These were captive bred. That LFS does not breed, but they do QT (well, copper and low salinity fish tanks). I meant same source as in LFS, not breeder as you probably guessed.
Honestly, I am taking this as something of a sign of fate. What I mean is after much thought I decided I would go with ocellaris clowns that were not a natural match for our host anemone. I debated long and hard about a Clarkii style clown, but I worried he would get too large and aggressive for our tank.
I enjoyed these ocellaris in their short stay. They were beautiful fish and the classic orange one had a lot of character. That said, it bothered me more than I expected that they were an unnatural match.
If I do get another Clownfish, I will get what I always really wanted, a Spotcinctus (A. bicinctus). It would be a natural species for our Bubble Tip Anemone. It would be the last fish I would add, leaving us with three total. I think the size could work with only three. As far as aggression, Ruby is fast and good at hiding, so Skyler would be the main concern. Skyler’s rock hole home is on the other side of the tank from the anemone, so there is a good chance it would work. A Spotcinctus does tend to venture further from the anemone than the smaller species, but I have decided I want to try. I am going to monitor the other fish for a couple of weeks and see if they show any signs of weakness or disease and go from there.
What bugs me is that Nemo, the classic orange ocellaris, showed no signs at all of ill health. No marks, no poo issues, very active and eating well. I have to think something external to his body killed him. I considered that he may have choked on something large. I had a couple of fish in my lifetime that died from choking on large food pellets or live feeder fish, so that thought occurred to me. The only disease that would kill overnight seems to be velvet, but that would be visible (I am a novice to disease study though for sure). For the other Darwin ocellaris, his passing was not a surprise.
I have seen articles talking about fish and invertebrate trauma causing sickness or death weeks or months after the event even though the animals seem fine at time of purchase - for example cyanide poisoning (wild caught fish) and salinity shock (invertebrates)