Hewbie is swimming upside down!

Fish excrete ammonia as a waste, especially from the gills. The amount of ammonia is at least partially based on fish mass. Even a fish that is not eating will produce ammonia. Porcupines are really massive fish for their length, so comparing a 6" porcupine to a 6" tang, the porc is going to be 3x as massive, with a corresponding higher ammonia output (I got this data from my fish mass data set).

This ammonia output is more or less continuous. In a small un-cycled tank, it is very common to see ammonia build at a rate of 1 ppm per day. If you do a 50% water change on such a tank, the next day the ammonia will be at 1.5 ppm (you diluted the first day's ammonia by 50%, but then in the next 24 hours, another 1 ppm of ammonia was excreted by the fish). If you do a second 50% water change, the ammonia will be 1.75 ppm, and so on. Even if you change 100% of the water daily, the ammonia will stay at 1 ppm

Hewbie is very massive, your ammonia build-up could be even faster.

"Cycled tank water" doesn't help - the beneficial ammonia removing bacteria lives on solid surfaces, not much in the water itself.
Thank you! This explains it so much better.
 
Toxic Ammonia Levels will vary significantly as Ph fluctuates. A good Test Kit will usually have a chart that you can calculate Toxic Ammonia based on Ph level and Total Ammonia. Most all Kits read Total Ammonia. I use a Red Sea Kit. The Seachem badges are useful but once used if they dry out they are usually done. With a 12" Puffer if you aren't reading Ammonia in a QT Tank something is wrong.
As I see it you have 2 issues that need to be addressed. How to keep the Ammonia levels in check in a QT Tank with such a large fish.
And more important, this odd behavior and sporadic eating starting in your DT so it sounds like you Biofilter is not up to the Task.
 
And just a note on the topic of Prime as it too blindsided me when I first heard about the controversy here on R2R: Prime states that it binds ammonia into a non-toxic form for a number of hours. There is a growing consensus amongst professional scientists that this just isn't the case, and that whatever Prime does do is ultimately unhelpful one way or the other for the purpose of rendering the water safer for fish. The problem is, and the reason why it continues to persist as a thing so many of us have, is that it also doesn't hurt. So in times like these, you just do it anyway "just in case".

My only advice would be: Don't rely on Prime alone.
I used prime for years but only to neutralize chlorine when adding tap water to freshwater tanks. Personally I think that's the only thing its good for.
 
Toxic Ammonia Levels will vary significantly as Ph fluctuates. A good Test Kit will usually have a chart that you can calculate Toxic Ammonia based on Ph level and Total Ammonia. Most all Kits read Total Ammonia. I use a Red Sea Kit. The Seachem badges are useful but once used if they dry out they are usually done. With a 12" Puffer if you aren't reading Ammonia in a QT Tank something is wrong.
As I see it you have 2 issues that need to be addressed. How to keep the Ammonia levels in check in a QT Tank with such a large fish.
And more important, this odd behavior and sporadic eating starting in your DT so it sounds like you Biofilter is not up to the Task.
Actually it is fine in the main display it isn’t a water quality issue that was Hewbie is having is some kind of an internal infection per the vet team. My big concern now is the ammonia level and keeping it down for the duration of his quarantine before he goes back into the display.
 
I am so glad Hewbie is doing better than he was at the beginning of this thread. I was so scared for the little fella my stomach was churning the whole read. I love Hewbie and I hope he gets better so he can go back to running his kingdom with the other fishies soon!🐡🫶
 
I can confirm ammonia can climb super fast. When I had a sick fish with little to no biofilter, it was climbing at least by 1 ppm a day, and that was a fairly small fish. I had to do two 50-60% water changes (usually 6-8h apart) almost every day to keep up, and even then I was barely able to keep up. I also second Hanna ammonia checker, it's a bit of a pain since it uses 3 reagents, but it has been always very accurate and on point with the badge.
 
Hewbie is graduating today! I made the calculated effort to get him out of quarantine today and get him into the display! He is less stressed and not floating upside down! Hewbie is graduating!🥺
IMG_2576.jpeg
 
Last edited:
He hasn’t been this excited about food in a few weeks so this makes me extremely happy!🤩🐡 His diet will now be mainly crabs followed by off days and shrimp.
 
Fish excrete ammonia as a waste, especially from the gills. The amount of ammonia is at least partially based on fish mass. Even a fish that is not eating will produce ammonia. Porcupines are really massive fish for their length, so comparing a 6" porcupine to a 6" tang, the porc is going to be 3x as massive, with a corresponding higher ammonia output (I got this data from my fish mass data set).

This ammonia output is more or less continuous. In a small un-cycled tank, it is very common to see ammonia build at a rate of 1 ppm per day. If you do a 50% water change on such a tank, the next day the ammonia will be at 1.5 ppm (you diluted the first day's ammonia by 50%, but then in the next 24 hours, another 1 ppm of ammonia was excreted by the fish). If you do a second 50% water change, the ammonia will be 1.75 ppm, and so on. Even if you change 100% of the water daily, the ammonia will stay at 1 ppm

Hewbie is very massive, your ammonia build-up could be even faster.

"Cycled tank water" doesn't help - the beneficial ammonia removing bacteria lives on solid surfaces, not much in the water itself.
Hewbie is back home! Thank you for all your advice and thorough explanations. The tub was really starting to stress him out. He was bored, in bad water, and in a dark tub. He seriously got so depressed! I would too if someone stuck in my a tiny dark closet and couldn’t get out. This such a happy boy again! I missed this. He did too. Not only did his color come back immediately he was doing zoomies around the tank and fins were wagging.
IMG_2597.jpeg
IMG_2592.jpeg
 
I didn't realize how cool puffer fish are. He is definitely a super cool fish; look how happy he looks! What an amazing and strong fish. Well done hewbie.
 
I didn't realize how cool puffer fish are. He is definitely a super cool fish; look how happy he looks! What an amazing and strong fish. Well done hewbie.
They definitely are! They are like saltwater puppy dogs. Not a lot of people understand this.
 
And Hewbie is still floating around upside down! He is a lot better than before and correcting himself! I don’t understand why this keeps happening!😭
 
You need to have a Hanna checker on hand. The Hanna checker, and the seachem badges work well for me. They are in sync all the time. I do not trust anything else.

As much as many want to post about the badges not working they are not far off. One way to test to make sure it still works properly is get a spray bottle. Then spray down the badge till it turns bright white/yellow as when new. If it does not time to replace it. Something ruined it. And it does not take much to ruin them. But if it turns the light color as if new, blow on the badge yourself. You should see is change real quick to darker colors. Then spray it again and see if it’s back to normal.

I’m working on a video on QT tanks and what to me is a newer method of QT. The QT systems can really work if what I have come up with is used. It’s going to be a six part video, and I’m just now compiling it together.

One of my tanks actually had a Super tiny mandarin in it, with copper power at 2.35ppm. And he is gaining weight because the tank is loaded with pods. In the past two years I have refined the system to where it’s insane how well it works.

But over all try to get a hannna check and along side the seachem badge you will see how accurate and in the know you end up being.

Rooting for Hewbie!
Pods survive 2.35 ppm Cu?!?! Who knew?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 25.0%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.7%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 42 40.4%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 25 24.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new