Dry skimming produces less liquid in the bottom of the cup. People who run wet generally have a higher tank water/bubble interface level inside of the skimmer body, either by closing down the outflow or increasing the pump speed into the skimmer, or by increasing the water depth in the submerged skimmer, to name the three methods I have used and there are probably more. The "skimmate" tends to be clearer because the scum is more diluted with tank water when a skimmer runs wet.
Dry skimming tends to produce darker skimmate like what your skimmer is collecting in the cup.
I'm full of words this evening. I hope this is helpful? (Oh, and your skimmer does appear to be skimming nicely. I just emptied my cup and it was darker like yours.)