Hewbie is swimming upside down!

I can’t see well on my phone - Hewbie is still floating upside down? Is there a point, or area in the abdomen that is above the water line?

Side note - I may have missed it, but what is the ammonia level in the tub, and what method are you using to test it?
No. Tail is up completely parallel and he is stares at me/his eyes are still actively looking around the room. I flip him back and he goes back to swimming. Ammonia per my Fritz test kit is 0, slight nitrites (saltwater not as big of a deal), 10 nitrates. Phosphate I haven’t tested. However, my Seachem shows slightly darker than alert. I have been doing water changes, added an established rock, bottled bacteria, and the water is oxygenated very well. The system is trying to stabilize is what I see. I have two filters running on this. This gets worse after he eats. I have been feeding him way less and every few days. He is not as interested in food and I only have him a tiny amount. But I still want him to eat something. The vet recommended feeding him less. But my main concern is he got better. Why is he now doing this again? I could take him back to the vet which I don’t want to and hopefully avoid this. The vet wants to avoid this as well. I was told to extend the prescription metro. The next step I think if I took him back to the vet would be a CT scan and trying new meds which I hopefully don’t have to. Considering his massive size he is a very hardy fish. Side note…I know one measures free and the other measures total.
 
It doesn't sound like a Water Quality problem. Eating sporadically may not be that much of a problem. Is he really expending that much energy in a small, confined tank. If it was a Tang, eating irregularly would be more of a concern.
Also, this is a question for Jay. Could O2 supersaturation and microbubbles cause trouble with puffers ingesting air?
 
It doesn't sound like a Water Quality problem. Eating sporadically may not be that much of a problem. Is he really expending that much energy in a small, confined tank. If it was a Tang, eating irregularly would be more of a concern.
Also, this is a question for Jay. Could O2 supersaturation and microbubbles cause trouble with puffers ingesting air?
I think the answer may be yes. But I am talking with the vet. Hewbie is basically doing this and can’t expel the air if he swallows any. He is more interested in his environment so his mouth is sticking up out of the water. He is bored!:(
 
I can’t see well on my phone - Hewbie is still floating upside down? Is there a point, or area in the abdomen that is above the water line?

Side note - I may have missed it, but what is the ammonia level in the tub, and what method are you using to test it?
Another new development he has been correcting himself and goes back and swims in around. Is it possible that he is enjoying spinning around and being upside down in the bin? I ask this because now the few times my family members have flipped him over he saw them and basically reoriented himself a few times and said, “I’m fine don’t touch me!”😂😂😂😂 I did it 3 times and he swam around like normal. I was just told now the few times someone walked into the room he flipped himself over immediately. Please let me know your thoughts.
 
Another new development he has been correcting himself and goes back and swims in around. Is it possible that he is enjoying spinning around and being upside down in the bin? I ask this because now the few times my family members have flipped him over he saw them and basically reoriented himself a few times and said, “I’m fine don’t touch me!”😂😂😂😂 I did it 3 times and he swam around like normal. I was just told now the few times someone walked into the room he flipped himself over immediately. Please let me know your thoughts.

That’s not normal behavior. It may be that it is just easier for the fish to float upside down, so it doesn’t have to struggle to stay upright.

Did you see my note about the ammonia level?
 
That’s not normal behavior. It may be that it is just easier for the fish to float upside down, so it doesn’t have to struggle to stay upright.

Did you see my note about the ammonia level?
0 on a Fritz test but slightly elevated with the Seachem badge with the light blue/greenish color at the first alert level. However, I know one measures total and the other measures free.
 
0 on a Fritz test but slightly elevated with the Seachem badge with the light blue/greenish color at the first alert level. However, I know one measures total and the other measures free.

Can you have a LFS test it? I’m concerned because the Seachem badge should read lower than the Fritz test - it would be nice to have a third test to point you in the right direction.
 
That’s not normal behavior. It may be that it is just easier for the fish to float upside down, so it doesn’t have to struggle to stay upright.

Did you see my note about the ammonia level?
OMG! This is why. Thanks Jay. I am doing a 1-3 gallon water change with my display tank water for the next few hours and then adding more live rock. To be fair I knew it was creeping up and this confirmed my suspicions. Now I need to do daily water changes. I was doing every other day give or take.
IMG_2557.jpeg
 
Last edited:
He is so much happier and looks better. I am going to watch watch the water like a hawk now and have bought new Salifert test kits. This fish creates so much waste! This is all from one week. I cleaned out the filters in the tank and he is not gasping or rolling around.
IMG_2558.jpeg
IMG_2560.jpeg
 
You need to have a Hanna checker on hand. The Hanna checker, and the seachem badges work well for me. They are in sync all the time. I do not trust anything else.

As much as many want to post about the badges not working they are not far off. One way to test to make sure it still works properly is get a spray bottle. Then spray down the badge till it turns bright white/yellow as when new. If it does not time to replace it. Something ruined it. And it does not take much to ruin them. But if it turns the light color as if new, blow on the badge yourself. You should see is change real quick to darker colors. Then spray it again and see if it’s back to normal.

I’m working on a video on QT tanks and what to me is a newer method of QT. The QT systems can really work if what I have come up with is used. It’s going to be a six part video, and I’m just now compiling it together.

One of my tanks actually had a Super tiny mandarin in it, with copper power at 2.35ppm. And he is gaining weight because the tank is loaded with pods. In the past two years I have refined the system to where it’s insane how well it works.

But over all try to get a hannna check and along side the seachem badge you will see how accurate and in the know you end up being.

Rooting for Hewbie!
 
He is so much happier and looks better. I am going to watch watch the water like a hawk now and have bought new Salifert test kits. This fish creates so much waste! This is all from one week. I cleaned out the filters in the tank and he is not gasping or rolling around.
IMG_2558.jpeg
IMG_2560.jpeg


Yes at the size of fish he is, the amount of bacteria needed along side food and waste is quite substantial to keep ammonia down. And it takes quite some time for bacteria it catch on in a QT tank. Especially if bacteria media is not present, or smaller amounts.
 
Last edited:
OMG! This is why. Thanks Jay. I am doing a 1-3 gallon water change with my display tank water for the next few hours and then adding more live rock. To be fair I knew it was creeping up and this confirmed my suspicions. Now I need to do daily water changes. I was doing every other day give or take.
IMG_2557.jpeg

That is obviously a total ammonia reading, but it is REALLY high. Your pH is a bit low also, and that helps keep more of the ammonia in a less toxic form. Here is the problem - if you do a series of small water changes, the ammonia level is going to continue to climb, but so will the pH. That will make the ammonia more toxic. In that case, doing water changes can actually hurt the fish more in the long run.

I wouldn't use Prime to control ammonia - there is a LOT of controversy about how well that product actually works. I would use Amquel and large water changes. A better option would be to move the fish into a tank with an operating bio filter, or move portions of bio media into the filter in this tank.
 
That is obviously a total ammonia reading, but it is REALLY high. Your pH is a bit low also, and that helps keep more of the ammonia in a less toxic form. Here is the problem - if you do a series of small water changes, the ammonia level is going to continue to climb, but so will the pH. That will make the ammonia more toxic. In that case, doing water changes can actually hurt the fish more in the long run.

I wouldn't use Prime to control ammonia - there is a LOT of controversy about how well that product actually works. I would use Amquel and large water changes. A better option would be to move the fish into a tank with an operating bio filter, or move portions of bio media into the filter in this tank.
Sorry Jay pardon my ignorance and confusion. But as explained by the fish store and a marine biologist friend this was recommended. This doesn’t make any sense to me. Why would ammonia climb? You are diluting it and ultimate compensating “cycled” tank water and prime is aiding but not solving it. The goal is to get it as low as possible quickly without shocking the fish and moving him I will not be doing. I can tell you…ammonia did drop overnight and that he seems a lot better and is not puffed or gasping at the surface. My plan is to continue water changes but not as much now since I did get it lower. It is also not being done with fresh saltwater but rather display water. But that being said I am also awaiting further instructions from the vet. But once it does drop I am then going to add more live rock as if I add it now it will die.
 
Last edited:
Getting advice from multiple different people isn't ideal; it's hard to make decisions with too many people saying different things. You should do what you feel is best, and if you need help and advice, just stick to one person whom you feel is best to help you.
 
Getting advice from multiple different people isn't ideal; it's hard to make decisions with too many people saying different things. You should do what you feel is best, and if you need help and advice, just stick to one person whom you feel is best to help you.
I agree it makes it harder. I don’t love to do this but sometimes it happens.
 
Sorry Jay pardon my ignorance and confusion. But as explained by the fish store and a marine biologist friend this was recommended. This doesn’t make any sense to me. Why would ammonia climb? You are diluting it and ultimate compensating “cycled” tank water and prime is aiding but not solving it. The goal is to get it as low as possible quickly without shocking the fish and moving him I will not be doing. I can tell you…ammonia did drop overnight and that he seems a lot better and is not puffed or gasping at the surface. My plan is to continue water changes but not as much now since I did get it lower. It is also not being done with fresh saltwater but rather display water. But that being said I am also awaiting further instructions from the vet. But once it does drop I am then going to add more live rock as if I add it now it will die.

Fish excrete ammonia as a waste, especially from the gills. The amount of ammonia is at least partially based on fish mass. Even a fish that is not eating will produce ammonia. Porcupines are really massive fish for their length, so comparing a 6" porcupine to a 6" tang, the porc is going to be 3x as massive, with a corresponding higher ammonia output (I got this data from my fish mass data set).

This ammonia output is more or less continuous. In a small un-cycled tank, it is very common to see ammonia build at a rate of 1 ppm per day. If you do a 50% water change on such a tank, the next day the ammonia will be at 1.5 ppm (you diluted the first day's ammonia by 50%, but then in the next 24 hours, another 1 ppm of ammonia was excreted by the fish). If you do a second 50% water change, the ammonia will be 1.75 ppm, and so on. Even if you change 100% of the water daily, the ammonia will stay at 1 ppm

Hewbie is very massive, your ammonia build-up could be even faster.

"Cycled tank water" doesn't help - the beneficial ammonia removing bacteria lives on solid surfaces, not much in the water itself.
 
Sorry Jay pardon my ignorance and confusion. But as explained by the fish store and a marine biologist friend this was recommended. This doesn’t make any sense to me. Why would ammonia climb? You are diluting it and ultimate compensating “cycled” tank water and prime is aiding but not solving it. The goal is to get it as low as possible quickly without shocking the fish and moving him I will not be doing. I can tell you…ammonia did drop overnight and that he seems a lot better and is not puffed or gasping at the surface. My plan is to continue water changes but not as much now since I did get it lower. It is also not being done with fresh saltwater but rather display water. But that being said I am also awaiting further instructions from the vet. But once it does drop I am then going to add more live rock as if I add it now it will die.
And just a note on the topic of Prime as it too blindsided me when I first heard about the controversy here on R2R: Prime states that it binds ammonia into a non-toxic form for a number of hours. There is a growing consensus amongst professional scientists that this just isn't the case, and that whatever Prime does do is ultimately unhelpful one way or the other for the purpose of rendering the water safer for fish. The problem is, and the reason why it continues to persist as a thing so many of us have, is that it also doesn't hurt. So in times like these, you just do it anyway "just in case".

My only advice would be: Don't rely on Prime alone.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new