I dont think my hammer is happy

  • Thread starter Thread starter pirateian
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

pirateian

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 20, 2025
Messages
20
Reaction score
5
Location
NJ
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Last couple days half of my hammer coral seems retracted and i even think a couple polyps are gone now. All the rest of the tank seems fine and stable. I am wondering if it is a flow, temperature, or light issues? A pest? Now i haven’t seen anything out of the ordinary and i dipped everything but what might be a culprit? I noticed the tank has been using slightly more magnesium but i think that may be from coralline algae establishing.

Could this be some kind of chemical attack from a nearby coral? The affected side is about 4-5 inches away from a chalice and on the opposite unaffected side there is a torch about 6 inches away.
20251217_114757_6EFDF230-CB6F-4923-99D0-C4BB7B071CA0.png

20251217_114757_53888CBC-01CB-4225-B8FC-EC85F1825CEC.png

20251217_114758_1B086BAF-F396-4D4D-85DB-2B19839C7F64.png
 
The flesh band looks great but that smaller head for sure looks unhappy. The torch can't reach it right? Maybe a little too much flow or got damaged some how? Flesh band would be first to go if it were a "parasite" issue. Can you post a video to see flow?
 
I had a similar issue with a hammer, moved it around the corner (behind a rock structure) with less flow and a little less light, it not only recovery but extended even larger. It's still in that spot
 
The flesh band looks great but that smaller head for sure looks unhappy. The torch can't reach it right? Maybe a little too much flow or got damaged some how? Flesh band would be first to go if it were a "parasite" issue. Can you post a video to see flow?
View attachment 20251217_150349_3DE5B315-380B-47AA-AFC9-73FBA2E3D79B.mov
Maybe it is too close to the torch now that its fully extending. The unhappy side is near to the chalice though. I’m pretty new to the reefing so don’t kill me please lol
 

Maybe it is too close to the torch now that its fully extending. The unhappy side is near to the chalice though. I’m pretty new to the reefing so don’t kill me please lol
That flow may be a bit too harsh but not terrible. Chalices can extend sweepers as well, usually at night so look for that. If thats the torch in the front it should be fine at this time later you may have to give some more space. I watched the video again I dont think either torch or chalice are too close at this time.
 
I had a similar issue with a hammer, moved it around the corner (behind a rock structure) with less flow and a little less light, it not only recovery but extended even larger. It's still in that spot
I’m gonna try moving the wave maker first, came home from work and looks like even more polyps are just “gone”. I dont know any other way to describe it.
 
It definitely doesnt look very happy. What time in your light schedule was this pic taken? Heads close up sometimes as the lights wind down.
This picture was at night i popped the light back on just to check up about 40 minutes after the “sunset” started maybe 20 minutes after lights out
 

Maybe it is too close to the torch now that its fully extending. The unhappy side is near to the chalice though. I’m pretty new to the reefing so don’t kill me please lol
That flow may be a bit too harsh but not terrible. Chalices can extend sweepers as well, usually at night so look for that. If thats the torch in the front it should be fine at this time later you may have to give some more space. I watched the video again I dont think either torch or chalice are too close at this time.
I’m gonna hold off on moving it and just reposition and turn down the wave maker first
 
I’m gonna try moving the wave maker first, came home from work and looks like even more polyps are just “gone”. I dont know any other way to describe it.
One way to tell if a Euphyllia or the new...er classification fimbriaphyllia are over all healthy is the flesh band below the polyps. That looks healthy or did in the pic. I would guess its just ticked off and pulling the polyps in as long as that flesh band looks the same.
 
It definitely doesnt look very happy. What time in your light schedule was this pic taken? Heads close up sometimes as the lights wind down.
This picture was at night i popped the light back on just to check up about 40 minutes after the “sunset” started maybe 20 minutes after lights out
The reason I ask is because the flesh band looks good. How does it look during the day?
 
Last couple days half of my hammer coral seems retracted and i even think a couple polyps are gone now. All the rest of the tank seems fine and stable. I am wondering if it is a flow, temperature, or light issues? A pest? Now i haven’t seen anything out of the ordinary and i dipped everything but what might be a culprit? I noticed the tank has been using slightly more magnesium but i think that may be from coralline algae establishing.

Could this be some kind of chemical attack from a nearby coral? The affected side is about 4-5 inches away from a chalice and on the opposite unaffected side there is a torch about 6 inches away.
20251217_114757_6EFDF230-CB6F-4923-99D0-C4BB7B071CA0.png

20251217_114757_53888CBC-01CB-4225-B8FC-EC85F1825CEC.png

20251217_114758_1B086BAF-F396-4D4D-85DB-2B19839C7F64.png
Should i do a water change or holdiff at this point? Do you think this can recover?
 
You mentioned all other corals in the tank look good, so I personally wouldn't jump off schedule with a water change (unless it's the normal time you do it) because of the hammer. Other corals happy I doubt a water change will help with what's bothering the hammer. Start with reducing the flow a bit and see if that helps.
 
It definitely doesnt look very happy. What time in your light schedule was this pic taken? Heads close up sometimes as the lights wind down.
This picture was at night i popped the light back on just to check up about 40 minutes after the “sunset” started maybe 20 minutes after lights out
The reason I ask is because the flesh band looks good. How does it look during the day?
Hard to tell the last few days because i had a lot of overtime out of the norm but from the camera looks like little change during daytime
 
You mentioned all other corals in the tank look good, so I personally wouldn't jump off schedule with a water change (unless it's the normal time you do it) because of the hammer. Other corals happy I doubt a water change will help with what's bothering the hammer. Start with reducing the flow a bit and see if that helps.
It is my routine weekly water change
 
Should i do a water change or holdiff at this point? Do you think this can recover?
Have you tested water parameters? If so what are alk, nitrate, phosphate? If nitrate is below 10 I would not. IMO phosphates dont matter that much as long as its not near 0. I would worry more about the flow its in right now more than anything else. Thats assuming the retracted polyps have become more common.
 
This is my tank, i have moved the left wavemaker to the back hopeing that this will solve the problem if it was a flow issue. I have also turned both down. (Left and right alternating) Can i place the hammer anywhere else without over crowding and coral warfare?
20251217_165821_A9656430-616A-43C9-8A0F-46659182C5E2.png

From left to right and front to back:

1. Chalice
2. Hammer
3. Torch
4. Anacorapora
5. Gsp(back wall)
6. Zoa
7.Toadstool
8. Zoa
9. Pulsing Xenia
10. Baby Palythoa
 
Kind of hard to tell but I think its in a good spot now. I see in post 14 you said it looks normal during the day? Did I read/understand that right?
 
Kind of hard to tell but I think its in a good spot now. I see in post 14 you said it looks normal during the day? Did I read/understand that right?
It has been normal until the last 2 to 3 days, from all i can tell it looks like this 24/7 since then
 
Should i do a water change or holdiff at this point? Do you think this can recover?
Have you tested water parameters? If so what are alk, nitrate, phosphate? If nitrate is below 10 I would not. IMO phosphates dont matter that much as long as its not near 0. I would worry more about the flow its in right now more than anything else. Thats assuming the retracted polyps have become more common.
Going to test again now
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 4.5%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 13 59.1%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new