Let me run something by everybody

  • Thread starter Thread starter BHAMR6
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

BHAMR6

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 28, 2009
Messages
510
Reaction score
0
Location
Kimberly , Al
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Most of you in here have seen my tank or atleast heard stories of how OCD I am w/th tank cleanings with that said I have started having a issue that I have never had to deal w/th.
Just in case you dont know I have a 65g SPS tank that has been running 3yrs I do 30g water changes every 2-3 weeks I use the same reef crystals salt everytime I have a RO/DI that all my water comes from and i clean all pumps and skimmer everytime I clean. So my point was to let you know the tank and equipment is as clean as you can get it.

My problem is about 2mos ago I started noticing dime size places of what looks like cyano dark red/purple in color and could be blown off the rock. Now I have a handfull of it around the tank and I cant seem to get rid of it no matter what I do.

Here are my ideas of what might be going on and let me know what everybody thinks...
1.I started putting aptasia x in the tank to kill off unwanted xenia (this started about the same time)
2. RO/DI filters are bad about a yr old (TDS test zero)
3. SPS have started growing into each other and causing some die off
4. I put new bulbs ( dont see what that would matter )

I have tested the water with fresh made up salt and nitrates 0 phosephates 0 my tank water same thing nitrate 0 phos 0

I'm lost w/th this stuff never dealt w/th it before so any ideas would be good
 
Turning your lights off for 3-4 days in a row can kill it, but your SPS would probably get peed off.
I had a major break out in my 20H a while back and my dad has had his fair share of it in his 75g. We use Red Slime Remover by Chemi-Clean. The stuff works amazing. Got rid of mine in about 3 days, every last bit of it. You have to put it in a high flow area, or something like that, can't remember exactly, so if you do use it, read the directions very carefully.
GL
515826.jpg
 
My thing is not how to remove it but what could be causing it I dont want to make it sound like a outbreak it started out 1 or 2 dime size spots of it but now there is about 5 to 8 spots of it scattered through the tank if I didnt point it out most people wouldnt even notice it.. I'm just baffled because other then the things I posted I have not changed anything so it seems that i would have to be adding the fuel for this to grow somehow.. Makes me wonder if killing off all this xenia isn't causing to much die off in the tank???? I'm trying not to treat it w/th a chemical just find the cause...
 
I would say it was killing the Xenia if that's the only thing you've change don't use chemi clean I've seen to many tanks crash from it the best way I've got rid of it add extra powerheads in the direction it's growing and do daily 5-10 percent water changes suck the slime off with the siphon hose each water change usually this gets it cleaned up after a week or week and a half !
 
Oh also question do you frequently stir your sand bed? If not get a baster and fill it with water and squirt it into the sand bed to get out absorbed detritus before you do the water change! This may also be fueling your cyano!
 
First thing i notice is you say your DI filter is a year old but TDS still reads zero. I produce about 60-70 gallons of RO/DI a month and that burns through 2 DI canisters in about 3 months. I would look at your TDS meter could be out of calibration and your DI likely need replaced.
 
+1 on Yerboy.I go through alot of filters reguardless of the TDS meter reading.I actually rarely chk the reading.I have not ever had an issue with the Chemiclean if used properly.Knowing you Paul you will follow directions to the T where most of those who have had issues with this product do not.I agree the die off is creating excess nutrients which dont show in your test which cause the cyano outbreak.I have had it pop up after a killing off of majios,aptasia's and xenia.Just my thoughts.Hope everyone is having fun with the snow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I Had a problem like this a few months ago with the cyano, not killing off xenia. I have noticed that when my sps grow into each other I will get a small patch of cyano but it goes away in a day or two. But when I was having an out break I just blacked out the tank for 3 full days. TOTALLY blacked out. I covered the whole tank with thick blankets and turned off all the light timers. Not even moonlights stayed on. After 3 days I gradually got the lights back on schedule, ie. atinics only the first day then atinics followed by 3 hours of halide the next day and so on for about a week. Since then no more cyano other than what I described about where the sps grow together. but that doesn't hang around. Good luck.
 
@Oiseau reefer- I dont have but a small layer of sand in the tank which is taken out and cleaned every time the tank is cleaned.. As for as flow I have noticed that all my spots are under ledges are under colonies where the water flow isnt very strong.

@ Yerboy - That makes sense w/th the filters that was my first thought thats why i check the nitrates and phose w/th fresh made water. Do you think they could test 0 on that but still be bad enough to cause this???

@ Jason- Thats why i posted in here because I figured people like you would know how anal I am w/th the tank ..Lol.. See I killed off several hairy mushrooms some button polyps and a baseball size patch of xenia all at the same time. And you know now every 3 wks when i clean i have to always kill off some that didnt die the first time never ending story w/th coral you dont want you.. Add that to the colonies that are fighting each other and you have a lot of die off going on

@ Dave- I used to just keep fragged so they didnt grow into each other but now you cant keep up so i just let them fight it out and always the losers has cyano on it

After thinking about it i think it is a combo of me killing off coral ,coral killing each other and old filters in my ro/di
 
@ Yerboy - That makes sense w/th the filters that was my first thought thats why i check the nitrates and phose w/th fresh made water. Do you think they could test 0 on that but still be bad enough to cause this???

It's really hard to say what all you could be introducing in your tank other then Nitrate and phos. You may have posted this already but is there any ammonia or nitrite in the fresh made water that could be breaking down?
 
the cyano is feeding off the bioload in your tank which is vastly more and completely swamps out other sources of nitrates/phosphates and whatever.

After some time the tank can become "nitrate" starved and cyano can use nitrogen gas in the water vrs nitrates for its nitrogen.

So if there is lights for the cyano it blooms.

but killing the lights will allow the cyano to die off return nitrates to feed the corraline (and other) algaes, corals and so on.

my .02
 
Don't make it any harder than it needs to be.

STOP putting chemicals in your water.

Do a complete blackout for three days while your skimmer is adjusted a little to the wet side. On the forth day turn the actinics on. Next day turn all the lights on as usual. Your corals will be fine.

You may have to repeat this a week or 10 days later.

Cyano is not hard to get rid of when you eliminate the "fuel source" through aggressive skimming (and not do anything else to contribute to it like killing xenia) and eliminate the "power source" by the blackout.

It's actually so simple most people won't even try it. :pudency:
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new