Just double-checking. My cycle is done right?

20261116_200237_F7C9FC7F-E713-4914-86EC-EF794C375ECC.png


20261116_200237_4F680B50-8A22-4DE3-9A2E-28641A45BB4E.png


20261116_200237_4C8D98A0-4FD3-4BBE-A113-42BE663C3C5D.png


20261116_200237_8DB7025E-A537-41DF-B2BC-84F3CDA4B2D4.png

As the title says, am I officially done? Also what do you think the nitrates read as? I’m unofficially colorblind and can’t tell if that’s 5ppm or 10ppm or 20ppm lol. I dosed 2ppm of ammonia’s worth of ammonium chloride if that helps.
Looks good to me too, and I'd put your nitrates at somewhere between 5 ppm and 10 ppm, which is nothing to worry about.

Good luck!
Okay perfect thats what should be the expected result with 2ppm of ammonia but I literally couldn’t differentiate the oranges lol. Thank you!
Used to have the same issue lol
 
Yeah, they get a bad wrap, most of it just repeated from one person to the next. I think @Dan_P and @taricha did some extensive testing and showed the reagents to be rock solid. The printed cards were the weak link.
I agree that API test kits get a bad rap from many here on R2R for no reason. I think they are mostly fine, especially for cycling a tank.

I don't know if it's the color charts themselves, or just the act of matching the colors, which is frustrating for many. Some of the Salifert kits are titrations, which makes them much easier to read, and not much more expensive than API.
 
Yeah, they get a bad wrap, most of it just repeated from one person to the next. I think @Dan_P and @taricha did some extensive testing and showed the reagents to be rock solid. The printed cards were the weak link.
I agree that API test kits get a bad rap from many here on R2R for no reason. I think they are mostly fine, especially for cycling a tank.

I don't know if it's the color charts themselves, or just the act of matching the colors, which is frustrating for many. Some of the Salifert kits are titrations, which makes them much easier to read, and not much more expensive than API.
I used api test kits a long while back for around a year to try them out/keep costs down with a new build and honestly the only problem I ever had was just reading them because some colors were close to others but other than that they’re accurate and at a decent price point
 
I could never feel confident with nitrates when it was my primary test kit. Always felt like +-30 🤣 Phosphate the lowest range is 0.25 if memory serves so it never felt right. Used Salifert for awhile after I retired the API which I always felt more confident in. Splurged on a Hanna Alk and think it was worth it, but Salifert I always felt was a good balance of accuracy in reading and cost. You should always do what your budget allows though.
 
I agree that API test kits get a bad rap from many here on R2R for no reason. I think they are mostly fine, especially for cycling a tank.

I don't know if it's the color charts themselves, or just the act of matching the colors, which is frustrating for many. Some of the Salifert kits are titrations, which makes them much easier to read, and not much more expensive than API.
I struggle with those to, the endpoint color is often not succinct.
 
Yeah, they get a bad wrap, most of it just repeated from one person to the next. I think @Dan_P and @taricha did some extensive testing and showed the reagents to be rock solid. The printed cards were the weak link.
The API test reagents are concentrated to give good color response over a large range. That is API’s strong suit.

API test colors are a bit ambiguous at the low end of the range, the ammonia test being the most notofious. When the tests are reformulated to use much less reagent, that is give paler colors that are measured in a photometer like the Hanna Checker, the performance of the modified API test is comparable to every other test kit. The one exception to this observation was the phosphate test which gave me nonsensical results, which I attributed to reagent quality (I could also have screwed up the test chemistry with a bad dilution reformulation).

Reagent consistency is poorer for API reagents which is only noticed for the dilution reformulated versions that use a photometer to measure color intensity. My solution for this was to blend several lots of reagents and calibrate the mixture. This gives hundreds of cheap tests.
 
The API test reagents are concentrated to give good color response over a large range. That is API’s strong suit.

API test colors are a bit ambiguous at the low end of the range, the ammonia test being the most notofious. When the tests are reformulated to use much less reagent, that is give paler colors that are measured in a photometer like the Hanna Checker, the performance of the modified API test is comparable to every other test kit. The one exception to this observation was the phosphate test which gave me nonsensical results, which I attributed to reagent quality (I could also have screwed up the test chemistry with a bad dilution reformulation).

Reagent consistency is poorer for API reagents which is only noticed for the dilution reformulated versions that use a photometer to measure color intensity. My solution for this was to blend several lots of reagents and calibrate the mixture. This gives hundreds of cheap tests.
Thank you for the information and the correction.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 2.9%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 4 11.8%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 25 73.5%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 4 11.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new