Herbie Style overflow

PSCoral

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 16, 2024
Messages
35
Reaction score
9
Location
North America
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is a dry fit as I wanted to get some feedback as to whether or not you all would think this would be fine for my overflow and wouldn’t cause any problems down the line. I had to redo my plumbing as my other design was not able to post a full siphon. Ill post pictures of the last design which all the pipes are blue and what I have now in white pvc pipe. Thank you for your time in advance !

IMG_2346.jpeg IMG_2347.jpeg IMG_2345.jpeg
 
no I used a ball valve as I’ve heard people have had success with it , also no I just used the sump to relocate some of the water from the tank when I drained it earlier as my jugs were all full
 
Ball valves may work ok-ish but they are not designed to get the very small adjustments you really need. Even with a gate valve on a herbie style you will need to adjust occasionally to keep the emergency drain clear. Organic matter/bacteria will build up in the pipes and valve slowing the flow. This doesnt seem to happen as frequently in a beananimal set up using 3 drains the open drain takes up the "extra" flow without having to adjust the gate valve on the siphon drain. I completely open the gate valve once every 2 months during maintenance to help clear it out. If I dont I notice the emergency drain starts to get a trickle in it.
 
Ball valves may work ok-ish but they are not designed to get the very small adjustments you really need. Even with a gate valve on a herbie style you will need to adjust occasionally to keep the emergency drain clear. Organic matter/bacteria will build up in the pipes and valve slowing the flow. This doesnt seem to happen as frequently in a beananimal set up using 3 drains the open drain takes up the "extra" flow without having to adjust the gate valve on the siphon drain. I completely open the gate valve once every 2 months during maintenance to help clear it out. If I dont I notice the emergency drain starts to get a trickle in it.
Honestly I’m kinda regretting not just getting the larger overflow box to go with the bean animal style. But I will definitely keep that in mind and set up a schedule when I start to notice a pattern in reduced efficiency of the overflow. But overall do you think that the new design would work in theory at least or are there any adjustments I should make ?
 
Honestly I’m kinda regretting not just getting the larger overflow box to go with the bean animal style. But I will definitely keep that in mind and set up a schedule when I start to notice a pattern in reduced efficiency of the overflow. But overall do you think that the new design would work in theory at least or are there any adjustments I should make ?
No looks like it will work to me. I have had these setups for years and in different configurations. I was told having the gate valve closer to the overflow box is optimal but I didnt notice a difference running it just below the overflow or in my basement 16' below the tank. I think for amount of water in the pipes its better to have the valve closer to the tank but, it still worked both ways for me.
 
No looks like it will work to me. I have had these setups for years and in different configurations. I was told having the gate valve closer to the overflow box is optimal but I didnt notice a difference running it just below the overflow or in my basement 16' below the tank. I think for amount of water in the pipes its better to have the valve closer to the tank but, it still worked both ways for me.
Sweet sweet , I appreciate it
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new