract.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

ARE YOU READY TO CONFESS TO CRAZIEST, DUMBEST, FUNNIEST THING YOU’VE EVER DONE IN REEFING?

  • Yeah, I'll confess! (Share your story in the comments!)

    Votes: 44 53.0%
  • Nah, I'll keep mine a secret...(Don't be like that, share with the class!)

    Votes: 39 47.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new