Yeah, they get a bad wrap, most of it just repeated from one person to the next. I think
@Dan_P and
@taricha did some extensive testing and showed the reagents to be rock solid. The printed cards were the weak link.
I agree that API test kits get a bad rap from many here on R2R for no reason. I think they are mostly fine, especially for cycling a tank.
I don't know if it's the color charts themselves, or just the act of matching the colors, which is frustrating for many. Some of the Salifert kits are titrations, which makes them much easier to read, and not much more expensive than API.