Large daily PO4 swings

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ziggy17
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
I knew something would pop up.

Besides the skimmer (and water changes?) are you doing anything else to clean or filter the tank?

Like you said, dose up now.

But getting to the root of why you're seeing PO4 drawn down to zero every day is almost just as important.

Sometimes it's excess filtration, but it happens.

What's your read on why it's so low persistently?
I had increased the lights to see if the torches would like it better, but started to get excess algae which I presume now is what was consuming the PO4 and not the NO3. I turned the lights back down to 40% to keep the algae from exploding. But at the time I was seeing the spikes i backed off any dosing of PO4 just in case the high number was correct. But I’m thinking it was sitting at zero for a week.
 
What frozen food are you using to spike it that much? Would be curious to know.

You would expect it a bit in a small tank, but not when your over 100 Gal!
 
What frozen food are you using to spike it that much? Would be curious to know.

You would expect it a bit in a small tank, but not when you’re over 100 Gal!
PE frozen mysis
Sally’s frozen brine
1 sheet noori
Ever other day a small pinch of Vitalis pellets

I don’t rinse the frozen food prior to it going in the tank either.
 
I wonder how many other people's test readings are misleading because of something like this.

I tend to take samples from the DT since I don't want inaccurate readings from dosing and ATO (which go into the sump), but now I'm not so sure.
 
I wonder how many other people's test readings are misleading because of something like this.

I tend to take samples from the DT since I don't want inaccurate readings from dosing and ATO (which go into the sump), but now I'm not so sure.
I almost always take it from the chamber after the roller mat, and my doses feeds into the return chamber. So in theory , I perceive I’m a taking a sample as far away from the dose as possible.

But I got a new lid with a feed door that now makes it super easy to take samples from the DT. I’ve since moved back to the sump for samples.
 
I almost always take it from the chamber after the roller mat, and my doses feeds into the return chamber. So in theory , I perceive I’m a taking a sample as far away from the dose as possible.

But I got a new lid with a feed door that now makes it super easy to take samples from the DT. I’ve since moved back to the sump for samples.
The question about where to take sample can be answered by sampling both placees at once and comparing the results. We don’t have to deal with this like Aristotle and think through this, just let the data guide you.
 
Here we go again. Was .08 yesterday and the day before and this morning was .69. Took the test from the sump on the first one and then checked it again from the DT and it was .68. Nothing dead in the tank. what the heck is causing these spikes…..?
 
Here we go again. Was .08 yesterday and the day before and this morning was .69. Took the test from the sump on the first one and then checked it again from the DT and it was .68. Nothing dead in the tank. what the heck is causing these spikes…..?
Did the two samples look very different in color after the 3 minute countdown?

How are you taking the samples? Fellow reefer recently had a crazy PO4 swing. Turned out he used the same syringe to take a sample that he used to dose some food with on a previous day.

So even a tiny bit of food in the sample can cause quite a swing apparently.
 
Did the two samples look very different in color after the 3 minute countdown?

How are you taking the samples? Fellow reefer recently had a crazy PO4 swing. Turned out he used the same syringe to take a sample that he used to dose some food with on a previous day.

So even a tiny bit of food in the sample can cause quite a swing apparently.
Colour was blue. I knew it was going to be a high reading as I was shaking it up. Not using a syringe to draw up. I use the same pipette that’s only used for testing. The retest was dipping the vial straight in the water and no pipette. Same result.
 
Last edited:
Colour was blue. I knew it was going to be a high reading as I was shaking it up. Not using a syringe to draw up. I use the same pipette that’s only used for testing. The retest was dipping the vial straight in the water and no pipette. Same result.
So sounds like the reagents and tester are working correctly then.

The tank one was really high? I think you must be getting something in the water column, into the sample, that is spiking the test. Maybe take a pint of water out from the DT and test and then let it sit for an hour or two to settle, sample near the top, and test again?
 
When I cared about phoshphate I was testing several times a day and noticed that there is often a lag in phosphate rise and feeding, so if you feed at night, it takes a bit for the phosphte to become liberated for the test to pick up.

Maybe
 
Colour was blue. I knew it was going to be a high reading as I was shaking it up. Not using a syringe to draw up. I use the same pipette that’s only used for testing. The retest was dipping the vial straight in the water and no pipette. Same result.
So sounds like the reagents and tester are working correctly then.

The tank one was really high? I think you must be getting something in the water column, into the sample, that is spiking the test. Maybe take a pint of water out from the DT and test and then let it sit for an hour or two to settle, sample near the top, and test again?
Tank and sump were both identical. Doubtful particulate will be present post roller mat.
 
When I cared about phoshphate I was testing several times a day and noticed that there is often a lag in phosphate rise and feeding, so if you feed at night, it takes a bit for the phosphte to become liberated for the test to pick up.

Maybe
last feed was 15 hours prior to this morning’s test, so that rules that out.
 
Ok, so I decided to check my ATO water to see if I’m pumping PO4 into the tank. Turns out I am. Phosphate reading of .12 in the fresh water, so every time my ATO engages, it’s pumping phospate in there. Which makes sense as last night I was drip acclimating inverts and probably removed 1 or 2 litres of water that was replaced with ATO.

Could that be the true culprit? Is it accumulative or would it stay at .12 no matter how much ATO you pumped in? @Randy Holmes-Farley
 
Tank and sump were both identical. Doubtful particulate will be present post roller mat.
I’m confused. You said sump for two days .08 and then DT .69. But now you are saying they are the same? You’re also saying the one was very dark blue and the others were barely noticeable blue?

How about a large sample from the DT and run 2 or 3 tests back to back so you can rule out reagent/tester/user error?
 
I’m confused. You said sump for two days .08 and then DT .69. But now you are saying they are the same? You’re also saying the one was very dark blue and the others were barely noticeable blue?

How about a large sample from the DT and run 2 or 3 tests back to back so you can rule out reagent/tester/user error?
Yes, you’re confused.
 
Ok, so I decided to check my ATO water to see if I’m pumping PO4 into the tank. Turns out I am. Phosphate reading of .12 in the fresh water, so every time my ATO engages, it’s pumping phospate in there. Which makes sense as last night I was drip acclimating inverts and probably removed 1 or 2 litres of water that was replaced with ATO.

Could that be the true culprit? Is it accumulative or would it stay at .12 no matter how much ATO you pumped in? @Randy Holmes-Farley
I’m gonna say no
The amount of PO4 in top off water vs the total volume of the system is tiny. Also no way you can get to .69ppm if your top up water has .12ppm
 
Ok, so I decided to check my ATO water to see if I’m pumping PO4 into the tank. Turns out I am. Phosphate reading of .12 in the fresh water, so every time my ATO engages, it’s pumping phospate in there. Which makes sense as last night I was drip acclimating inverts and probably removed 1 or 2 litres of water that was replaced with ATO.

Could that be the true culprit? Is it accumulative or would it stay at .12 no matter how much ATO you pumped in? @Randy Holmes-Farley
I’m gonna say no
The amount of PO4 in top off water vs the total volume of the system is tiny. Also no way you can get to .69ppm if your top up water has .12ppm
It has to be something. I’ve eliminated sample contamination, duration after feeding, sample location, tester batteries, reagent error. So it’s coming from some place and no way food is popping it that high in 15 hours.
 
If it were me.. at this point I think I would need to confirm my readings. I would first do at least 3 tests from a single large sample to see if the Hanna gives results all within the correct margin of error. Could it still be a reagent problem? Possibly

I would also be looking at a different test kit to confirm the Hanna results. Or maybe a LFS if they have good equipment to test with.

Hope you figure it out. I don’t really think the tank water is swinging that much in a day all on its own.

Certainly maddening!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 25 25.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 9.1%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 39 39.4%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 24 24.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new